Working Papers
Without abstracts | With abstracts
Without abstracts | With abstracts
Integrating New York City Schools: The Role of Admission Criteria and Family Preferences
Updated January 2023 - Link to the Policy Brief - Revise and Resubmit at JPE
Abstract: Almost 70 years after Brown v. Board of Education, most urban school districts remain segregated by race and income. School admission criteria could perpetuate segregation by limiting access. This paper uses recent screened-school admission reforms and a structural model to gauge the contribution of school admission criteria to segregation in New York City middle schools. Two admission reforms that reduced academic screening decreased economic and racial segregation, while prompting some White and high-income students to leave the traditional public school sector. These admission reforms also appear to have changed application behavior in a manner reinforcing their desegregating effects. I use a model of school demand that allows for strategic application behavior to predict the consequences of hypothetical city-wide admission reforms. The resulting estimates suggest that removing academic screening only modestly reduces school segregation. In contrast, dropping admission criteria based on geographic proximity reduces segregation markedly. On balance, only about half of NYC middle school segregation is due to school admission criteria, with the rest due to family preferences and residential sorting.
Can Selective School Admission Reforms Increase Student Achievement?
Updated August 2026
Abstract: The recent surge in admission reforms across selective US schools has been a source of much debate. The achievement consequences of these reforms hinge on which students benefit from attending these schools. I show that Boston exam schools have heterogeneous effects on achievement, driven primarily by the quality of applicants’ non-exam school alternatives rather than their demographic characteristics. Admission policies prioritizing students with weaker schooling alternatives thus have more potential to increase academic achievement than policies targeting specific demographic groups. Simulations of alternative admission criteria suggest that schemes reserving seats for such students are likely to yield the largest gains.
Still Worth the Trip? School Busing Effects in Boston and New York (with Joshua Angrist, Guthrie Gray-Lobe and Parag Pathak)
Updated December 2022 - Link to the Policy Brief
Abstract: School assignment in Boston and New York City came to national attention in the wake of court-mandated desegregation in the 1960s and 1970s. Today, district-wide choice allows Boston and New York students to enroll far from home, perhaps enhancing integration. Urban school transportation is costly, however, and has unclear integration and education consequences. We estimate the causal effects of non-neighborhood school assignment and school travel on integration and achievement using an identification strategy that exploits partly-random assignment variation arising from the Boston and New York City school matches. Instrumental variables estimates suggest distance and travel boost integration for those who choose to travel, but have little or no effect on test scores and college attendance. We argue that small effects on educational outcomes reflect modest effects of distance and travel on school quality, as measured by value-added.
Choosing Segregation? The Determinants of Racial Gaps in School Choice and the Integrating Effects of Peer Exposure (with Viola Corradini)
Updated November 2024 - Link to the Policy Brief
Abstract: Combining administrative data with novel survey data from New York City, we document large racial gaps in the value-added and racial composition of school choices, and show that they primarily stem from differences in awareness of high-quality schools and preferences over school demographics. Exploiting quasi-experimental variation in middle school peer composition, we find that exposure to other-race peers leads students to choose and enroll in more integrated high schools, and leads Black and Hispanic students to enroll in higher-value-added schools. These peer effects operate by broadening awareness of high-quality schools and reducing preferences for demographically similar peers.
Equilibrium Effects of Neighborhood Schools (with Raymond Han)
Updated January 2025
Abstract: Many public school districts allow families to enroll in schools outside their neighborhood. At the cost of higher transportation spending, choice programs aim to decouple educational opportunity from residential geography. This paper evaluates the impact of a return to neighborhood-based assignment following Seattle's re-introduction of neighborhood schools in 2010. We quantify the aggregate and distributional consequences of neighborhood assignment using an equilibrium model of joint residential and enrollment choices. Residential relocation responses limit the welfare costs of neighborhood assignment, reducing aggregate losses by roughly half. Lower housing costs fully offset welfare losses from restricted choice for low-income renters. Neighborhood assignment does not increase racial segregation or reduce the quality of schools attended by low-income families.
School Choice Under Uncertainty: Search Cost and Disappointment Aversion (with Viola Corradini)
Preliminary draft available upon request
Abstract: In this paper, we study how families make school search and application decisions when admission to schools is uncertain. We introduce a new tool on the NYC school application website that displays personalized admission probabilities to families. Using detailed data from the city’s school search website, families’ application choices, and a post-application survey, we examine the impact of this tool on families’ search behavior and application decisions. We leverage randomness in admission outcomes to isolate the causal effect of having a higher probability of admission to a given school. We find that families redirect their search effort toward schools for which they have a higher chance of admission, and in some cases consider schools they would not otherwise have applied to. Conditional on knowing a school, families are also less likely to apply to a school when their admission probability is lower. This avoidance behavior is more consistent with disappointment aversion than with search costs. These behavioral responses point to a hidden cost of providing families with information about their admission chances, which may have unintended consequences—particularly given imperfect understanding of probabilities.