How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a tough, travel-ready home for foldable on-ear headphones you already own — especially if you move between a backpack, a carry-on and a MacBook setup — choose Comecase Headphone Case; if you need the actual sound, a built-in microphone and a lightweight pair of on-ear Bluetooth headphones for a MacBook, choose XuanGui On-Ear Headphones. These two products sit at opposite ends of the same problem, and once you see what each one is really built to do, the choice stops being confusing.
• Comecase Headphone Case — biggest strength: a hard EVA shell with PU leather finish that resists shock, crush, dust, scratches and moisture, plus a carabiner and hand strap for clipping onto a bag.
• Comecase Headphone Case — biggest trade-off: it is a case only. No headphones, no cable, no charger — you supply the gear it protects.
• XuanGui On-Ear Headphones — biggest strength: a complete wireless package — Bluetooth 5.3, a built-in HD microphone, 20 hours of playback, a 500 mAh battery, FM radio, a micro SD/TF slot and multi-point pairing, all at just 144 g.
• XuanGui On-Ear Headphones — biggest trade-off: the enclosure is faux leather and plastic with no active noise cancellation, so isolation depends on the ear cushions rather than electronics.
• Who the Comecase is for: anyone who already owns foldable on-ear or over-ear headphones (Beats Solo, Studio, JBL, Sony MDR-ZX110, TOZO, Picun and similar) and wants them to survive daily commutes and flights.
• Who the XuanGui is for: anyone who needs working headphones right now — calls, music, radio, memory-card playback — and wants them light enough to forget in a bag.
The Comecase case is a protection product, and it is honest about that. The shell is hard EVA, wrapped in a PU leather finish that feels soft in the hand but shrugs off dust, scratches, scuffs and light moisture. Comecase describes it as semi-waterproof and shockproof, and the combination of a rigid shell plus a soft exterior is exactly what you want when a bag gets shoved under an airplane seat or thrown into a trunk.
What makes it genuinely useful for a foldable on-ear headphone owner is the compatibility list. It is sized to fit Beats Solo 2, Solo 3, Solo 4, Studio 3 and Studio Pro, JBL E45BT and E55BT, Sony MDR-ZX110, TOZO HT2, noot products K11, Mpow models, Picun P26 and more — in other words, the classic folding on-ear and around-ear shapes. At 6.1 x 3.35 x 7.87 inches it stays compact enough for a backpack or carry-on, and the inner mesh pocket gives cables and a charger somewhere to live so they are not rattling against the earcups.
XuanGui On-Ear Headphones: Who It's For
The XuanGui Q9M is the opposite kind of purchase: it is the whole experience in one box. Bluetooth 5.3 gives you a faster, more stable connection with a claimed range up to 15 meters, and pairing is quick — XuanGui says about three seconds, with a memory function that reconnects automatically next time you power on. For a MacBook user who hops between video calls, music and a phone, multi-point connection to two devices at once is the feature that quietly saves the most annoyance.
Battery life is the headline number: 20 hours of Bluetooth playback from a 500 mAh battery, recharged in roughly 2.5 hours. That is a full week of commutes on a single charge for most people. The 40 mm dynamic drivers handle the audio, and XuanGui describes the tuning as crisp and clean with well-balanced bass and hi-fi tones — a reasonable target for on-ear headphones at this weight class. There is also an FM radio mode and a micro SD/TF card slot, which is unusual and genuinely handy if you want music without a phone or laptop nearby.
Weight is where these shine: 144 g. On-ear headphones clamp, and a light pair with soft protein-leather cushions is far easier to wear for a long afternoon of online meetings. The adjustable headband at both ends helps it fit different head shapes. The built-in HD microphone is the piece that matters most if you are shopping for a best gaming headset for MacBook use or want a microphone Bluetooth setup for calls — XuanGui states the internal chip filters the mic signal to reduce wind and background noise for clearer voice transmission.
The trade-offs are real. Noise control is listed as none, so isolation comes from the cushions pressing against your ears, not from active cancellation. The build is faux leather and plastic, which keeps the weight down but will not feel like a premium metal-and-leather headphone. And if you want a wired option, there is a 3.5 mm jack, but the design leans wireless-first. Buy it if you want one affordable-feeling, featherweight pair that does calls, music, radio and card playback. Skip it if you already own better-sounding headphones and only need protection for them — that is the Comecase's job.
• Best for protecting expensive foldable on-ear headphones → Comecase Headphone Case. Hard EVA shell, PU leather wrap, shock and crush resistance, and a fit list that covers Beats Solo/Studio, JBL, Sony and more.
• Best for battery life → XuanGui On-Ear Headphones. 20 hours of Bluetooth playback and a 2.5-hour recharge from a 500 mAh battery.
• Best for calls and meetings → XuanGui On-Ear Headphones. Built-in HD microphone with chip-based noise filtering, plus multi-point connection to two devices.
• Best for travel convenience → Comecase Headphone Case. Lightweight, compact, removable hand strap and a carabiner for hanging off a bag.
• Best for lightweight all-day wear → XuanGui On-Ear Headphones. 144 g with soft protein-leather ear and head cushions and an adjustable headband.
• Best for offline music without a phone → XuanGui On-Ear Headphones. FM radio mode and a micro SD/TF card slot.
• Best for cable and accessory storage → Comecase Headphone Case. The inner mesh pocket keeps a USB cable and charger from tangling with your earcups.
• Best if you want both jobs covered → buy the XuanGui for listening and the Comecase to store them. The case's compatibility list is built around exactly this class of folding headphone.
In my opinion, most people shopping this exact comparison should buy the XuanGui On-Ear Headphones — because a case is only useful once you have headphones worth protecting, and the Q9M gives you Bluetooth 5.3, a working microphone, 20 hours of playback and a 144 g frame for MacBook calls, music and travel in one purchase. I would only pick the Comecase Headphone Case first if I already owned a pair of foldable on-ear headphones I loved, in which case a hard, water-resistant shell with a carabiner is the smarter spend. If you can stretch to both, that is the combination I would actually run: XuanGui on your head, Comecase in your bag.
are on ear headphones good
Yes, for the right job. On-ear designs sit lighter on the head than over-ear models — the XuanGui Q9M weighs just 144 g — which makes them comfortable for long calls and commutes. The trade-off is less passive isolation, since this model lists no active noise control.
what are the best open ear headphones
That is a different category from both products here. Neither the Comecase case nor the XuanGui Q9M is an open-ear design; the XuanGui is a closed on-ear Bluetooth headphone with 40 mm drivers, and the Comecase is a storage case rather than a headphone at all.
which are the best over the ear headphones
If you mean over-ear rather than on-ear, the Comecase case is explicitly built to fit that family — Beats Studio 3 and Studio Pro, JBL E55BT and similar around-ear models. The XuanGui Q9M itself is an on-ear headphone, so it is the wrong pick if you specifically want cups that surround your ears.
what are the best over the ear headphones to buy
I would decide by need rather than by label. If you want headphones to use today, the XuanGui gives you Bluetooth 5.3, a built-in mic, 20 hours of battery and multi-point pairing. If you already own over-ear headphones and want them to survive travel, the Comecase hard case with its shockproof EVA shell is the practical buy. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding, since that is the one number that changes.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Bang & Olufsen Beoplay vs VENTION USB Sound Card, 50th Anniversary of Hip Hop Over Ear Headphones vs Rotibox Beanie Hat, 1Mii Aurisonic GX vs AOC 2.4GHz, our PLT Poly vs Monster Open Ear AC600 pick