How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• COWHERDING Air Fryer Pan — biggest strength: one rigid, warp-resistant stainless pan with a reinforced rim, a 16 oz capacity and a straightforward dishwasher-safe cleanup routine. Biggest trade-off: it's a single tray, so you get no basket or rack for draining and layering.
• MQHJKAB Air Fryer Tray — biggest strength: a three-piece set (baking pan, fry basket, wire rack) that covers grilling, baking and frying in one box. Biggest trade-off: it needs a 10-minute preheat at 300°F before first use, otherwise it can deform.
• Pick COWHERDING if you just want to replace a worn-out tray and keep cooking the way you already do.
• Pick MQHJKAB if you want to expand what your oven can do, not just replace one part of it.
COWHERDING's tray is built around one job: being a direct replacement pan for Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 toaster ovens. The dimensions — roughly 12.4 x 11 x 0.78 inches — are sized for those ovens, and the brand also says it fits other similarly sized air fryer toaster ovens. It's a square, silver, stainless-steel tray with a non-stick finish and a stated 16 oz capacity.
The engineering story here is about rigidity. COWHERDING uses an "encapsulated" steel rim that the brand says resists warping up to 480°F / 260°C, and that reinforced edge doubles as a handle, so you can pull a hot tray out without hunting for a grip. The tall sides are meant to contain drips and spills, which matters in a toaster oven where a runaway pool of fat can smoke and burn onto the element. The brand also emphasizes even heat conductivity for browning that's consistent from edge to center.
Who should skip it? Anyone who wants a basket for draining fried food, or a rack for stacking two layers of baking. You get one tray here, and that's it. If your cooking is mostly "roast or bake on a flat surface," you won't miss the extras. If it isn't, you will.
MQHJKAB Air Fryer Tray: Who It's For
MQHJKAB takes the opposite approach: instead of one replacement part, it hands you a kit. The set includes a spacious baking pan, a fry basket and a wire rack, all sized for Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 ovens. The brand lists the model number as TOA-70 and the material as food-grade stainless steel that is BPA-free, odorless and stated to meet FDA standards, with no chemicals released at high baking temperatures.
Each piece has a defined role. The grate is for grilling, letting oil drain away so food crisps instead of steaming. The rack is for multi-layered baking — think two trays' worth of cookies or vegetables in one session. The pan handles frying and catching sauces and juices. Together they cover grilling, baking and frying, which is genuinely more range than a single flat tray gives you.
There is one important catch, and it's spelled out clearly: you must preheat this set before first use. The brand says to put the pan in a preheated 300°F oven for 10 minutes, because the material's properties mean that skipping this step can cause the pieces to deform, bend or be damaged, shortening their lifespan. That's not a dealbreaker — it's a one-time ritual — but it's the kind of instruction people ignore, and ignoring it is how a warping complaint gets written. The set is also dishwasher safe and the brand says the pieces resist sticking and bending, with a quick soak loosening anything stubborn on the rack, grate, pan or splatter shield.
Who should buy it? Anyone who wants to unlock more of what their Cuisinart toaster oven can already do — grilling with drainage, baking on two levels, frying with a basket. It's also a good fit if you're setting up the oven for the first time and would rather buy one complete accessory set than piece it together. Who should skip it? Someone who only needs a replacement pan and doesn't want to store three pieces, or anyone unwilling to follow the preheat instruction. This set weighs about 2.38 pounds, so it's noticeably more substantial than a lone tray, and it takes up more cabinet space.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for cooking versatility → MQHJKAB Air Fryer Tray. Pan, fry basket and wire rack cover grilling, baking and frying in one purchase.
• Best for draining fried food → MQHJKAB Air Fryer Tray. The grate lets oil drip away for crispier results; the COWHERDING tray is a flat surface.
• Best for multi-layer baking → MQHJKAB Air Fryer Tray. The wire rack is designed for stacking, which a single pan can't do.
• Best for minimal storage and simplicity → COWHERDING Air Fryer Pan. One piece, roughly 9.28 ounces, easy to slide into the oven and back into a drawer.
• Best for spill containment → COWHERDING Air Fryer Pan. Its tall sides are specifically designed to hold in juices and keep the oven cleaner.
• Best for heat tolerance without special handling → COWHERDING Air Fryer Pan. Both are rated to 480°F, but COWHERDING doesn't require a conditioning preheat.
• Best for someone who hates instructions → COWHERDING Air Fryer Pan. MQHJKAB's 10-minute preheat at 300°F is mandatory, not optional.
If I were replacing the tray in a Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 or TOA-70 and my goal was simply to keep cooking the way I already do, I'd buy the COWHERDING Air Fryer Pan. The reinforced rim, tall spill-containing sides and no-strings dishwasher-safe routine make it the lower-effort, lower-maintenance pick, and there's nothing to remember before the first use. I'd only steer myself to the MQHJKAB Air Fryer Tray if I actually wanted to grill with drainage, bake on two levels, or fry in a basket — because that's the real reason to buy it, and the three-piece set is what makes that possible. Decide which of those two cooks you are, and the choice is easy. Before you commit, check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page.
FAQ
It's a three-piece set: a baking pan, a fry basket and a wire rack. The COWHERDING Air Fryer Pan, by contrast, is a single tray.
Yes. The brand instructs a 10-minute preheat at 300°F before first use, warning that skipping it can cause the pieces to deform or bend and shorten their lifespan. The COWHERDING pan has no such requirement.
Both are dishwasher safe. COWHERDING notes residue wipes or soaks off and warns against abrasive scrubbers; MQHJKAB says a quick soak loosens stuck food on the rack, grate or pan.
Both brands state compatibility with all three models. COWHERDING lists dimensions of about 12.4 x 11 x 0.78 inches and adds that it fits other similarly sized air fryer toaster ovens.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Flylin Stainless Steel Dual vs HERCHR Air Fryer Replacement, Ciieeo Air Fryer Recipe vs Ipetboom 2pcs: Air Fryer Recipes, Mafier Professional Gold Kitchen vs MHADBKH Air Mesh Tray