We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-05 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want replacement ear pads that cover the widest spread of Skullcandy models — Crusher, Hesh and Venue alike — choose Duyfioa Replacement Ear Pads; if you need memory foam cushions purpose-shaped for the H390, H600 or H609, choose Wolegdou Replacement Ear Pads. Neither of these is a pair of wireless earbuds for running, and that matters more than most buyers realise: these are cushion kits for headphones you already own.
• Duyfioa's biggest strength: model coverage. One set is listed as compatible with Crusher Wireless, Crusher ANC, Crusher Evo, Crusher 360, Hesh 3, Hesh Evo, Hesh ANC and Venue ANC.
• Duyfioa's biggest trade-off: you have to verify your exact headphone model before ordering, because that long compatibility list is also a long list of ways to buy the wrong pad.
• Wolegdou's biggest strength: the cushion itself — thick slow-rebound memory foam wrapped in protein leather, with a breathable surface designed to cut heat and sweat.
• Wolegdou's biggest trade-off: narrow fit. It is shaped for the H390, H600 and H609 only, and there is no stated manufacturer warranty.
• Buy Duyfioa if your Skullcandy Crusher or Hesh pads have flattened and you want the originals back.
• Buy Wolegdou if you own an H-series headset and want a plusher, cooler-feeling cushion for long sessions.
Duyfioa's pitch is breadth. The listed fit covers the Crusher family (Wireless, ANC, Evo, 360), the Hesh family (3, Evo, ANC) and the Venue ANC — a genuinely wide net for one set of pads. The set is black, the enclosure material is leather, and each pad measures roughly 2.75 x 0.79 x 3.54 inches. A one-year manufacturer warranty is stated, which is more than many repair-part listings offer.
The design story is about sealing, not just looks. Duyfioa says the cushions fit tightly so they don't leak sound or degrade noise cancelling, and describes the foam as soft enough not to press on the ears over long use. That's the whole point of a replacement pad: a worn, flattened cushion breaks the seal, and a broken seal is what quietly ruins bass and ANC on a Crusher or Hesh. Installation is tool-free — peel the old pad off with your fingers, tuck the rubber edge into the groove around the cup, rotate to seat it. No glue, no tweezers.
Who should buy it: anyone with a Crusher, Hesh or Venue whose pads have gone shiny, cracked or flat, and who wants the headphone to look and sound like itself again. Who should skip it: anyone with an H390, H600 or H609, or any model not named in the compatibility list — check your model first, because "close enough" doesn't exist for a snap-in cushion. Also skip it if you specifically want memory foam; Duyfioa's sheet describes foam sponge, not slow-rebound memory foam.
Wolegdou goes the other way: one narrow target, done properly. These pads are moulded for the H390, H600 and H609, and the fit is described as precise and gap-free, snapping into place rather than being stretched on. Each pad is about 67 x 67 x 15 mm — noticeably thick, which is where the comfort claim comes from. You get one pair, two pieces, in black.
The material spec is the interesting part. Thick slow-rebound memory foam conforms to the ear and spreads pressure instead of concentrating it, and the protein leather outer layer is described as staying cool and gentle against skin, minimising sweat and irritation. If you wear a headset through a full workday, a long gaming session or hours of calls, that combination — thickness plus a breathable surface — is exactly what stops the "hot ear, sore ear" problem that makes people rip their headphones off at hour three.
Installation is described as a peel-and-press swap: old cushions off, new ones pressed on in seconds, no screws or special skills. Wolegdou also frames these as a restoration part — replacing worn, flattened pads brings back the noise isolation and the full sound the headset was built around. One caveat worth knowing up front: the sheet lists no warranty.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Own a Skullcandy Crusher, Hesh or Venue → Duyfioa Replacement Ear Pads. That's the model list, full stop.
• Own an H390, H600 or H609 → Wolegdou Replacement Ear Pads. The Duyfioa set won't fit these.
• Want memory foam → Wolegdou. Slow-rebound foam is spelled out in its spec; Duyfioa specifies foam sponge.
• Want the widest model coverage from one purchase → Duyfioa. Eight-plus Skullcandy models versus three H-series models.
• Want the plushest, thickest cushion for marathon sessions → Wolegdou. 15 mm thickness plus a breathable protein leather surface.
• Want a stated warranty → Duyfioa. One year from the manufacturer; Wolegdou lists none.
• Want the simplest install → either. Both are tool-free finger swaps; neither needs glue, screws or tweezers.
• Care most about seal and noise cancelling → Duyfioa. Its design notes specifically target a tight, leak-free fit that protects ANC performance.
For running, neither of these is the product you want — no ear pad is. If you're chasing wireless earbuds for running, or the best multipoint headphones for running, buy those instead and come back here when your over-ears need refreshing. Between these two, I'd buy Duyfioa if I owned a Skullcandy Crusher or Hesh, purely because it's the one that fits; I'd buy Wolegdou if I owned an H390, H600 or H609 and wanted the memory foam upgrade. In my opinion the deciding factor is your headphone model, not the pads — match that first, then choose. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, and confirm your model number either way.
Yes — both are named in the compatibility list, along with Crusher Wireless, Crusher ANC, Crusher 360, Hesh 3, Hesh Evo and Venue ANC. Confirm your exact model before ordering.
No. They're shaped for the H390, H600 and H609 only. If you own a Skullcandy Crusher or Hesh, the Duyfioa set is the one to look at.
Wolegdou's spec is more comfort-focused: thick slow-rebound memory foam plus a breathable protein leather surface meant to reduce heat and sweat. Duyfioa leans on softness and a tight, non-pressing fit.
No. Both are tool-free: Duyfioa's pads tuck into the groove around the cup by hand, and Wolegdou's press straight on. No glue, screws or special skills required.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: QXUFV Earbuds vs Monster Active Noise Cancelling, Clooissr 32GB vs J-TREK BH03: Cycling Headphones, COCONISE Gaming Microphone vs ZealSound Microphone, AblePlanet Headset vs OnStage On-Stage AA3500: Durable Wired