How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a roomy hard shell that swallows big foldable on-ear headphones plus a charger and cable, choose Comecase Headphone Case; if you need a slimmer, water-resistant EVA shell built around flat-folding on-ear models, choose DigiCharge Carry Case.
• Comecase Headphone Case — biggest strength: a genuinely large 6.1 x 3.35 x 7.87 inch interior that fits extra-large foldable on-ear and around-ear headphones, with a removable hand strap, a carabiner and an inner mesh pocket.
• Comecase Headphone Case — biggest trade-off: that size and the PU-leather-over-EVA build make it the bulkier of the two, and it only works if your headphones fold.
• DigiCharge Carry Case — biggest strength: a 900D nylon exterior with a diamond pattern over a strong EVA shell, plus a soft flocking interior and honeycomb air cushion — water-resistant and impact-resistant in a flatter, more packable shape.
• DigiCharge Carry Case — biggest trade-off: it is designed around flat-folding on-ear models, so bulky over-ear cans may not sit comfortably, and the accessory space is a moulded insert rather than a deep pocket.
• Who each pick is for: Comecase for the traveller with chunky foldable Beats, JBL or Picun headphones who wants maximum interior room; DigiCharge for the commuter with Sony WH-CH520/WH-CH510 or JBL Tune on-ears who folds them flat and wants a slim, weather-resistant bag.
The Comecase Headphone Case is unapologetically about capacity. Its listed dimensions of 6.1 x 3.35 x 7.87 inches put it firmly in the "extra large" bracket, and the compatibility list backs that up: Beats Solo 2, Solo 3, Solo 4, Studio 3 and Studio Pro, TOZO HT2, JBL E45BT and E55BT, Sony MDR-ZX110, Picun P26, Mpow 059 and the noot products K11. That is a long list of foldable on-ear and around-ear headphones, and the case is built around the assumption that you will fold them down before you zip up.
Protection is where this case earns its keep. The shell is hard, wrapped in PU leather over an ethylene vinyl acetate body, and the manufacturer describes it as semi-waterproof, shockproof, dust-resistant and scratch-resistant, with a soft-touch finish. Practically, that means it shrugs off the crush of a packed carry-on, the scuffs of a daily commute, and the odd splash. A removable hand strap gives you a way to carry it on its own, and a carabiner lets you hang it off a bag. Inside, a mesh pocket takes a cable and a charger so nothing rattles loose against the earcups.
Who should buy it: anyone with large foldable headphones who wants one case that protects them properly and still has room for accessories. Who should skip it: anyone with small or non-folding headphones, or anyone trying to travel ultralight — this is a case that takes up real space in a bag. Comecase lists an 18-month warranty, which is worth noting if you plan to use it hard.
The DigiCharge Carry Case takes the opposite approach: slim, flat and weather-ready. Its 8.27 x 7.87 x 2.95 inch footprint is wide and shallow, which tells you exactly what it is for — headphones that fold flat. The compatibility list reads like a who's-who of budget on-ear favourites: Sony WH-CH520, WH-CH510, MDR-ZX110, MDR-ZX110NA, MDR-ZX310, MDR-ZX310AP, MDR-XB550AP, JBL Tune 500, 510BT, 520BT, 660NC, 670NC, T450BT and JR 310. If you own one of those, this case was basically designed for you.
The build is the interesting part. A strong EVA foam shell does the structural work, then it is wrapped in 900D nylon with a black diamond pattern that resists impacts and splashes. Inside, a soft flocking lining and a honeycomb air cushion are there to stop scratches and absorb knocks. The result is a case that is water-resistant rather than fully waterproof — fine for rain, a spilled drink on a tray table, or a damp gym bag, but not something to submerge. A moulded insert and a mesh pocket hold cables, chargers and small accessories, and a comfortable handle plus a heavy-duty zip round out the travel-friendly design.
Who should buy it: commuters, students and office workers with flat-folding Sony or JBL on-ears who want a case that slides into a backpack without hogging space. Who should skip it: anyone with thick over-ear headphones that do not fold flat — they simply will not sit right in a shallow shell.
• Best for large foldable headphones → Comecase Headphone Case. The extra-large 6.1 x 3.35 x 7.87 inch interior and long Beats/JBL/Picun compatibility list make it the safer bet for chunky cans.
• Best for flat-folding on-ear models → DigiCharge Carry Case. If you own Sony WH-CH520/WH-CH510 or a JBL Tune, the shallow shell is shaped around exactly that fold-flat form.
• Best for water resistance → DigiCharge Carry Case. 900D nylon with a water-resistant rating beats the semi-waterproof PU-leather finish of the Comecase.
• Best for crush protection in a packed bag → Comecase Headphone Case. Both use hard EVA-style shells, but the Comecase's deeper body gives thick earcups more room to sit without pressure.
• Best for carrying by hand → Comecase Headphone Case. The removable hand strap and carabiner give you two ways to carry it; DigiCharge relies on a fixed handle.
• Best for sliding into a backpack → DigiCharge Carry Case. At under three inches thick, it takes noticeably less room than the taller Comecase.
• Best for accessory storage → Comecase Headphone Case. The mesh pocket is roomier for a charger brick plus cable; DigiCharge's moulded insert suits cables and small bits.
• Best for peace of mind on build → either, with a lean to Comecase. Comecase backs its case with an 18-month warranty, which is a concrete detail worth weighing.
In my opinion, I would buy the Comecase Headphone Case if my headphones were large and foldable — the extra interior room, the hand strap, the carabiner and the 18-month warranty make it the more forgiving case for big Beats, JBL or Picun cans. I would pick the DigiCharge Carry Case instead if I owned flat-folding Sony or JBL on-ears and wanted something thin, water-resistant and easy to live with in a backpack. The deciding question is simple: how much interior space do your headphones actually need? Answer that honestly and the choice makes itself.
are on ear headphones good
For a lot of people, yes. On-ear models like the Sony WH-CH520 or JBL Tune 520BT are lighter and more compact than over-ear cans, and both cases here are built specifically around on-ear and flat-folding headphones — which tells you they are a mainstream, well-supported form factor. The trade-off is less passive isolation than a full over-ear cup.
what are the best open ear headphones
Neither case is designed for open-ear headphones. Both are built for on-ear models that fold — Comecase for larger foldable sets like the Beats Solo and Studio range, DigiCharge for flat-folding Sony and JBL on-ears. If you own open-ear headphones, check the dimensions against the case before buying.
which are the best over the ear headphones
That depends on your priorities, but from a storage standpoint the Comecase Headphone Case is the one to look at for over-ear sets, since its compatibility list includes around-ear models like the JBL E55BT and Beats Studio Pro. DigiCharge leans toward slimmer on-ear models and flat-folders.
what are the best over the ear headphones to buy
I cannot rank headphones for you, but I can tell you how to match a case to them. If yours fold and are bulky, the Comecase Headphone Case has the room. If they fold flat and are slim, the DigiCharge Carry Case is the tidier fit. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: KASOTT SoundMaster Pro V1 vs IIISOGNO 3.5mm, JVC Gumy Mini HAA6TB vs Monster Achieve 100: True Wireless, iChenovo 2022 vs Hello Kitty Light-Up Headphones, Audio-Technica ATH-M40x vs Rockville PRO-M50