How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a complete, plug-and-play wired headset you can hand to a kid or use straight out of the box on an Xbox controller, choose BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset; if you need to turn a pair of Bose QuietComfort 45 headphones you already own into a proper gaming headset for Xbox, choose Gneinour QC45. These two products are not really rivals — one is a finished headset, the other is an upgrade kit — but shoppers searching for the best comfortable gaming headset for Xbox keep landing on both, so here is the honest breakdown.
• BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset — biggest strength: a complete over-ear wired headset with a built-in mic, 50mm dynamic drivers, 225g ultralight build and 3.5mm plug that works across PS5, PS4, Xbox, PC and Switch.
• BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset — biggest trade-off: it is wired, pink, and the mic is fixed to the headset rather than detachable; it is also a kids/family-oriented product rather than a premium audio one.
• Gneinour QC45 — biggest strength: a detachable boom mic cable with mute switch, steelFlex adjustable arm and gold-plated connectors that converts Bose QC45 headphones into a gaming headset, plus a 3.5mm Y-splitter for desktop PCs.
• Gneinour QC45 — biggest trade-off: it is not a headset at all — it is a 5g cable accessory, and it only makes sense if you already own compatible Bose QC45 headphones.
• Who each pick is for: BUTFULAKE for anyone who wants one box, one cable and instant Xbox gaming; Gneinour for existing Bose QC45 owners who want to add voice chat without buying a second headset.
The BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset is a finished product: over-ear cups, a rounded enclosure in metal and plastic, a pink finish, and a hardwired 3.5mm jack. You plug it in and you are done. The 50mm dynamic drivers run a 20Hz–20,000Hz frequency range, and the passive noise cancellation relies on the cups sealing around your ears rather than any electronics. That is the honest version of "noise cancelling" at this level — it muffles background chatter, it does not silence a lawnmower.
What it does best is remove friction. The headset weighs 225g, which is genuinely light for an over-ear design, and BUTFULAKE pairs that with protein-leather-style earpads they describe as breathable and a 15° up/down adjustable earmuff. For long sessions — homework, online classes, a two-hour co-op run — those two details matter more than any spec sheet number. The mic is a soft rubber anti-static type mounted on the headset, and the volume control sits on the headset itself, so there is no dongle hunting or menu diving.
For Xbox specifically, the connection path is simple: the newer Xbox One and Series controllers have a 3.5mm port, so the headset plugs straight in. If you are on an older Xbox One controller without that port, you would need an extra Microsoft adapter, which is not included — that is a real limitation worth knowing before you buy.
Gneinour QC45: Who It's For
The Gneinour QC45 is a completely different animal, and I want to be blunt about that so nobody buys the wrong thing. It is a boom microphone cable — 5 grams of copper and TPE — designed to plug into Bose QuietComfort 45 wireless noise cancelling headphones and turn them into a gaming headset. If you do not own QC45 headphones, this product does nothing for you.
If you do own them, it solves a real problem. Bose QC45 headphones are excellent for music and travel, but they have no microphone for game chat. Gneinour's cable adds one: a flexible, detachable boom arm with a spring-loaded steelFlex section you can bend to any angle, plus an inline mute switch so you can cut your mic without touching a menu. The connectors are gold-plated and the conductors are oxygen-free copper, which is the standard recipe for keeping signal loss low over a cable run.
Two details make it more useful than a generic mic cable. First, the PVC jacket is described as soft and tangle-resistant with reduced stethoscope effect — that thumping noise you get when a stiff cable rubs against your shirt. Second, the package includes a 3.5mm female-to-dual-male Y-splitter, which is what you need to connect a TRRS headset to a desktop PC, laptop or all-in-one that has separate headphone and microphone jacks. That splitter alone is the reason a lot of people buy this kit.
Compatibility is broad: PS4, PS5, Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S controllers, PCs, laptops, tablets, iPhones and Android phones — anything with a 3.5mm jack. Gneinour also lists a 365-day warranty, which is a reasonable signal for a small accessory brand.
Who should buy it: Bose QC45 owners who game on console or PC and want voice chat without buying a second headset, streamers who already like their QC45 sound, and desktop users who need the Y-splitter. Who should skip it: anyone without QC45 headphones, anyone who wants a self-contained headset, and anyone who wants wireless mic audio — this is a wired solution.
• Best for a complete, ready-to-use Xbox headset → BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset. Everything is in one box; plug into the controller and play.
• Best for existing Bose QC45 owners → Gneinour QC45. It adds a mic and mute switch to headphones you already trust, for a fraction of the bulk.
• Best for kids and school use → BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset. The 225g weight, adjustable earmuffs and 3.5mm plug make it a natural fit for school supplies and shared family devices.
• Best for desktop PC setups with separate mic and headphone jacks → Gneinour QC45. The included Y-splitter is exactly the adapter those machines require.
• Best for travel and commuting audio → Gneinour QC45 (paired with QC45 headphones). Active noise cancelling lives in the Bose headphones; the cable is the add-on.
• Best for passive noise isolation during gaming → BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset. The over-ear seal does the work without batteries or charging.
• Best for a detachable, replaceable microphone → Gneinour QC45. The boom mic detaches, so a damaged cable is a cheap swap rather than a dead headset.
• Best if you want zero setup decisions → BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset. No pairing, no adapters, no compatibility homework beyond checking your controller has a 3.5mm port.
For most people reading this — especially anyone shopping for an Xbox headset for a kid or a shared family console — I would buy the BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset. It is the only one of the two that is actually a headset, it works on Xbox, PS5, PS4, PC and Switch with the same 3.5mm plug, and its 225g weight and adjustable over-ear design make it one of the more comfortable budget options for long sessions. I would only pick the Gneinour QC45 if I already owned Bose QC45 headphones and wanted to add game chat without buying a second pair of cans. In my opinion, buy the accessory only when you already own the headset it was built for.
Yes, on controllers that have a 3.5mm audio port — which covers the newer Xbox One controllers and Xbox Series X/S controllers. If you have an older Xbox One controller without that port, you would need an additional Microsoft adapter, which BUTFULAKE does not include.
No. The Gneinour QC45 is a replacement boom microphone cable made specifically for Bose QuietComfort 45 wireless noise cancelling headphones. Without those headphones, the cable has nothing to attach to and no purpose.
The BUTFULAKE Gaming Headset is the better fit here — it is a self-contained 225g over-ear headset with breathable pads and passive noise isolation, so it works for music, films and quiet listening without any other gear. The Gneinour QC45 depends entirely on the headphones you pair it with.
Both are budget-tier in their categories, but I am not going to quote numbers — they move around. Check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page before you decide, and weigh it against whether you already own QC45 headphones, since that single fact decides which of these two actually makes sense for you.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: HAUSBELL Open Ear vs SVJEFY Single Bluetooth5.4, WolfLawS Computer Speakers vs AOC 2.4GHz comparison, homicozy Kids Ear Protection vs YFSFQS USB Type C, WC PadZ QC35 vs Gobelieve Replacement Earpads: Memory Foam