Mattydaytrades Review: 353 Members, 4.8 Stars, But Is $85/Month Worth It?

I'll be straight with you: I went into this with the same skepticism most traders have when they see yet another options alerts Discord. The internet is full of people selling "holy grail" trade calls, taking screenshots of their winners, and going quiet when things go sideways. So when I started looking into Mattydaytrades (run by Matthew Garcia on Whop), I wasn't exactly expecting to be impressed.

But the review data told a different story than I expected.

Forty-four out of forty-nine verified buyers left five-star reviews. That's not marketing copy. Those are real purchasers who went through Whop's verification process. For a community that's been operating since 2023, that kind of consistency is hard to fake. My verdict: this is genuinely worth considering for active day traders and serious beginners who want more than just alerts, they want to actually understand what they're doing.

That said, there are some real limitations here that matter depending on your situation, and I'll walk through all of it.

CHECK CURRENT PRICING AND JOIN DETAILS ON WHOP ??

What You Actually Get Inside the Premium Discord

The flagship product is the Premium Discord, and at $85 per month (at the time I checked), here's what that buys you:

• Daily live trading sessions. This is the centerpiece. Matthew trades live, in real time, walking through his reasoning as he enters and exits positions. Not a recorded highlight reel. Live.

• Real-time trade alerts with callouts on options plays as they happen.

• Daily watchlists so you're not starting from scratch every morning trying to figure out what to focus on.

• Weekly seminars with experienced traders covering strategy and market analysis.

• 1-on-1 mentoring opportunities with experienced mentors in the community.

• A community of 300+ active traders for shared discussion, questions, and accountability.

• A built-in Content Rewards program (free to join separately) for engaged members.

The experience is delivered through Discord, with supplementary forum-style announcements and community chat features through Whop. Access to the live sessions runs through the Discord server once you're a member.

One thing worth understanding upfront: this is a day trading and options scalping community. Matthew's style involves entering and exiting positions quickly, often within the same trading session. If you're expecting swing trades held for weeks or passive "set and forget" signals, you'll want to recalibrate. This community is built for people who are at their screens during market hours, or who at least want to learn to be.

?? See what current members are saying before you commit

The Teaching Philosophy That Sets This Apart

Here's what surprised me most when I dug into the actual member reviews: the thing people kept praising wasn't the win rate or the big calls. It was how Matthew teaches.

One verified buyer put it well: "Matty truly cares about teaching people how to fish, not just handing out trades." Another mentioned that as someone new to trading, they'd "learned a lot more being part of this community than in others" specifically because Matthew "takes the time to literally explain why he's getting in and out."

That distinction matters more than it sounds. There's a huge difference between a community that sends you a ticker and a strike price and one that walks you through the reasoning in real time. The second type builds your own decision-making ability over time. The first creates dependency, and frankly, a lot of traders never get past that.

The live trading sessions seem to be where this philosophy comes alive. Matthew reportedly doesn't hide his screen or his process. You see the trades form, hear the rationale, and watch the execution. For someone trying to build actual skill (not just copy trades blindly), that's a fundamentally different product than what most alert services offer.

This is also why the community has held together with solid ratings since 2023. Communities built around a single "guru's" calls tend to collapse when a bad month hits. Communities built around genuine education tend to have more resilient members who stick around because they're growing.

Matthew Garcia's Credibility Profile

Matthew Garcia (username garciafit on Whop) has been on the platform for three years, which puts his roots there from around 2022. The Mattydaytrades store itself has been operating since 2023. He's active across Instagram, YouTube, X (formerly Twitter), and a dedicated website, which gives you multiple avenues to vet his work before you spend a dollar.

His own pitch: "I've dedicated my career to mastering day trading and building a community where traders of all levels can thrive." Whether that resonates with you or not probably depends on how many similar claims you've heard. Fair. But the review trail backs it up in a way that marketing copy usually can't.

353 members in the Premium Discord and 459 total store members as of when I looked. That's a focused, mid-size community rather than a bloated server where your questions disappear into the scroll.

?? Verify Matthew's credentials and check the latest member count on his Whop page

Pricing Breakdown and How the Math Works

Here's the full tier structure at the time I checked:

• Monthly: $85 per month

• Annual: $800 per year (works out to about $66.67/month, roughly a 22% discount)

• Lifetime: $2,500 one-time

The monthly option gives you flexibility to test the community before committing. If you're serious after a month or two, the annual plan pays for itself in about two months of savings. The lifetime option is the kind of thing that makes sense if you're already deeply committed to the community and planning to stay for years.

