How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• chengziyue 6QT — biggest strength: purpose-built for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT air fryer, with a double-layer nonstick coating, a handle for lifting it out of the basket, and dishwasher-safe cleaning.
• chengziyue 6QT — biggest trade-off: it fits one specific air fryer model (and you may need to adjust the four rubber feet to seat it properly), so it's a single-appliance accessory rather than a general-purpose pan.
• SynHHergyx 3Pcs — biggest strength: you get three 9 x 6.7 x 1 inch rimmed pans, oven safe up to 400°F, sized for toaster ovens and small baking jobs.
• SynHHergyx 3Pcs — biggest trade-off: it's a baking pan set, not an air fryer basket insert, so it doesn't drop into a 6QT air fryer drawer the way the chengziyue plate does.
• Who each pick is for: chengziyue 6QT for Gourmia GAF616 owners who want a crisping surface for air frying; SynHHergyx 3Pcs for anyone who bakes or roasts in a toaster oven and wants spares on hand.
The chengziyue 6QT is a square crisper plate made from food-grade carbon steel with a double-layer nonstick coating. It's shaped and sized as a replacement rack specifically for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT Digital Electric Air Fryer, and that single-model focus is the whole point. If you own that air fryer and the original rack has worn, warped, or gone missing, this is a direct stand-in rather than a generic pan you have to fight into place.
Two things to know before you buy. First, the fit is tight by design: the listing tells you to adjust the tension of the four feet so the tray seats correctly in your specific basket, so expect five minutes of fiddling on day one. Second, the nonstick coating is the part that decides how long this lasts — the instructions are explicit that you should not scrub it with abrasive cloths or metal balls, and the included cloth exists precisely so you don't have to. Skip this one if you don't own a Gourmia GAF616, and skip it if you want a pan you can also slide into a regular oven for cookies. It's a specialist tool, and it's honest about that.
SynHHergyx 3Pcs: Who It's For
The SynHHergyx 3Pcs is a set of three toaster oven pans, each measuring 9 x 6.7 x 1 inches with a 0.8MM wall thickness. The material is listed as high-quality heavy-duty carbon steel in a silver finish, and the pans are rated oven safe up to 400°F without warping or bending. That 1-inch rimmed depth is the design detail that earns its keep: it holds juices and sauces in the pan instead of letting them run into the bottom of your oven, while still allowing air to circulate for even browning.
Where this set shines is volume and variety. Three pans means you can prep cookies on one, roast vegetables on another, and have a third clean and ready — no mid-bake washing. They're sized for toaster ovens and small countertop ovens, which is exactly the niche a lot of people are stuck in: full-size sheet pans don't fit, and one flimsy pan isn't enough for a batch. The rimmed design also makes them plausible for lasagna, jelly rolls, chicken pieces, and pastries, not just flat cookies.
The trade-offs are real. This is a baking pan set, so it is not an air fryer basket insert — don't buy it expecting it to sit inside a Gourmia GAF616. Carbon steel needs a little care: the instructions say to let the pans cool to room temperature before washing, avoid sharp objects and scrubbing pads, and dry them thoroughly rather than leaving them to soak. Do that and they'll hold up; treat them like a scouring pad and the surface won't. Skip this set if you only need one pan, or if you're shopping specifically for an air fryer accessory.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a Gourmia GAF616 6QT air fryer → chengziyue 6QT. It's built for that exact model.
• Best for toaster oven baking → SynHHergyx 3Pcs. Three 9 x 6.7 inch pans that fit where full-size sheets won't.
• Best for cooking saucy or juicy food → SynHHergyx 3Pcs. The 1-inch rimmed sides contain juices and sauces.
• Best for batch baking → SynHHergyx 3Pcs. Three pans let you rotate batches without stopping to wash up.
• Best for lifting food out of a hot basket → chengziyue 6QT. The handle is designed for exactly that.
• Best for high-heat oven roasting → SynHHergyx 3Pcs. Rated oven safe to 400°F without warping.
• Best if you want a single-purpose, dialed-in fit → chengziyue 6QT. You adjust the feet once and it's seated for good.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to the appliance you actually own. If there's a Gourmia GAF616 6QT sitting on your counter, I'd buy the chengziyue 6QT — it's made for that basket, the handle and nonstick coating solve the two most annoying parts of air frying, and the four silicone feet let you dial in the fit. If your cooking happens in a toaster oven or small oven, I'd buy the SynHHergyx 3Pcs instead, because three rimmed pans that hold juices and take 400°F will get used far more often than one insert that doesn't fit your machine. Neither is a universal answer, and that's fine — buy for your oven, not for the category.
FAQ
how to clean air fryer drip tray
how to clean ninja air fryer drip tray
The general method is the same: cool, then wash with mild soap and a soft sponge, and avoid metal scouring pads. Note that the chengziyue 6QT is sized for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT, so it isn't a drop-in replacement for a Ninja basket — check your model's own accessory before buying.
how to clean breville air fryer drip tray
Treat it like any coated tray: let it cool, soak briefly if grease has baked on, then wipe with a non-abrasive sponge and dry thoroughly. The SynHHergyx 3Pcs pans follow the same logic — the maker says to cool them to room temperature before washing, skip sharp tools and scrubbing pads, and dry fully instead of soaking them for long periods.
how to clean cuisinart air fryer drip tray
Hand wash with warm soapy water and a soft cloth once the tray is cool, and dry it before storing. The chengziyue 6QT can go in the dishwasher, but always match the tray to your air fryer's model — the chengziyue plate is made for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT, not for Cuisinart baskets.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SIUDANGKA Crumb Tray Replacement vs Anniparts 304: Air Fryer, chengziyue 8PCS vs TOOHAO Air Fryer Magnets: Air Fryer, Nvkwca 6QT vs GWBSXM Air Fryer Grill