When buying a used car in New Zealand, one of the first financial decisions is whether to arrange a loan through a bank or use finance arranged by the dealership.
It is tempting to reduce the decision to one question: Which has the lower interest rate?
That is important, but it is not enough.
The interest rate is only one part of the cost of borrowing. Fees, loan term, repayment frequency, early repayment conditions, deposit, add-on products and the total amount payable can all affect which option makes more sense.
Consumer Protection recommends shopping around for finance and comparing the overall cost rather than simply accepting the first loan offered.
There is no universal rule that bank finance is always better than dealer finance.
A bank may offer a competitive rate or greater flexibility for a particular borrower. Dealer-arranged finance may be convenient because the vehicle purchase and finance application can be handled together, and the dealer may have access to more than one lending option.
The right comparison is the actual loan being offered to you.
Before signing, compare:
Interest rate
Establishment and other fees
Loan term
Repayment amount and frequency
Total amount payable
Deposit requirements
Early repayment or extra-payment rules
Any financed insurance or other add-ons
What happens if your circumstances change
New Zealand's responsible lending rules also require lenders to assess whether credit is suitable and affordable for the borrower.
Arranging a loan directly with a bank or other lender gives you an opportunity to establish your borrowing position before you start negotiating over a vehicle.
That can be useful because you know approximately how much you can borrow and can compare the vehicle price against a finance limit you have already considered.
There may also be flexibility around repayments depending on the particular loan.
Consumer Protection notes that bank or lending-institution finance may give borrowers more control over how much and how quickly they repay, depending on the contract. It also recommends shopping around for the lowest available interest rate before choosing a lender.
However, a bank loan is not automatically the cheapest option.
The rate available to you can depend on the lender, your circumstances, the loan and the terms offered. The only useful comparison is the actual offer you receive.
Dealer finance can be attractive because the finance process can happen alongside the vehicle purchase.
Instead of arranging a loan separately and then returning to the dealership, a dealer may help submit your application to a lender.
That does not mean the dealership itself is necessarily the lender.
For example, AJ Motors states that its finance application service helps applicants apply through its network of lenders, while the lenders receiving an application make the lending decisions based on their own credit, suitability and affordability criteria.
AJ Motors also says its finance service operates across its branches and provides examples showing the deposit, term, interest rate and total amount payable for advertised finance calculations. The company notes that different lenders can have different terms and fees.
That is an important distinction for buyers: compare the lender's actual terms, not simply the fact that the application came through a dealer.
A loan with a lower advertised interest rate can still have costs that affect the overall price.
Consumer Protection says borrowers should receive disclosure showing the total cost of the loan, repayments, interest and other fees before signing a consumer credit contract.
Suppose two loans are available for the same vehicle.
Loan A has a lower interest rate but higher fees and a longer term.
Loan B has a slightly higher rate but lower fees and a shorter term.
Looking only at the interest-rate percentage could make Loan A appear better.
Looking at the total amount payable could produce a different conclusion.
This is why the weekly repayment should never be the only figure you compare.
A longer loan term can reduce the scheduled repayment, which may make a vehicle appear more affordable each week.
But extending the term can also mean paying interest for longer.
Before agreeing to a repayment amount, work backwards from the total cost.
Ask:
How much am I borrowing?
How long will I be paying it back?
What is the total amount I will repay?
Can I make additional repayments?
Are there costs or restrictions if I repay early?
Consumer Protection specifically recommends using a debt calculator to understand the true cost of financing a vehicle, including interest and fees.
A deposit reduces the amount you need to borrow, but that does not automatically mean putting down the largest possible deposit is the right decision.
You need to consider your cash reserves as well.
Using most of your available savings for a deposit could leave little money for registration, insurance, servicing, tyres or unexpected repairs.
On the other hand, borrowing more than necessary can increase the total cost of the loan.
The sensible deposit depends on the vehicle price, loan terms and your wider financial position.
If you are looking at trade in cars options while buying another vehicle, make sure you separate the trade-in value from the finance calculation.
For example, consider a vehicle advertised at $25,000 with a $7,000 trade-in.
You may need to finance less than you would without the trade-in, but the important figures are still the purchase price, trade-in value, any outstanding finance on your existing vehicle, deposit and final amount borrowed.
Do not judge a deal simply because the dealer has offered a high trade-in figure.
Compare the complete transaction.
Consumer Protection specifically advises buyers to consider trade-in offers carefully alongside the value of any additional products.
