The cost to upgrade diamond engagement rings with James Allen would be to spend twice as much as your original purchase plus some shipping costs (probably less than $100) for sending back your ring. James Allen should be able to send you a return label from Fedex to help you securely send your old ring back. Get in touch with them when you are ready to upgrade.
You can return the engagement ring to the original jewelry shop if you have discussed the return policy. Some jewelry shops accept a full refund for non-personalized engagement rings. It is rare to find a jewelry shop that accepts a full refund. The return option is the quickest way to exchange the ring for your money back. Most of the time, though, the engagement ring value is halved once you walk out of the jewelry shop with it. Regardless if your partner wore the ring or not, jewelry shops will consider it as a used one. Therefore, before buying the engagement ring from a jewelry store, please learn about their refunding policy.
Zales Lifetime Diamond Commitment limited warranty applies to all diamond rings, diamond earrings, diamond bracelets and diamond necklaces. This Lifetime Diamond Commitment does not cover previously owned diamond jewelry, nor does it cover theft, mysterious disappearance, loss or damage other than that incurred in normal wear, and only diamonds in their original settings that have been inspected and repaired by Zales are covered by this limited warranty. Proof of purchase is required on items being returned or exchanged and on trade-ins. Net purchase price refers to final price actually paid, excluding tax. This limited warranty does not cover colored gemstone jewelry or watches. Repair charges necessary to properly secure a diamond in its mounting can be covered under Zales' optional Lifetime Protection Plan.
Another downside is that some setting styles aren't offered. For example, you may be out of luck if you're looking for a bezel or tension ring. It also doesn't have as many choices for yellow gold or rose gold rings.
Are Costco diamonds a good deal?
Costco offers reasonable prices compared to traditional brick-and-mortar jewelers. However, all rings are pre-set and you cannot customize at all. And not all diamonds have a GIA grading report. Online jewelers like James Allen have cheaper prices and allow you to design your own ring. Costco also does not offer any after-purchase care, like resizing or cleaning.
In most states where engagement rings are considered conditional gifts, the recipient remains the owner of the ring only if the condition of marriage is met. In most cases, the ring goes back to the purchaser if the couple breaks up.
A fault-based approach to determining the answer to this question states that the person who broke the engagement shouldn't be allowed to keep the engagement ring. Thus, the person at fault, or the person who broke the engagement, has to give the ring back to the other person. If the state and court use a fault-based approach, the giver is not entitled to get the ring back if they were the one who ended the relationship, even if the state also uses a conditional gift approach to engagement rings.
A no-fault approach states that it doesn't matter who broke the engagement. In these cases, the giver gets the ring back, regardless of who ended the engagement. Typically, the only states where a no-fault approach does not lead to the giver getting the ring back is if the ring was considered an unconditional gift.
Ring Reinvention: When the brothers saw a multitude of mall jewelry stores crop up, they decided to take their family-owned William Pitt Jewelers out of the malls, change their image and become Robbins Bros., focusing exclusively on engagement rings. Their first free-standing store opened in 1995. "There was no going back," recalls Steve. "We had to convince the bank and vendors. Everyone thought we were crazy."
 38c6e68cf9