Post date: Nov 5, 2013 11:16:31 PM
A TURN-BACK-THE-CLOCK SEASON FOR CHICAGO
How 2013 Resembled 1948
As the baseball world focuses on the World Series, fans of the Chicago Cubs and White Sox are still trying to getget over a year they would rather forget. The 2013 season in Chicago tied 1948 for the gold standard of futility, with both teams finishing last for the first time in 65 years. If any baseball aficionado in the City of Big Shoulders thought they could clear their heads of six months of terrible baseball by watching the playoffs, the “ex-Cub and ex-Sox” factor seemed to rear its ugly head in too many postseason matchups to help them forget. To see the likes of Scott Baker, David DeJesus, Sam Fuld, Carlos Marmol, Sean Marshall, and Jake Peavy playing deep into September hurts, and the pain will be excruciating if baseball’s clown prince, Ryan Dempster, plays a successful role for the Red Sox. Speaking of discomfort, in a matter of four weeks Theo Epstein fired a manager, was unable to sign the guy whose potential availability caused the firing, witnessed his successor in Boston get to the World Series, and experienced three teams from his division –two with much younger lineups—reach the playoffs. Cherington’s Red Sox lost over 90 games in 2012 and followed it up by going to the World Series. Epstein’s Cubs lost over 90 games in 2012 and….lost over 90 games and finished in last place in 2013. Is Theo Epstein related to Wid Matthews? Just a thought; thus far their results are almost identical. On the other side of town nobody will ever mistake Rick Hahn for Frank Lane or Chuck Comiskey. To help Chicago baseball fans become more adept at accepting futility, let us turn the clock back the year that “Dewey Beat Truman” and more closely examine the Cubs and Sox of 1948.
The 1948 Chicago Cubs
The 1948 Chicago Cubs set a club record for most losses in a season, finishing in last place with a record of 64-90. They finished 27.5 games behind the pennant winning Boston Braves, against whom they were 6-16 for the season. Of course the Cubs’ poor performance on the field did not have any effect on their popularity. With every home game covered for the first time in history by WGN television, the Cubs drew 1,237,792 fans, fifth best in the National League. This was a remarkable achievement for a team that was in last place for all but 15 days from the first of June until the end of the season. At the start of 1948 owner Phil Wrigley and general manager Jim Gallagher were enthusiastic about the youth movement they had embarked upon to keep the Cubs competitive. The batting order and lineup in ’48 was as follows:
Hank Schenz, second base
Eddie Waitkus, first base
Hal Jeffcoat, center field
Andy Pafko, third base
Bill Nicholson, right field
Peanuts Lowrey, left field
Roy Smalley, shortstop
Bob Sheffing, catcher
The Cubs lineup had seven legitimate hitters in Waitkus, Jeffcoat, Pafko, Nicholson, Lowrey, and Sheffing. Waitkus hit .295 with 27 doubles and 11 stolen bases. Jeffcoat, who would eventually become an effective National League pitcher, hit .279. Pafko played 142 games at third base, a position he had never played before, and still hit .312 with 26 home runs, 30 doubles, and 104 RBI. Pafko also made the All-Star team and finished hgh in National League MVP voting. Nicholson’s average was only .261 but he had 19 homers and 26 doubles. Lowrey hit .294 and Scheffing hit .300, better than every catcher in the majors.
Nicholson provided one of the great thrills in Wrigley Field history in a game against the Cardinals when he got ahold of an Al Brazle fastball and just missed becoming the first player in history to hit the center field scoreboard. His tremendous 550+ blast sailed just to the right of the middle of the scoreboard, bounced off the building at the southeast corner of Waveland and Sheffield, and then hit the hood of a southbouind automobile. As the season progressed Phil Wrigley took note of how, regardless of the score, if Nicholson was going to be coming to bat in the late innings most of the crowd would hang around just to see him bat, even if they Cubs were bound to lose, and even though they were doomed to go nowhere in the standings. As the years progressed, if the Cubs were bad, they still always seemed to have a slugger; Hank Sauer, Ernie Banks, later on Dave Kingman, Sammy Sosa…it’s funny how that worked.
Unlike the offense, the pitching staff, with the exception of Johnny Schmitz, left a lot to be desired:
Johnny Schmitz, 18-12, 2.64
Russ Meyer, 10-10, 3.66
Dutch McColl, 4-13, 4.82
Hank Borowy, 5-10, 4.89
Bob Rush, 5-11, 3.92
Cub pitching highlights in 1948 were Schmitz and two isolated one-hit games. In addition to his sparkling numbers above, Schmitz pitched 18 complete games, his WHIP was only 1.169, and he led all major league pitchers in fewest hits per nine innings pitched. Meyer, the “Mad Monk”, whose experiences, exploits, and social activities at the Sheridan Plaza Hotel became legendary, missed a
no-hitter in an April game against the Cardinals when a scratch grounder to Andy Pafko at third was ruled a hit. Borowy, one of the heroes of the 1945 pennant who by 1948 was reaching the end of his career, threw a one-hitter against the Brooklyn Dodgers on the last day of August. Borowy faced the minimum 27 batters because Gene Hermanski, who got the only hit, was thrown out by Scheffing when he tried to steal second. To be fair, Cub hurlers were not helped by the fact that the team committed 186 errors, the highest total in the majors.
