BüchelLab
Welcome to the BüchelLab
We are part of the Department for Systems Neuroscience at the University Medical Center Hamburg Eppendorf (UKE)
Through the PI (Christian Büchel) we are also affiliated with the Institute of Psychology at Hamburg University
News
New paper in Neuron by Andreas Strube, showing that self treatment is more potent than external treatment and that this is mediated by a change in expectation. Computational modeling and EEG results suggest that in a Bayesian pain model, the prior is shifted by agency. In addition, we also manipulated "classic" expectation effects and found that the agency effect is additive to the expectation effect.
Paper in PLoS Biology by Bjoern Horing, identifying reinforcement learning relevant signals in the anterior insula. Unsigned prediction errors are represented in the anterior part, whereas signed prediction errors are represented more posterior, in areas also coding for pain intensity.
RTG 2753 on Emotional Learning funded! Together with colleagues from Nijmegen we will investigate the neuronal basis of emotional learning over the next 4.5 (hopefully next 9) years.
Paper in eLife by Alexandra Tinnermann illustrating how connectivity between the cortex-subcortex(PAG) - spinal cord orchestrates opioid (remifentanil) analgesia. Interestingly, regional responses did not disssociate between opioid analgesia from unspecifc analgesia.
Check out our paper in eLife by Andreas Strube illustrating the temporal orchestration of predictions and prediction errors in pain. We observed an early expectation related response in alpha-beta frequency bands, followed by a later prediction error related response in the gamma band. Interestingly the gamma band response was negatively correlated with the magnitude of the prediction error.
New paper accepted at Neuroimage about standards in cortico-spinal fMRI in collaboration with Julien Cohen-Adad from Canada.
SFB 289 funded! Together with colleagues from Essen and Marburg we will investigate treatment expectation effects in pain over the next 4 (hopefully next 12) years.
The lab has just been awarded an ERC Advanced grant. The project PainPersist will investigate mechanisms underlying the trajectory from acute to chronic pain. The project will start in 2021 and will be conducted by a team of PhD students, PostDocs and study coordinators. We are now recruiting PostDocs for the first phase of the grant. PhD positions will start in January 2022.
Lab Christmas Party 2022
A bit cold
2022 Summer Party
What we do
Our lab is mainly interested in pain, fear and decision making. These topics are naturally intertwined, for example in classical conditioning, an example for fear learning, the organsim learns to predict a painful stimulus (e.g. shock). In addition, aversive outcomes such as pain have a tremendous influence on our behavior and especially on our decision making, which is mainly centered around the idea of seeking pleasant and avoiding aversive states e.g. those involving pain.
We try to identify mechanims behind these phenomena using a multi-level approach: analysis of behavior (e.g. eye-tracking), analysis of autonomic responses (e.g. skin conductance, pupil size) computational modeling of the underlying algorithmic and neural processes, multimodal neuroimaging (fMRI and EEG) of these processes, and pharmacological challenges to investigate the causal role of specific neurotransmitter systems.
These studies will not only contribute to our understanding of basic neuroscience mechanisms, but also provide novel ideas and approaches in clinical neuroscience, which could eventually improve prevention, diagnosis, prognosis and disease progression assessment in neuropsychiatric disorders including chronic pain.
Pain
In the domain of pain we study very basic physiological mechanisms of pain processing and more complex interactions with cognitive systems.
One example of a basic mechanism is the longstanding and heavily debated question whether certain brain areas play a special role in pain processing. Many previous studies on this topic confounded pain with salience, but we have now suggested a novel approach how to disentangle pain from salience (preprint of Horing et al.; details below).
In addition, we have a major focus on the cognitive modulation of pain processing. A prime example of this effect is the placebo and nocebo effect in which expectation and experience can shape pain perception. Together with our Physics group, we have developed novel MR protocols to investigate spinal cord and brain responses simultaneously. This method was used to show that placebo analgesia involves modulation at the spinal cord level (Eippert et al., 2009) and more recently that also nocebo nyperalgesia involves a spinal mechanism (Tinnermann et al., 2017). We also employ pharmacological interventions and computational models, to identify the neuronal mechanisms underlying these effects.
Fear
After initial studies on classical conditioning, we have a focus on generalization in fear learning or put simply why we fear something that we have never encountereed, but what looks similar to a dangerous object. Here we employ Bayesian models to explain how the percpetual distance can explain fear generalization (Onat and Büchel 2015; preview by Katherine Whalley). We often use very simple paradigms such as classical conditioning, because this enables a link of our research to existing animal work. Methodologically, we are also bridging the gap between human neuroscientific research and animal neurophysiology by using high resolution neuroimaging techniques for instance to investigate emotional processing in different subnuclei of the amygdala.
Decision making
We have a longstanding interest in value based decision making, temporal discounting and hedonic processing. We currently focus on the opioid system and for instance could show that hedonic processing in the ventral striatum depends on endogoenous opioids (Büchel et al., 2018; details below). An additional interest lies in the predictive value of neuronal markers for the development of addictive behavior. As part of the IMAGEN study together with our partner Brain Knutson at Stanford, we could show that hypoactivation of the ventral striatum and the dlPFC at age 14 can predict problematic drug use at age 16 (Büchel et al., 2017)
Examples of recent projects
Pain or salience?
We investigated the longstanding issue whether "pain related brain areas" are simply activated by salience (spoiler: the dpIns is not) and tested this by comparing pain to aversive sounds which were salience matched (skin conductance). Full preprint on biorxiv.
Opioids and hedonic processing?
It has been speculated that the pleasure of a reward in humans is mediated by endogenous opioids. Using the opioid receptor antagonist naloxone and fMRI we can show that blocking opioid receptors reduced pleasure associated with viewing erotic pictures and that this was paralleled by a reduction of activation in the ventral striatum, lateral orbitofrontal cortex, amygdala, hypothalamus and medial prefrontal cortex at reward delivery, but not during reward anticipation. Full paper at eLIfe.
Does the price of medication affect side effects?
Patients in clinical clinical trials often complain of side effects, even if they are part of the placebo group and thus never received any active medication. This nocebo drmatically interferes with medical treatment. Our study shows that higher value (i.e price tag) of a a drug can further enhance the nocebo effect and the underlying neural network dynamics involving the dspinalk cord, PAG and anterior cingulate cortex. Full paper in Science.