How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• DSMY Air Fryer Disposable — biggest strength: 200 square sheets in one pack, 8 x 8 inches, heat resistant up to 480°F, made from food-grade wood pulp with a non-stick coating.
• DSMY Air Fryer Disposable — biggest trade-off: it's a single-format product. Square liners only — no cups, no pre-cut holes, and you adjust them yourself to fit your basket.
• Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment — biggest strength: a two-part bundle. Fifty pre-cut 9-inch unbleached liners with holes for air circulation, plus ten 8 fl oz aluminum cups for wet and messy foods.
• Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment — biggest trade-off: lower heat ceiling at 400°F on the air fryer setting, and far fewer liners in the pack — 50 versus 200.
• Pick DSMY Air Fryer Disposable if you cook air-fryer meals constantly and want a deep supply of one liner size that fits a 5–8 quart square basket.
• Pick Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment if you want liners that are already cut to shape plus cups that let you cook egg bites, muffins, dips and mac and cheese in the basket.
The DSMY liners are a volume play. You get 200 sheets, each 8 x 8 inches square, cut from food-grade wood pulp and finished with a non-stick coating that's also oil-proof and waterproof. The stated heat resistance goes up to 480°F, and the pleated corners are designed to keep the paper from curling up when the basket gets hot. If your air fryer is in the 5 to 8 quart range — the listing calls out Ninja, PowerXL, Gourmia, Instant Pot and Cosori among others — an 8-inch square drops straight into the basket without trimming in most cases. If it doesn't, the paper is meant to be adjusted by hand.
What I like about the design is the square shape. Round liners in a square basket leave four dead corners where grease and crumbs collect. A square sheet covers more of the floor, and since it's non-stick, lifting out sticky food — glazed wings, marinated chicken, cheese-crusted anything — is a one-hand job instead of a soak-and-scrub job.
The versatility is broader than the name suggests. The sheets are microwave and oven safe and don't need pre-heating, so they work under baking sheets, on pizza pans, in cake pans and muffin tins, and for roasting, grilling and steaming as well as air frying. That matters if you'd rather buy one liner and use it everywhere.
Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment: Who It's For
Reynolds approaches the same problem from a different angle: instead of one big pack of one shape, you get a bundle of two different tools. Fifty unbleached parchment liners, 9 inches across, pre-cut to fit round and square baskets with no cutting required. And ten 8 fl oz aluminum air fryer cups, each measuring 3.85 inches by 2.45 inches — roughly individual-portion size.
The pre-cut holes in the liners are the detail I'd point a buyer toward. Air fryers work by moving hot air around the food, and a solid sheet of paper blocks the bottom of the basket. Holes let air circulate underneath, which helps the underside of fries, tenders and wings actually crisp instead of steaming in their own moisture. That's a genuine functional difference from a plain flat liner.
The cups are the other half of the story, and they're the part DSMY simply doesn't offer. Because they're made from sturdy aluminum foil and are safe in air fryers, ovens and grills, they hold things a flat liner can't: egg bites, muffins, dips, individual mac and cheese portions. That's the "food you never thought possible in an air fryer" angle, and it's fair — those are exactly the dishes that either leak through parchment or need a rigid vessel to hold their shape. They also let you cook two different things at once in one basket, side by side.
Where it gives ground: the heat ceiling is 400°F on the air fryer setting, which is lower than DSMY's stated 480°F. If you routinely push your air fryer to its top temperature for crisping, that's a real constraint to plan around. And the count is 50 liners plus 10 cups, versus 200 sheets — this is a smaller supply meant to be replenished more often. The unbleached paper is a deliberate choice for people who'd rather not use a bleached liner, and the cleanup story is the same either way: cook, lift, toss.
Who should skip it: high-volume cooks who'd burn through 50 liners in a few weeks and don't care about cups, and anyone who needs the higher heat tolerance.
• Best for sheer quantity → DSMY Air Fryer Disposable. 200 sheets in one pack versus 50 liners plus 10 cups.
• Best for cooking saucy, wet, or batter-based food → Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment. Only Reynolds gives you a rigid foil cup to hold it.
• Best for maximum heat tolerance → DSMY Air Fryer Disposable. Up to 480°F versus Reynolds' 400°F air fryer limit.
• Best for crispy undersides → Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment. The pre-cut holes are built specifically to let air circulate under the food.
• Best for square 5–8 quart baskets → DSMY Air Fryer Disposable. The 8 x 8 inch square covers the floor with no trimming in most cases.
• Best for round or square baskets without cutting → Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment. The 9-inch liners are pre-cut for both.
• Best for baking, roasting and microwave use beyond the air fryer → DSMY Air Fryer Disposable. The sheets are microwave and oven safe and sized for baking sheets, pizza pans and cake pans.
• Best for portion control and variety in one basket → Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment. The 8 fl oz cups are individual-portion sized, so you can run two different dishes at once.
In my opinion, the right answer comes down to how you actually cook. If your air fryer is a daily workhorse and you mostly do wings, fries, chicken and roasted vegetables, I'd buy the DSMY Air Fryer Disposable — 200 square sheets, a higher heat ceiling, and a shape that matches a 5–8 quart basket properly. If you want your air fryer to do more than reheat and crisp — egg bites, muffins, dips, single-serve mac and cheese — I'd buy Reynolds Kitchens Unbleached Parchment instead, because the foil cups open up a category of food a flat liner can never hold, and the pre-cut holes are a smarter design for crispiness. My honest pick for a general-purpose kitchen: DSMY on volume and heat tolerance, Reynolds on versatility.
It depends on what you're counting. DSMY gives you 200 sheets in one pack; Reynolds gives you 50 liners plus 10 aluminum cups. On liner count alone, DSMY is the bigger supply. On what you can cook, Reynolds covers more ground because of the cups. Check the current price on Amazon for both and compare cost per liner against how often you'd actually use the cups.
No. They're 9-inch pre-cut liners designed to fit round and square air fryer baskets without any cutting. They also have pre-cut holes to let air circulate during cooking. DSMY's 8-inch square sheets are meant to be adjusted by hand if your basket runs smaller or larger.
DSMY states heat resistance up to 480°F. Reynolds Kitchens Air Fryer Liners are rated safe up to 400°F on the air fryer setting. If you cook at the top end of your air fryer's range, that gap is worth factoring in.
Yes, both. The DSMY sheets are microwave and oven safe and work for baking, roasting, grilling and steaming — including baking sheets, pizza pans and cake pans. The Reynolds cups are safe in air fryers, ovens and grills, which makes them useful for muffins, egg bites and dips.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.