How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
These two products get compared a lot in air fryer bacon conversations, and honestly they solve opposite halves of the same problem. One is the metal pan you cook on and keep. The other is the paper you cook on and throw away. Once you see it that way, the decision is easier than it looks.
• CEKEE Quarter Sheet Pan — biggest strength: a complete 4-piece stainless steel set (two 12.59 × 9.84 × 1.18 inch pans plus two 11.57 × 8.97 inch wire racks) that is uncoated, rust-resistant and warp-resistant, so it stays in service for years.
• CEKEE Quarter Sheet Pan — biggest trade-off: it is real cookware, so it needs washing. Grease and baked-on residue have to be scrubbed off after each use to keep it bright.
• BYKITCHEN 12 — biggest strength: 200 precut 12 × 12 inch silicone-coated parchment sheets that are non-stick, waterproof and greaseproof up to 446°F, so trays stay clean and cleanup is basically a bin toss.
• BYKITCHEN 12 — biggest trade-off: it is disposable paper, not a cooking surface. It is built around the Ninja SP-series air fryer toaster ovens (SP151, SP351, SP101, SP201, SP301), and other brands or sizes need trimming.
• Who each is for: CEKEE for anyone who wants one durable baking set for oven, grill and picnic duty. BYKITCHEN for anyone who air fries bacon, fries and wings often and hates scrubbing baskets.
CEKEE is the "buy it once" pick. The set is four pieces — two quarter sheet pans and two wire racks — which means you can bake on one pan while the other holds something cooling on its rack. The pans measure 12.59 × 9.84 × 1.18 inches and the racks 11.57 × 8.97 inches, so the racks sit inside the pans as a proper roasting-and-draining combo rather than as loose accessories.
The material story is the real selling point. It is commercial-grade stainless steel with no coating, which means no chemical concern at high baking temperatures and no non-stick layer to flake or wear through. CEKEE also states the pans are rust-resistant and hard to warp, and the surface is smooth with curled edges so they are easy to grip. Heat distributes evenly across the tray, which the brand says helps avoid over-baking and can shorten baking time. Take that as a design claim, not a promise — but an uncoated stainless pan with a flat base is a sensible choice for even browning.
Maintenance is where you have to be honest with yourself. CEKEE calls the pans non-stick and dishwasher safe, but also says to gently scrub with soapy water and to fully remove oil and grease after every use to keep everything bright and clean. That is a small routine, not a chore — but it is routine. If you will not wash a pan, this is not your product.
BYKITCHEN 12: Who It's For
BYKITCHEN 12 is the cleanup shortcut, and it is designed around one specific job: keeping air fryer trays clean. The 12 × 12 inch sheets are precut to fit Ninja SP151, SP351, SP101, SP201 and SP301 air fryer toaster ovens. No measuring, no scissors, no wrestling with a roll. For any other brand or size, you trim to fit — which is easy enough with a square sheet, but worth knowing before you buy.
The paper itself is silicone-coated and food-grade, and BYKITCHEN lists it as non-stick, waterproof, greaseproof and heat-resistant to 446°F (230°C). In practice that covers bacon, fries, fried chicken, wings and anything else that spits grease, because the sheet catches the drips and crumbs instead of letting them bake onto the tray. There are 200 sheets in the pack, and the item form is a flat sheet, so they store neatly.
BYKITCHEN also positions these as multi-purpose: sandwich wrapping paper, deli sheets and food basket liners for burgers, fries and fried chicken. That makes them genuinely useful beyond the air fryer if you host parties or pack lunches.
The one warning to take seriously is BYKITCHEN's own note: put enough food on the sheet to weigh it down, and keep it away from the heating element, because loose parchment near a hot element can burn. That is standard parchment-paper common sense, but it matters more in a small air fryer oven where the element sits close to the tray. Skip BYKITCHEN if you want a permanent pan, if you bake things that need a rack for airflow, or if you own an air fryer outside the Ninja SP lineup and do not want to trim each sheet.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer bacon with almost no cleanup → BYKITCHEN 12. The sheet catches the grease; the tray stays clean.
• Best for reusable, long-term cookware → CEKEE Quarter Sheet Pan. Uncoated stainless steel that resists rust and warping.
• Best for exact fit in Ninja SP-series air fryer ovens → BYKITCHEN 12. Precut 12 × 12 inch sheets, no trimming needed.
• Best for draining grease off food → CEKEE Quarter Sheet Pan. The wire racks lift food out of the fat instead of letting it sit in it.
• Best for parties, deli service and food baskets → BYKITCHEN 12. 200 sheets double as wrapping and serving paper.
• Best for small kitchens → both, honestly. CEKEE pans stack flat; BYKITCHEN sheets are thin and store anywhere.
• Best if you refuse to scrub → BYKITCHEN 12. Best if you refuse to keep rebuying → CEKEE Quarter Sheet Pan.
For air fryer bacon specifically, I would buy BYKITCHEN 12. Bacon is the messiest thing most people cook in an air fryer, and a precut 12 × 12 inch sheet that fits the Ninja SP series and takes the grease with it when you bin it is exactly the right tool for that job — just keep food on the sheet and away from the element. That said, I would not want it as my only cooking surface. In my opinion the smarter setup is both: BYKITCHEN for greasy air fryer sessions, CEKEE Quarter Sheet Pan for everything you actually want to bake, roast or grill on a rack. If you can only pick one and you cook bacon more than you bake, go BYKITCHEN. If you bake more than you air fry, go CEKEE.
how to air fryer bacon
Lay the strips on a liner or tray in a single layer so air can move around them, and keep the parchment weighted down with food so it does not lift toward the heating element. Bacon releases a lot of fat, so a greaseproof liner like BYKITCHEN's, rated to 446°F, keeps the basket clean. If you prefer draining, a rack over a quarter sheet pan like CEKEE's lifts the bacon out of the fat instead.
how to air fryer bacon in the oven
If you mean the air fryer mode on a toaster oven, treat it like a small oven: use a pan and rack, or line the tray with a precut sheet. BYKITCHEN's 12 × 12 inch sheets are sized for Ninja SP151, SP351, SP101, SP201 and SP301 air fryer toaster ovens, so they drop straight in. CEKEE's quarter pan with its wire rack also fits most toaster ovens and gives you a reusable option.
how to air fryer bacon uk
The method is the same wherever you are — single layer, space between strips, liner or rack underneath to handle the fat. What changes is the equipment you can get. The main thing to check is your air fryer's basket or tray size, since BYKITCHEN's sheets are cut for the Ninja SP series and other sizes need trimming to fit.
how to air fryer bacon wrapped sirloin
Bacon-wrapped steak is thicker than plain bacon, so give it more room and expect more drips. Use a liner to catch the grease, or a rack over a pan so the meat is not sitting in fat. Either way, keep the food clear of the heating element, and remember parchment only stays put when there is enough food on top of it.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: CEKEE Quarter Sheet Pan vs Lodgisity Air Fryer Disposable, BYKITCHEN 220pcs vs GeeRic 100: Air Fryer Pizza Pan, HONGBAKE 2 vs YeKuKing 16: Air Fryer Pizza Pan