Features
Both the Xrite Colormunki and the i1 Display Pro are designed to measure the color and brightness of your display and create a custom profile that matches your preferences and environment. They both come with a USB-powered colorimeter that attaches to your screen with a counterweight or a tripod mount, and a software that guides you through the calibration process. However, there are some differences in the features and capabilities of each device.
Feature
Colormunki Display
i1 Display Pro
Software
ColorMunki Display software
i1Profiler software
Modes
Easy and Advanced modes with simple one-click presets or wizard-driven options
Basic and Advanced modes with predefined workflows or user-defined settings
Ambient Light Measurement
Yes, automatically determines the optimum display luminance based on the lighting conditions where prints will be viewed
Yes, automatically determines the optimum display luminance based on the lighting conditions where prints will be viewed
Ambient Light Smart Control
Yes, compensates for the effect of ambient light on the perception of colors and provides the option to automatically adjust the profile or notify as ambient light conditions change
Yes, compensates for the effect of ambient light on the perception of colors and provides the option to automatically adjust the profile or notify as ambient light conditions change
Flare Correct
Yes, measures and adjusts the display profile for reduced contrast ratios caused by flare light or glare on the surface of the display
Yes, measures and adjusts the display profile for reduced contrast ratios caused by flare light or glare on the surface of the display
Intelligent Iterative Profiling
Yes, an adaptive technology that measures and analyzes the color capabilities of each unique display for increased accuracy of profile
Yes, an adaptive technology that measures and analyzes the color capabilities of each unique display for increased accuracy of profile
Automatic Display Control (ADC)
No, manual adjustment of display hardware (brightness/backlight, contrast, and color temperature) is required
Yes, automates the adjustment of display hardware (brightness/backlight, contrast, and color temperature) to speed up the profiling process and ensure highest quality results
Display Quality Assurance (DQA)
No, does not provide tools to check the quality of the display profile or monitor uniformity
Yes, provides tools to check the quality of the display profile or monitor uniformity and generate reports
Projector Profiling
Yes, supports projector profiling with a wizard-driven interface and predefined settings
Yes, supports projector profiling with a user-defined interface and advanced settings
Mobile Device Profiling
Yes, supports mobile device profiling with a free ColorTRUE app that delivers accurate color from desktop to mobile devices
Yes, supports mobile device profiling with a free ColorTRUE app that delivers accurate color from desktop to mobile devices
Third-Party Software Compatibility
No, does not work with third-party software such as NEC's Spectraview or Eizo's ColorNavigator
Yes, works with third-party software such as NEC's Spectraview or Eizo's ColorNavigator
As you can see, the i1 Display Pro offers more features and options than the Colormunki Display, especially in terms of automatic display control, display quality assurance, projector profiling, and third-party software compatibility. The i1 Display Pro is also more versatile and customizable, allowing you to choose between predefined workflows or user-defined settings, while the Colormunki Display is more wizard-driven and simplified.
Performance
Another difference between the Xrite Colormunki and the i1 Display Pro is the performance and accuracy of the device. Although both devices use the same hardware and sensors, the i1 Display Pro has a faster measurement and adjustment speed than the Colormunki Display. The i1 Display Pro can also measure a wider range of colors and brightness levels than the Colormunki Display, making it more suitable for high-end displays and projectors.
Performance
Colormunki Display
i1 Display Pro
Measurement Speed
Slow, takes about 5 minutes to calibrate a display
Fast, takes about 3 minutes to calibrate a display
Measurement Frequency
Low, measures about 118 colors per patch set
High, measures about 462 colors per patch set
Luminance Range
Narrow, measures from 80 cd/m2 to 250 cd/m2
Wide, measures from 10 cd/m2 to 5000 cd/m2
Color Gamut Coverage
Limited, covers about 97% of Adobe RGB and 100% of sRGB
Extensive, covers about 99% of Adobe RGB and 100% of sRGB
The i1 Display Pro clearly outperforms the Colormunki Display in terms of measurement speed, frequency, luminance range, and color gamut coverage. The i1 Display Pro can calibrate your display faster and more accurately than the Colormunki Display, and it can also handle a wider range of display types and technologies. The i1 Display Pro is also more future-proof, as it can support new standards and formats such as HDR and Rec.2020.
Price
The last difference between the Xrite Colormunki and the i1 Display Pro is the price. The Colormunki Display is cheaper than the i1 Display Pro, but it also offers less features and performance. The Colormunki Display is currently priced at $169 on Amazon, while the i1 Display Pro is priced at $259 on Amazon. The price difference is about $90, which may or may not be worth it depending on your needs and budget.
Conclusion
The Xrite Colormunki and the i1 Display Pro are both excellent devices for display calibration, but they have different strengths and weaknesses. The Colormunki Display is a good choice for beginners or hobbyists who want a simple and easy way to calibrate their displays and projectors. The i1 Display Pro is a better choice for professionals or enthusiasts who want more features and options to calibrate their displays and projectors with higher accuracy and speed. The i1 Display Pro is also more compatible with third-party software and supports new standards and formats. The price difference between the two devices is significant, but it reflects the difference in quality and performance. Ultimately, the best device for you depends on your personal preferences, needs, and budget.
: [X-Rite ColorMunki Display (CMUNDIS)] : [X-Rite i1Display Pro (EODIS3)]
a7a7d27f09