Almost everything else about the 1948 Cub season was a big disappointment. The much ballyhooed youth movement centered around Schenz, Smalley, outfielder Clarence Maddern, McColl, and Rush. Schenz was replaced in the lineup early in the season by Emil Verban. Smalley entered the majors as a highly touted power-hitting shortstop but posted a dismal .216 batting average, hit only four home runs, and had a league-high 34 errors at shortstop. Maddern hit only four homers in 80 games and was quickly replaced by Peanuts Lowrey. McColl set a club record with twelve consecutive losses. Rush showed some promise, winning only five games but having many hard-luck losses and striking out nearly twice as many hitters as he walked. Out of this quintet of youngsters only the tall, bespectacled Rsh would develop into a front-line major leaguer.
On August 27 the Cubs, mired in last place 18 games behind Boston, eclipsed the one million mark in attendance. Three days later Phil Wrigley took out a full page ad in all five Chicago newspapers, thanking the fans for their support, apologizing for the '48 rebuilding year being such a flop, vowing that Cub management did not just have an eye on attendance, and expressing a desire to build a winning team as badly as the fans wanted one. He and general manager Jim Gallagher backed up the truck after the season, sending Borowy, Meyer, Nicholson, and Waitkus to the rapidly improving Philadelphia Phillies, and also dispatching veteran catcher Clyde McCullough to the PIttsburgh Pirates. These trades made little difference, however. The Cubs finished in last place in 1949 and in seventh in 1950.
The 1948 Chicago White Sox
The penurious practices of Grace Copmiskey and the utter incompetence of general manager Leslie O'Connor finally caught up with the White Sox organization in 1948. As a consequence the team's harvest at the end of the year was a 51-101 record, good enough for last place, 44.5 games behind the pennant winning Cleveland Indians. Sox fans stayed away from the ballpart at 35th and Shields in droves, with only 777,844 clicks of the turnstiles for the entire season, an 11% drop in attendance from 1947 and an alarming 21% drop from 1946. Those that did show up at Comiskey usually saw the following lineup and batting order:
Don Kolloway, second base
Luke Appling, third base
Tony Lupien, first base
Pat Seery, left field
Cass Michaels, shortstop
Dave Philley, centerfield
Aaron Robinson, catcher
As a team the '48 Sox batted .251, seventh in the American League, managed just 55 home runs, and scored only 588 runs, the lowest totals in the majors. Their leading hitter was the young Dave Philley, who hit a respectable .287. Philley also led all major league centerfielders in assists (22) and double plays (6), these accomplishments occurring in a season when Richie Ashburn, the DiMaggio brothers, Larry Doby, Johnny Groth, Andy Pafko, Bobby Thomson, and Duke Snider were patrolling the same position.
Whatever power the anemic Sox hitters could generate came mostly from Pat Seery, who had 18 round-trippers and provided Sox
fans with the teams' most memorable offensive display in history. On July 18, in the first game of a doubleheader against the Philadelphia Athletics, Seery became the first Sox to hit four home runs in one game. In the fourth inning he completely cleared the roof of Shibe Park's double-decked left field stands, and in the fifth the portly slugger hit another tape measure blast that bounced off that same roof. Seery batted again in the sixth and reached the back row in the upper deck of those same left field bleachers, becoming the first player in history to hit three home runs in three consecutive innings. In the eleventh Seery's fourth round-tripper reached the left field upper deck and became the eventual game-winning hit. Long forgotten today, Seery was kind of a post-war Adam Dunn. During his career he hit an impressive 86 home runs in only 1,815 at bats, which averages out to about 30 per season, but he led all American League batters in strikeouts each of the four years he played, and had a poor .224 lifetime batting average for his career. Luke Appling led all Sox hitters in '48 with a .314 average and an impressive .423 on base percentage in what would be the second to last season in his Hall of Fame career.
The starting rotation in 1948, missing their ace Eddie Lopat for the first time in four seasons who went to New York in an ill-advised trade for Bill Wight, left a lot to be desired:
Bill Wight, 9-20, 4.80, 135 BB, 68 K
Joe Haynes, 9-10, 3.97, 60 BB, 49 K
Marino Pieretti, 8-10, 52 BB, 28 K
Randy Gumpert, 2-6, 3.97, 13 BB 31 K
The first thing that jumps off the page with this group is that they walked 250 batters and struck out only 176. The entire Sox pitching staff walked 673 batters and struck out 403; Gumpert weas the only one of 16 pitchers manager Ted Lyons sent to the mound who ended the season with more strikeouts than walks.
Like the Cubs, the '48 White Sox were poor from the start of the season until the end of September. They went 6-20 in May, and as if to prove that they were not waiting for the warm weather to heat them up, finished the season 7-18 in September. The Sox had a punishing 22 game road trip in July and went 5-17. As soon as the season ended Jack Onslow replaced Lyons as manager, O'Connor was fired, Frank Lane took over as general manager, and 22-year-old Chuck Comiskey was named vice president. Exactly one month after Lane came aboard, on November 10, 1948, Aaron Robinson was dispatched to Detroit for a crafty little lefty named Billy Pierce, and the go-go White Sox were conceived. While the gestation took almost three more seasons, the White Sox were primed for the greatest decade in their history.
+++++++++++++
So what will it be for Chicago's heroes in 2014? Will the history of the 1948 era repeat itself for the Cubs, with another 19 seasons of stumbling in the wilderness before they once again become respectable? And will the Sox' failures of 2013 mark the start of a slow but intelligent rebuilding process, with fifteen years of success to follow? For now let's just hope that Theo Epstein can sign no lesser an individual than his third choice for manager, and let's also hope that Rick Hahn can try to impersonate Frank Lane and learn how to back up the truck.