A Subtle Correction - Going Straight

When I was first learning how to paddle a canoe I was taught the ubiquitous 'J' stroke. This stroke was to be used by the stern paddler every three strokes to 'steer' the canoe in a straight line. Today I still use the 'J' stroke but only on occasion since there are many variations and alternatives. I still show new paddlers how to do a J and explain why it is important, I also let them know that there are alternatives. Learning the J initially is useful because it is relatively easy to learn and execute, most other corrective strokes are at least partly a variation on the J. I want to introduce a few of these alternatives and where they can be used for correcting the direction of the canoe.

The J stroke and its variations are done when needed and generally only for subtle corrections. When going in a straight line I prefer to think of doing small corrections rather than steering. If you want to steer a canoe, such as when going down a windy creek, landing at a dock (or shore), or doing canoe ballet, both paddlers must be involved using adequate and appropriate communication.

The reason that I was taught the 'J' in the first place was to correct for the canoe turning away from the stern paddling side. On flat calm water this happens for a very basic reason: the stern paddler is further away from the pivot point of the canoe and paddling is done off to one side. With greater leverage the canoe turns away from the stern paddlers side. The problem is exacerbated by not keeping the paddle vertical in the water, long paddling strokes, doing a 'sort of' sweep following the canoe shape, a canoe with lots of rocker, and having poor trim where the canoe weighted toward the front. Having a stronger paddler in the back is not as significant as many people think. In the end all the 'J' stroke does is push the stern of the canoe back into line with the bow.

Correction strokes should be done as soon as the canoe starts to wander away from your chosen course. Most experienced canoeists do a subtle correction with almost every stroke, usually without any thought. An easy way to determine when a correction is needed is to watch a marker, such as a tree on a distant shore, over the bow person's head. If the marker is to your paddling side of the bow persons head then do a J to bring the canoe back. If the marker is to the other side then do straight stokes or a light sweep. By the time you have done this a few thousand times you will no longer think about markers and correction strokes you will just think about going someplace and it will happen - very Zen like.

Switching sides is a common correction technique sometimes referred to the as the 'sit and switch, 'hut' or 'Minnesota hut' stroke. The name comes from the stern person calling out 'hut' each time there needs to be a correction and both paddlers switch sides. This technique works fine on flat water with two paddlers that are comfortable with the technique; it will move a canoe with minimal rocker quickly through the water. If the paddlers are not familiar with more traditional correction/steering techniques the use of the 'hut' stroke alone can have serious, and dangerous, consequences when conditions get rough. I would not want to paddle on a lake or river trip with someone who uses this as their sole correction technique.

In this article, I am only going to cover the 'J' stroke and its variations. I have provided names and descriptions for each stroke but I don't want to mislead you into thinking that there are seven different correction strokes. There is a continuous variation between all of the listed paddling strokes. Each of the following strokes shine under specific conditions but when paddling for long periods of time remember to use a variety of styles, body positions, and strokes (or at least variations along the continuum).

J 

The traditional J starts with a forward stroke then near the end of the stroke the power face of the paddle rotates away from the canoe and pushes out from the canoe. When I am paddling the push out portion of the stroke (bottoom of the J) is done by pulling my grip and back towards the middle of the canoe. Think of a lever with the fulcrum at your shaft hand. With practice the J portion of the stroke gets shorter and if you watch people that have paddled for years this becomes just a small twist or twitch near the end of the stroke. Most J variations follow the same theme where the power face rotates away from the canoe at some point during the stroke. The exception is the river J and rudder.

Canadian or knifing J

The Canadian is similar to a J through the first part of the stroke but there is less push out, the recovery is sliced partially through the water. During the recovery your grip hand is inside the canoe and usually lowered some what, near the middle of your chest. There is a slight pitch on the paddle during the recovery which provides the correction and makes it feel like you are lifting the water. This is a common variation on the J stroke - it works best with a thin blade and straight shaft paddle. 

Northwoods

The Northwoods is a short correction stroke, generally following the pattern of a Canadian stroke. The grip hand has more movement, following a circular pattern, than the shaft hand. The shaft hand provides a fulcrum point during the stroke. The grip hand is typically held across the grip, with fingers and thumb on one side, rather than on top "Northwoods" paddle grip is long and flat providing a platform for the palm. A typical Northwoods paddle is longer than a more traditional paddle making the cross grip both more comfortable and easier to use. A "Northwoods" grip is not required, but it does make paddling this style easier and more comfortable. There is significant variance in the interpretation of how to execute a Northwoods stroke. 

Rolling J or Silent stroke

 This stroke has similar characteristics to both the C and Canadian except the blade never leaves the water and the power face switches every stroke. The great advantage to this stroke is the blade is always in the water allowing for continuous correction. I often use this stroke when getting the canoe going and in windy conditions. This stroke works best with a thin blade and deep water. It can only be done with a straight shaft paddle since the power face switches with each stroke.

I have seen this referenced as a hunting stroke, and stealth stroke as well. The potentially pejorative 'Indian' stroke is still found in older manuals and a few other places.

Some people do a similar stroke with a River-J, in-water recovery, and no palm roll. It looks similar to the casual observer.

River J

This is a powerful stroke often used by river paddlers. Instead of using the power face for the correction the non-power face is used by rotating the power paddle face toward the canoe and doing a pry. The greatest advantage is that it allows for a quick transition from a forward stroke to a reverse or reverse sweep. A River J done with a bent shaft paddle is more difficult to execute properly often slowing the canoe and overcorrecting.

Note of Clarification (fall 2019): Paddle Canada no longer recognizes a 'River-J' as this is a combination of forward stroke and [stern] pry. The reference will be to a 'Stern Pry'. I will continue to use 'River-J' in my discussions as a convenient reference to a blended correction stroke with a change in power face.

Rudder (sleeping stern stroke) - don't mistake this for a River J.

This is an easy stroke to spot from a distance as the stern paddler is lying back on the stern deck with his hat pulled down to shade his eyes and his feet propped up on the stern thwart. A good stroke to use on a hot lazy afternoon in calm weather. If you are in the stern lie back and relax - let the bow paddler do all of the work. If you are in the bow with one of these lazy paddlers rock the canoe violently and quickly without notice and watch your stern partner fall in the water. Turn a bent shaft paddle backward to the rudder. 

With all of these strokes there are a few common problems to watch for: as with all paddling keep the paddle vertical and near the canoe, shorten your stroke down a little and don't delay or let the paddle hang at the end of a J or river J, make sure the blade is rotated enough (poor rotation with the J does not provide correction and with the River J it stops the canoe). Insure that the blade surface is perpendicular to the water surface at the end of the stroke; this may not be the case in the Rolling J or the Canadian. Be careful of the infamous 'Air J' where there is good rotation and push but it is done after the blade exits the water. Remember to do a correction stroke when it is needed; do several small corrections rather than one big one.

Don't be fooled into thinking that the J and its variations are the only way to correct the course of your canoe. There are a variety of other strokes and options, such as sweeps, draws and prys, 'sit and switch', and cross strokes that also allow for subtle corrections.

At the end of the day, for most of us, it is more important understand why things work rather than getting a specific stroke 'right'. Do what feels right and use what gets you safely home at night. No matter how much you read you will never really be able to paddle a canoe until you pick up a paddle and actually use it - quit reading this and get out and paddle.

Some other articles

Going Straight (Paddling.net)
Straight ahead: Four canoe strokes to move you forward (Ottawa Outdoors Magazine)