One practical mistake is choosing the vehicle first and thinking about borrowing afterwards.
If you know you will need finance, establish a realistic budget before becoming committed to a particular vehicle.
Consumer Protection recommends working out how much you want to spend before going to a dealership and, where possible, obtaining loan pre-approval beforehand.
This is especially useful when comparing finance cars because it prevents the repayment figure from becoming the main focus.
A vehicle that fits comfortably within your budget is more important than stretching the loan simply because a longer term produces a manageable weekly payment.
The same principles apply whether you are looking at car dealers Wellington buyers use or comparing dealerships elsewhere in New Zealand.
Do not compare dealerships only by the sticker price.
Compare:
Vehicle price
Trade-in value, if applicable
Deposit
Interest rate
Establishment and ongoing fees
Loan term
Total amount payable
Repayment flexibility
Optional products included in the loan
Conditions for early repayment
The dealer's location should not distract from the financial details of the contract.
A short list of questions can expose differences between two apparently similar loans.
Ask the lender or finance provider:
What is the interest rate?
What is the total amount I will repay?
What establishment or other fees apply?
How much is each repayment?
How often are repayments made?
What is the full loan term?
Can I make extra repayments?
Are there fees or conditions for paying the loan off early?
Are insurance, warranties or other products included in the amount financed?
Who is the actual lender?
These questions are particularly important because a dealer arranging finance and a lender providing the credit are not necessarily the same business.
Car finance can sometimes be accompanied by additional products such as credit-related insurance, mechanical breakdown insurance or other warranties.
These may be appropriate in some circumstances, but they should not be treated as automatically necessary.
If an additional product is being financed as part of the loan, ask how much it costs and how much extra interest you will pay because it is included in the borrowing.
Consumer Protection says lenders must assess whether credit-related insurance is suitable and affordable when it is sold with the loan.
The question should always be: Do I need this product, what does it cover, and what will it actually cost me?
New Zealand's Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act contains responsible lending requirements.
Lenders must assess whether a loan is suitable and affordable, explain the relevant contract information and meet disclosure requirements.
This applies whether you are dealing directly with a lender or arranging vehicle finance through a dealer.
Consumer Protection also states that when a car dealer sets up vehicle finance as a lender's agent, responsible lending obligations still apply.
That does not mean every loan will be identical or that approval is guaranteed. It means borrowers should expect the lender to consider whether the proposed borrowing is suitable and affordable.
If you have two offers in front of you, put them into a simple table.
When comparing two car finance offers, check the following:
Amount borrowed: How much are you actually borrowing?
Interest rate: What interest rate will you pay?
Fees: Are there application, establishment or other fees?
Loan term: How long will you be making repayments?
Repayments: How much will you pay and how often?
Total cost: How much will you repay altogether?
Early repayment: Can you pay the loan off early, and are there any fees?
Add-ons: Are insurance, warranties or other products included in the loan?
Don't choose a loan based only on the weekly repayment or interest rate. A lower weekly payment can mean a longer loan and a higher total cost.
Always compare the full cost and terms before signing.
No. Consumer Protection recommends comparing finance options because costs vary between lenders and loan products. A buyer should compare the actual interest rate, fees, term and total amount payable rather than assuming one source is always cheaper.
It can be more convenient because the finance application can be handled alongside the vehicle purchase. However, convenience should not replace comparing the financial terms.
It can be useful. Consumer Protection recommends, where possible, getting pre-approval from a lender before going through a dealership so you have a clearer idea of your borrowing position.
Neither should be considered in isolation. Look at the interest rate, fees, term, repayment amount and total amount payable together.
Yes, the value of a trade-in can reduce the amount you need to borrow, although any existing finance owed on the vehicle also needs to be taken into account.
The better question is "Which loan gives me the right combination of cost, affordability and flexibility?"
A bank loan may work well for one buyer, while dealer-arranged finance may be more convenient or suitable for another. Neither should be accepted simply because it is familiar or easier to arrange.
Before signing, compare the complete numbers.
Know the amount borrowed, interest rate, fees, term, repayment schedule and total amount payable. Understand any conditions around early repayment and question additional products that are being added to the loan.
For anyone researching finance cars in New Zealand, that comparison is more valuable than choosing a lender based on a single advertised number.
The goal is not simply to get approved for a car loan. It is to understand what the loan will cost and make sure the vehicle and repayments fit your financial situation.