Details of Meeting 3
Region: Europe/AfricaDate/time
Wednesday July 5th 2023 at 0700 PDT (US Pacific) / 1000 EDT (US East Coast) / 1500 BST (UK) / 1600 CEST (Central Europe) / 1930 IST (India).
Chaired by Valldeflors Viñuela Navarro (Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya).
Agenda
Welcome
Recap of ISCET progress so far (presented by Matt J Dunn)
Setting priorities for ISCET standards development. Based on:
current use of clinical eye tracking internationally, i.e., what are the current main use cases? How can we clearly establish this?
which patient groups would most benefit from standards.
Developing a mission statement for ISCET – e.g., to provide clinical guidance / represent the clinical eye tracking sector – anything else?
Any other business
Meeting recording
Attendees
12 people attended the meeting.
Notes
Understanding clinical use of eye trackers
Use of eye trackers in the following clinical disorders/disciplines was mentioned:
Eye movement disorders (e.g. nystagmus)
Concussion (lots of recent products being developed)
Neuropsychology
Dizziness
Orthoptics
Optometry
Reading disability
Audiology
Ophthalmology
Neuro-ophthalmology
However, this may not be an exhaustive list and further work is required to ensure no disciplines are excluded. Current ISCET membership may not reflect actual international use.
Could approach manufacturers to determine full extent of clinical eye tracker use
However, clinical uses are currently 'off-label' for many eye trackers so this may not reflect actual use
After identifying a list of clinical disciplines, ISCET could approach professional clinical bodies and ask a representative from each to attend a meeting to determine actual scope of usage and/or distribute a questionnaire to their members
Gemma Arblaster will determine whether University of Sheffield is able to provide ethical approval as host institution for a questionnaire study on current international eye tracker usage; results may be publishable.
Matt Dunn will create a collaborative document to enable members to propose suggestions for organisations to approach and questions to ask regarding eye tracker usage
Remit of ISCET
Suggested that ISCET add to its remit "maintainence of reference datasets" (i.e. 'normative data')
Unlikely that ISCET would want to be involved in signing people off as competent in techniques (too resource-intensive; providing guidance/standard protocols is enough)
Structure of ISCET
Moving toward a committee structure may be worthwhile
To be more inclusive of collegues in the Americas, a a third meeting time should be added, mirroring ISCEV's structure of international representation. The three regions are therefore:
Europe/Africa
Asia/Australia
Americas
Noted that only 12 people in attendance at this meeting (compare to 70 at first meeting). Discussed:
Is it too difficult to sign up to the mailing list / find the website?
Is the time slot not amenable to clinicians?
Consider alternating the day of the week
Consider advertising via more channels and encouraging current members to spread the word (provide link to website and sign-up to mail group)
Next meeting
The next meeting will be arranged at a time to suit the Americas and will focus on:
Identifying representative/professional clinical bodies to approach to (a) determine current international eye tracker usage and (b) expand ISCET membership
Formalising committees for each of the three regions (Europe/Africa, Asia/Australia, Americas)
Formalise ISCET's purpose (currently three aims proposed):
Maintain guidelines
Maintain reference datasets
Represent the clinical eye tracking sector
Chat
15:11:07 From Matt J Dunn : https://sites.google.com/view/clinicaleyetracking/meeting-2-2023-05-3015:31:33 From Gemma Arblaster : Yes - it went to the British and Irish Orthoptic Society, but we could go out to the wider European and International Orthoptic Associations as well15:42:10 From Gemma Arblaster : If we are keen to do this - I am happy to be part of a working group surveying clinical eye tracking use15:49:54 From Matt J Dunn : Neurological disordersNystagmus (many people)
Antisaccades
Saccadic reaction times
Fixational eye movements
Reading disability / dyslexia
Orthoptics
Ophthalmology
Audiology
Amblyopia
Cognitive impairment
Glaucoma
Vergence / diplopia
Neuropsychology15:53:17 From Matt J Dunn : missing on the list: vestibular functions (VOR, head Impulse test, caloric Irrigation/Nystagmus, etc.)16:03:21 From Jonathan Erichsen To Matt J Dunn(privately) : Lee has been warned that we’re running over.16:05:15 From Mario E Giardini (University of Strathclyde, UK) To Matt J Dunn(privately) : Need to leave. Many thanks.16:06:30 From Gemma Arblaster : good idea16:07:45 From Matt J Dunn : https://sites.google.com/view/clinicaleyetracking/home16:07:51 From Matt J Dunn : https://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/cgi-bin/webadmin?A0=ISCET16:10:16 From Gemma Arblaster : Thanks all - I've got to go now too.