We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a simple, full-coverage barrier that keeps your air fryer basket clean and doubles as a liner for your oven, microwave, or fridge, choose Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer; if you need to cook more food at once with a stackable stainless steel system that comes with a complete accessory kit, choose OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack.
• Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer — biggest strength: a straight-sided 8.5" x 8.5" silicone mat that covers the full basket instead of tapering inward, in a 3-pack of pastel colors.
• Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: it's a liner, not a cooking structure. It protects and simplifies cleanup but doesn't add cooking surface or lift food for airflow.
• OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack — biggest strength: a 2-tier stackable 304 stainless steel rack that roughly doubles usable cooking height, plus 25 liners, a silicone mini oven mitt, an oil brush, and rubber feet.
• OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack — biggest trade-off: it's sized for 4–6 QT square baskets at 8.2" x 8.2", so larger or round fryers may not be a good match, and it asks a bit more of you at cleanup time than a single mat.
• Who each pick is for: Cee & Dee for anyone who hates scrubbing the basket and wants a low-effort, reusable liner; OFFKITSLY for anyone who wants to cook two layers of food at once and prefers a metal, kit-in-a-box approach.
The Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer is a 3-pack of square silicone mats, each 8.5" x 8.5", made from BPA-free, food-grade silicone. That's the whole idea, and it's a good one: you drop a mat into the basket, cook on top of it, and the basket itself stays largely free of grease, crumbs, and baked-on residue. The detail that separates it from a lot of generic liners is the straight-sided shape. Tapered liners sit inside the basket with gaps around the edges, so oil and small bits slide underneath anyway. A square mat sized to the basket footprint covers more of that floor and catches more of the mess.
The perforated design matters too. Holes let hot air move through the mat so food still crisps rather than steaming in its own moisture. And because silicone is heat-stable and non-stick by nature, cleanup is a rinse under warm soapy water or a trip through the dishwasher.
Beyond the air fryer, the mats work as liners for an oven tray, a microwave turntable, or a refrigerator shelf. Silicone doesn't mind cold, so using one under produce or leftovers in the fridge is a reasonable secondary job. Three mats in the pack means you can keep one in rotation while another dries.
Who should skip it: if your goal is to fit more food into the basket, this won't help. It's a protective layer, not a capacity extender. And if you specifically want metal rather than silicone, this isn't that product.
OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack: Who It's For
The OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack takes a different approach entirely. It's a 2-tier stackable rack made from 304 stainless steel, measuring 8.2" x 8.2" x 1.57" per rack, with a stated capacity of 6 quarts and compatibility aimed at 4–6 QT fryers. The brand lists fits for Ninja models including the Pro 5 QT AF141 and the Crispi portable glass system, Cosori Pro 5 quart, and Chefman 5 QT/6 QT units. The honest caveat, which OFFKITSLY states directly, is that you should measure your basket before buying. Square baskets in that size range will fit; a large round basket or an 8-quart-and-up model likely won't.
The point of a stackable rack is vertical cooking. Instead of one layer of wings on the basket floor, you get two levels, so you can roast vegetables on the bottom tier and chicken wings on top, or run a batch of nuggets and a batch of steak bites at the same time. Lifting food off the floor also lets hot air circulate underneath it, which is how you get browning on the underside without flipping every piece. That's the real functional difference from a flat liner.
The materials story is solid: 304 stainless steel, BPA-free, heat-resistant, rust-proof, with a polished surface and rounded edges so there are no burrs when you handle it. It's dishwasher-safe or hand-washable. Four rubber feet are included to keep the rack from sliding around inside the basket.
Then there's the kit. OFFKITSLY bundles 25 air fryer liners to prevent sticking, a silicone mini oven mitt for pulling hot racks out, and an oil brush for basting. Two racks are included, plus the feet. For someone starting from zero on air fryer accessories, that's a fairly complete starting point in one box.
Who should buy it: people who cook for two or more and keep running out of basket space, anyone cooking mixed foods in one session, and buyers who want a metal rack they can also use as an oven baking tray, a steamer rack, or a drainer for fruit and vegetables.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for mess prevention → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. The straight-sided 8.5" square covers the basket floor with fewer gaps than tapered liners.
• Best for cooking more food at once → OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack. The 2-tier stackable design adds a second cooking level inside the same basket.
• Best for airflow and crispiness → OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack. Lifting food off the floor lets hot air reach all sides, which is the whole reason it exists.
• Best for a complete accessory kit → OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack. Two racks, 25 liners, a silicone mini mitt, an oil brush, and four rubber feet all come together.
• Best for multi-appliance use → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. The silicone mats are also intended for ovens, microwaves, and refrigerators, not just the air fryer.
• Best for dishwasher-friendly simplicity → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. Both are dishwasher-safe, but one flat mat is easier to load and stack than a two-tier rack.
• Best for fit confidence in a 4–6 QT square fryer → OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack. It's explicitly sized and listed against common 5 QT and 6 QT models — just verify your basket first.
• Best for a reusable, plastic-free liner → Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer. BPA-free food-grade silicone, three to a pack, no disposable parchment needed.
In my opinion, most people torn between these two should buy the OFFKITSLY Air Fryer Rack — not because the Cee & Dee mats are weaker, but because the rack solves a problem you'll hit every week, while a liner solves one you'll hit every day but in a milder way. If you regularly wish you could fit more wings, more veggies, or two different foods in one cook, the stackable 304 stainless steel design is the more useful upgrade, and the bundled liners, mitt, and brush mean you're not buying accessories separately.
That said, if your basket is a large or round model, or if your only real complaint is scrubbing, I'd take the Cee & Dee Square Air Fryer without hesitation. Three straight-sided silicone mats for the air fryer, oven, and fridge is a genuinely practical set, and the full-coverage square shape is the smarter design choice for the mess problem specifically. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your basket and your cooking style.
FAQ
It depends on your basket. OFFKITSLY sizes it at 8.2" x 8.2" and lists compatibility with 4–6 QT models, including several Ninja and Cosori 5 QT units and Chefman 5 QT/6 QT fryers. Measure your basket before ordering, especially if you own a large round fryer.
You can, but both of these change the experience. The Cee & Dee mat cuts cleanup time by keeping grease and crumbs off the basket. The OFFKITSLY rack adds a second cooking tier and lifts food so hot air circulates underneath, which helps with even browning.
The Cee & Dee mats are simpler: flat, flexible silicone that rinses or goes in the dishwasher and stacks in a drawer. The OFFKITSLY rack is also dishwasher-safe with a polished, rust-proof finish, but it has two tiers plus feet, so there's more to wash and more to store.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWYSY Air Fryer Basket vs GARNITOXU Air Fryer Rack, GWBSXM Air Fryer Rack vs mutvle Air Fryer Liners, TOHONFOO Heat Resistant Mats vs GWBSXM Oven Rack: Air Fryer