We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-17 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a replacement case for your AirPods 4th Generation with a 5-minute quick-charge top-up and a 1-year warranty, choose CCAN Charging Case Compatible; if you need a case built for your AirPods Pro 3 (2025) that can carry you through a full day on a single case charge, choose Baiyx Replacement Charging Case.
• CCAN's biggest strength: Fast-charge behaviour — 5 minutes in the case gives you about 1 hour of listening, and a fully drained pair refills in roughly 30 minutes.
• CCAN's biggest trade-off: It fits only the 4th-generation AirPods (model numbers A3053/A3050/A3054/A3056/A3055/A3057) and nothing else, and neither earbuds nor a Type-C cable are included.
• Baiyx's biggest strength: Capacity and safety — the case is rated for up to 3 full charge cycles of the earbuds, and its built-in chip guards against over-charging, over-heating and short circuits.
• Baiyx's biggest trade-off: It only works with AirPods Pro 3 (A3065/A3063/A3064), and its stated warranty is the shorter of the two.
• Pick CCAN if you own AirPods 4 and want the fastest possible top-up plus the longer warranty.
• Pick Baiyx if you own AirPods Pro 3 and want maximum charge cycles and protective circuitry.
This is a purpose-built replacement shell for the 4th-generation AirPods, and it says so plainly. The compatibility list is narrow — model numbers A3053, A3050, A3054, A3056, A3055 and A3057 — and it explicitly will not work with the 1st, 2nd or 3rd generation, nor with any Pro model. If your earbuds match that list, you're the exact buyer this case was designed for; if they don't, walk away.
Two things to plan around. First, the box contains the case only — no earbuds, no Type-C cable — so if you don't already own a spare cable, factor that in. Second, the shell is hard plastic, which protects the case itself but is a basic enclosure rather than a ruggedised one. In my opinion, this is the pick for a current AirPods 4 owner who wants fast turnaround and a 1-year warranty, and the wrong pick for anyone with older or Pro-model earbuds.
Baiyx Replacement Charging Case: Who It's For
Baiyx's case targets a different generation entirely: AirPods Pro 3, specifically models A3065, A3063 and A3064. The listing is blunt about the exclusions — it is not compatible with AirPods 1, 2, 3 or 4, nor with Pro 1 or Pro 2. So before anything else, check the model number on your earbuds.
Assuming you match, the headline number is capacity. Baiyx rates the case at up to 3 full charge cycles for the earbuds, with the earbuds reaching full in about 30 minutes and the case itself charging in roughly 2 hours. That cycle count is the real selling point: it means you can head out for a long day and top your earbuds up repeatedly without hunting for a wall outlet. Charging is supported both wirelessly and by wire, and there's a Bluetooth pairing button so the case syncs with your original earbuds in seconds. An LED indicator shows the current power level.
The other differentiator is the electronics inside. Baiyx describes a built-in chip with protection against over-charging, over-heating, short circuits, overvoltage, overcurrent and overload — a sensible inclusion for something that sits on a charger overnight. The housing is ABS plastic, finished in white, and described as odourless, scratch-resistant, shockproof and non-slip, which is a more protective story than a plain hard shell. The trade-offs: the stated warranty is 180 days rather than a year, and the case ships without earbuds, so it's strictly a replacement for a lost or broken case. In my opinion, this is the stronger pick for an AirPods Pro 3 owner who cares most about total runtime and safe charging.
• Best for fast top-ups → CCAN. 5 minutes of charge for about 1 hour of listening is the standout figure here.
• Best for all-day capacity → Baiyx. Up to 3 full charge cycles means fewer trips to a charger.
• Best for AirPods 4 owners → CCAN. It's built for A3053/A3050/A3054/A3056/A3055/A3057 and nothing else.
• Best for AirPods Pro 3 owners → Baiyx. Built for A3065/A3063/A3064, with explicit warnings against every other generation.
• Best for charging safety features → Baiyx. Over-charge, over-heat and short-circuit protection is spelled out.
• Best for warranty length → CCAN. A 1-year warranty against Baiyx's 180 days.
• Best for a more protective outer shell → Baiyx. ABS housing described as shockproof and non-slip versus a basic hard plastic enclosure.
• Best if you want both wired and wireless charging → either. Both support Type-C/wired input and wireless charging.
In my opinion, the decision here is made by your earbuds before it's made by the specs — these two cases don't overlap on compatibility at all. If you own AirPods 4, I'd buy the CCAN case: the 5-minute-to-1-hour fast charge is genuinely useful, and the 1-year warranty is the longer of the two. If you own AirPods Pro 3, I'd buy the Baiyx case instead, because 3 full charge cycles and the built-in protection circuitry matter more day to day than a faster single top-up. Check your model number first — that's the only thing that can send you to the wrong one.
FAQ
No. Baiyx lists compatibility only for AirPods Pro 3, models A3065/A3063/A3064, and explicitly excludes AirPods 1, 2, 3, 4 and Pro 1 and Pro 2.
No to both. CCAN notes that earbuds and the Type-C cable are not included, and Baiyx likewise ships the case only — it's a replacement for a lost or damaged case, not a full earbud set.
I don't quote prices here, since they change often. Use the "Check latest price on Amazon" button on this page to see the current cost of each before you decide.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.