How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Croask Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: a rigid, ceramic-coated, non-stick crisper plate measuring 8.2 x 8.2 x 1 inches with a handle, built to fit Ninja AF100–AF161 and FD401, OP300–OP500 models. It's reusable, so nothing gets thrown away after dinner.
• Croask Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: it's one physical accessory with one size and one shape, and the ceramic coating needs gentle care — no abrasive cloths or metal scouring pads. It also only fits the basket-style Ninja units listed, not flip-up oven models.
• YQL 12 — biggest strength: 200 pre-cut 12 x 12 inch unbleached parchment sheets for Ninja SP151/SP101/SP201/SP301 flip ovens, heat-rated to 428°F, non-stick and disposable — lift, toss, done.
• YQL 12 — biggest trade-off: it's a consumable, not a tool. You use it up, and it's sized for 12-inch ovens rather than round air fryer baskets (though it can be trimmed).
• Who each is for: Croask if you own a basket-style Ninja and want one accessory you keep; YQL 12 if you own a Ninja flip-up oven and want to stop scrubbing trays.
The Croask crisper plate is a replacement part, not a gadget. It's a single 8.2 x 8.2 inch square plate, an inch tall, with a perforated surface and a handle so you can lift it out of the frying basket mid-cook without burning your fingers. The perforations matter more than they look: they let hot air circulate underneath the food, which is exactly how you get a crisp underside on fries, chicken, steak, onion rings or a small pizza instead of a soggy one.
The material is food-grade steel with a ceramic non-stick coating, in black. That ceramic layer is what makes food slide off and what makes the plate dishwasher-safe — Croask explicitly says you can put it in the dishwasher. It also explicitly warns you not to scrub it with rough abrasive cloths or metal balls, and not to clean it while it's still too hot. A dishwashing cloth is the gentler route. That's the honest trade-off of any coated accessory: it works beautifully until someone attacks it with steel wool.
Who should skip it? Anyone with a Ninja flip-up toaster oven — this plate isn't built for that form factor. Anyone who wants a no-thought cleanup — you still have to wash this plate. And anyone who won't respect the coating care instructions, because a ruined ceramic surface is worse than no accessory at all.
YQL 12: Who It's For
YQL 12 is a completely different category of product: 200 pre-cut square parchment liners, 12 x 12 inches, made from unbleached natural wood pulp. They're designed to fit Ninja Air Fryer + Convection Oven models SP151, SP101, SP201 and SP301 — the flip-up "foodi" toaster ovens — and YQL notes they can be trimmed to fit other ovens as needed.
The pitch is convenience, and it's a fair one. You don't tear, fold or trim for the listed Ninja models. You drop a sheet in, cook your wings, fries, cookies or pizza, then lift the sheet out and bin it. No scrubbing the tray, no soaking, no crusted-on grease. The liners are non-stick, they resist oil and butter, and YQL says they absorb excess oil while preventing leaks and soggy bottoms — which is the difference between crisp results and a tray swimming in fat.
The material is unbleached paper, brown, rated to withstand up to 428°F without curling or burning. That ceiling is worth remembering: it's comfortably above typical air frying temperatures, but it is a ceiling, and parchment near a hot element still deserves common sense. YQL also positions these as multi-use — ovens, microwaves, steamers — so a single box covers more than just the air fryer.
Who should buy it? Ninja flip-oven owners who cook often and hate cleanup. If your SP-series oven sees daily use, 200 sheets is a long runway. Anyone who bakes messy things — cookies, sticky glazes, greasy wings — will feel the difference immediately.
Who should skip it? People with round basket air fryers, since these are square 12-inch sheets and trimming is on you. People trying to reduce single-use waste — this is a disposable by design. And anyone who wants a durable tool rather than a consumable.
• Best for basket-style Ninja AF100–AF161 → Croask Air Fryer Replacement. It's sized and listed for exactly those models.
• Best for Ninja flip-up ovens SP151/SP101/SP201/SP301 → YQL 12. Pre-cut 12-inch squares, no trimming needed.
• Best for crisp undersides → Croask. The perforated plate lifts food off the basket floor and lets air circulate underneath.
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup → YQL 12. Lift the liner, toss it, and the tray stays clean.
• Best for a reusable, dishwasher-safe accessory → Croask. Ceramic-coated and dishwasher-friendly, provided you skip the abrasives.
• Best for high-volume cooking without running out → YQL 12. 200 sheets go a long way.
• Best for multi-appliance flexibility → YQL 12. YQL lists oven, microwave and steamer use, and the sheets trim to fit.
• Best for replacing a worn-out part → Croask. It's a direct replacement crisper plate, not a supply.
These two don't really compete — they solve different problems for different Ninja owners, and your oven model decides it. If you have a basket-style Ninja AF100–AF161 or a Foodi FD401/OP300–OP500, I'd buy the Croask Air Fryer Replacement: it's a one-time, reusable, dishwasher-safe plate that genuinely improves crisping. If you have a Ninja SP151/SP101/SP201/SP301 flip oven and cleanup is your pain point, I'd buy YQL 12 without hesitation. Check your model number first — that's the whole decision. Whichever you pick, check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since that's the one thing that could tip a close call.
FAQ
Yes. Croask states it can go in the dishwasher. The caveat is the coating: avoid rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring pads, and don't wash it while it's still very hot.
They're cut for Ninja SP151, SP101, SP201 and SP301 flip ovens at 12 x 12 inches. For other models YQL says you can trim them to size, so a round basket fryer would need cutting down.
YQL rates them to 428°F without curling or burning. That covers normal air frying, but keep them away from direct contact with a hot heating element.
Croask is reusable and should last with proper care of the ceramic coating. YQL 12 is disposable by design — 200 sheets, used one at a time, then thrown away.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GXF Air Fryer Grill vs Croask Replacement Rubber Bumpers, YQL 120PCS vs Dimioaoa 500Pcs: Air Fryer Cheese Sticks, GWBSXM Air fryer Replacement vs SANTOUXIANG 3-Pack