To give you some context: options alert services on platforms like Whop typically range from $30/month on the low end to $200+ for premium rooms with well-known traders. At $85/month, Mattydaytrades sits in a reasonable middle tier, especially given the live daily sessions (which are resource-intensive to produce and often priced much higher elsewhere).

One reviewer did note they found it "pretty expensive." That's a valid data point, and whether it feels worth it probably comes down to how actively you use the daily live sessions. If you're logging in regularly and engaging with the material, the per-session cost drops significantly. If you're checking in sporadically, you won't get the value.

It's also worth checking the Whop listing directly, since first-time buyers on Whop sometimes see a welcome discount popup at checkout. Those offers tend to be time-limited, so it's worth looking before you walk away.

?? Check if a welcome discount is still active when you visit the page

What the Critical Reviews Actually Tell You

Two of the three-star reviews are worth reading carefully because they're honest in a useful way.

Both reviewers said Matthew himself was a good person and that the community was solid. Their issue was style fit: specifically, that his approach is pure day trading and scalping, nothing held longer than a day or two, and that you need to be at your screen during market hours to catch the plays in real time.

This isn't a knock on the community. It's a fit issue. If you're a swing trader, a position trader, or someone who checks their account once a day after work, this isn't built for you. But if you're trying to learn active intraday trading, it's exactly the environment you'd want.

The one one-star review exists, though no detail is visible in the public data. With 49 reviews total, a single outlier doesn't shift the picture much, but it's there if you want to factor it in.

Who Gets the Most Out of This Community

The people who will get the most out of Mattydaytrades Premium Discord are:

Newer traders who want real education, not just alerts. If you've been copying trades without understanding them and feel like you're not building any real skill, this community's teach-while-trading format is genuinely different.

Active market participants who can watch the screen during hours. The live sessions are the core value. If your schedule lets you be present from the open, you'll use a lot more of what you're paying for.

Traders tired of large, impersonal Discord servers. At 353 members, you can still get questions answered and have your presence felt. That community dynamic changes significantly once servers hit thousands of members.

Intermediate traders who want to sharpen their scalping and short-term options skills. Even if you're not brand new, watching a practiced trader work in real time and explain their entries and exits is one of the more efficient ways to identify gaps in your own process.

The fit is tighter for swing traders or anyone who can't be present during market hours. There are better communities for those styles, and Matthew's format is specifically calibrated for the active day trading approach.

Pros and Cons at a Glance

Pros:

• Live daily sessions where Matthew trades transparently in real time, explaining his reasoning as he goes

• Strong verified review track record (4.8 stars across 49 reviews, 44 of which are five-star)

• Genuinely educational approach focused on building skills, not just trade dependency

• Reasonable community size (353 members) where individual attention is still possible

• Multiple pricing tiers including a lifetime option for long-term members

• 1-on-1 mentoring access, which is often a premium feature at other services

• Active social presence across YouTube, Instagram, and X for additional vetting

Cons:

• Must be present during market hours to capture the real-time value; not built for passive followers

• Exclusively short-term/scalping style won't suit swing or position traders

• $85/month is a real commitment that requires active engagement to justify

• Results will vary based on your own account size, risk management, and how much you apply the education (as with any trading community)

My Overall Take on Mattydaytrades

The thing that keeps bringing me back to this community as a recommendation is the consistency between what Matthew says he does and what members report actually experiencing. He says he wants to teach people to trade, not create followers. The reviews confirm that's what's happening. That alignment is rarer than it should be in this space.

If you're an active trader or someone trying to become one, who can show up during market hours and wants to learn from someone doing it live every day, $85/month is a reasonable ask. It's less than a single bad options trade and more than most traders spend on their actual education. The annual plan at $800 is the better value for anyone planning to stick around.

The community is still growing (operating since 2023 with nearly 460 total store members), which means you're joining while it's still accessible and before any potential scaling changes the dynamic. Communities at this stage often offer the most direct access to the creator.

JOIN MATTYDAYTRADES ON WHOP AND SEE THE FULL DETAILS FOR YOURSELF ?

Quick note: options trading involves real financial risk. Nothing in this review is financial advice, past results shared by any community don't guarantee future performance, and you should never risk capital you can't afford to lose. Do your own research and trade within your means.