How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a pair of replacement cushions built around high-density memory foam and protein leather for a specific H12 BT 5.0 noise-cancelling headset, choose Brrnoo Headphone Earpads Replacement; if you need new pads for a Skullcandy Crusher, Hesh or Venue model and want the widest model coverage, choose BAKDIK Replacement Ear Pads.
• Brrnoo's biggest strength: a comfort-first build — high-density memory foam wrapped in protein leather, with reinforced stitching and a stretchy, shape-holding fit designed for long sessions.
• Brrnoo's biggest trade-off: the fit is narrow. It's aimed at the H12 BT 5.0 noise-cancelling headset, so it is not a one-size-fits-most pad.
• BAKDIK's biggest strength: broad Skullcandy compatibility — Crusher Wireless, Crusher Evo, Crusher ANC, Hesh 3 and Venue ANC are all covered, with a thickened foam layer for noise blocking.
• BAKDIK's biggest trade-off: it is a Skullcandy-focused pad, so if your headset isn't on that list, this isn't your pair.
• Who Brrnoo is for: owners of that specific H12 BT 5.0 headset who want a plush, pressure-free cushion and a no-tools swap.
• Who BAKDIK is for: Skullcandy Crusher/Hesh/Venue owners who want original-style fit, easy installation and a spare set of two pads in the box.
Brrnoo's pitch here is comfort and materials rather than universal fit. The pads use high-density memory foam under a protein leather cover, and the brand leans hard on the idea that the foam contours to your ears instead of pressing on them. That matters more than it sounds. Most of the reason people replace earpads is that the originals have flattened out, and a flattened pad stops sealing — which means bass thins out and outside noise creeps in. A fresh memory foam layer restores that seal, and Brrnoo also points to improved sound isolation as a result.
The second thing worth knowing is the construction. Brrnoo describes reinforced stitching and an upgraded protein leather that keeps its shape while staying elastic — the pads flex around your ears without clamping. In my opinion, that "snug without pressure" balance is the real selling point for anyone who wears headphones for hours at a desk, on a commute, or through long gaming or editing sessions. The pads are also designed to be installed without tools: pull the old ones off, snap the new ones on, done. No prying, no glue, no fiddling.
The catch is compatibility, and it's a real one. Brrnoo states these pads are designed specifically for the H12 BT 5.0 noise-cancelling headphones. That's a narrow target. If you own that headset, this is a clean, purpose-built match. If you own anything else — a Skullcandy, a Sony, a Bose — you should assume these won't fit unless you confirm the mount style yourself. There's also a 90-day manufacturer warranty noted on the listing, which is shorter than what some competitors offer, so factor that in if you want a longer safety net.
BAKDIK Replacement Ear Pads: Who It's For
BAKDIK takes the opposite approach: instead of one headset, it covers a family. The pads are listed as compatible with Skullcandy Crusher Wireless, Crusher Evo Wireless, Crusher ANC, Hesh 3 Wireless, the Crusher Evo Collina Strada edition, the Crusher Evo Budweiser Limited Edition, and Skullcandy Venue ANC. If you own almost any recent Crusher or Hesh model, you're probably covered. That breadth is the whole reason to pick this pair.
The materials are familiar territory: protein leather over memory foam, with BAKDIK specifically calling the foam "thickened." That thickness does two jobs — it keeps the plush, original-style feel so you can wear them for hours without ear pressure, and it improves noise blocking by giving you a better seal against your head. BAKDIK also claims the foam retains the original sound signature rather than coloring it, which is the right goal for a replacement pad. You're not buying an upgrade; you're buying your headphones back.
Installation follows the same logic as most Crusher pads: remove the old cushions, align the card position, press the new pads into place. BAKDIK says they seat tightly like the originals and won't fall off easily, and the process takes seconds. You get two pads in the box — one full set — plus a stated 24-hour response window if something goes wrong. The warranty is listed at one year, which is a notably longer commitment than Brrnoo's 90 days.
The trade-off is focus. These are Skullcandy pads. The dimensions (roughly 3.66 x 3.07 x 0.98 inches) and the mounting style are built around those models, so they won't transfer to a random over-ear headset. The color is black, and that's the only option listed. If you want a specific finish or a pad for a non-Skullcandy brand, keep looking.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a specific H12 BT 5.0 headset → Brrnoo Headphone Earpads Replacement. It's built for that model, so fit is the point.
• Best for Skullcandy Crusher, Hesh or Venue owners → BAKDIK Replacement Ear Pads. The compatibility list is the deciding factor here.
• Best for wide model coverage → BAKDIK. Six-plus Skullcandy variants versus one target headset.
• Best for reinforced, shape-holding stitching → Brrnoo. Its listing emphasizes reinforced stitching and upgraded protein leather.
• Best for thicker noise-blocking foam → BAKDIK. The foam is explicitly described as thickened for better isolation.
• Best for a longer warranty → BAKDIK. One year versus Brrnoo's 90 days.
• Best for plush, contouring comfort on long sessions → Brrnoo. High-density memory foam shaped to your ears is its core claim.
• Best if you want two pads and a fast support promise → BAKDIK. You get a full set plus a stated 24-hour response window.
In my opinion, the choice mostly makes itself once you check your headset model. If you own the H12 BT 5.0, buy the Brrnoo pads — they're purpose-built for it, and the memory foam and reinforced stitching are exactly what you want in a comfort-first replacement. If you own a Skullcandy Crusher, Crusher Evo, Crusher ANC, Hesh 3 or Venue ANC, buy the BAKDIK pads instead. The broader compatibility, thickened noise-isolating foam and one-year warranty make it the safer pick for that family of headphones. Figure out which camp you're in, then check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
FAQ
No. Both are described as tool-free swaps — remove the old cushions and press the new ones into place. Brrnoo says no tools are required, and BAKDIK describes aligning the card position and pressing the pad in until it seats tightly.
They can. Worn, flattened pads break the seal against your head, which weakens bass and lets noise in. Brrnoo points to improved isolation from its memory foam, and BAKDIK says its thickened foam enhances noise blocking while retaining the original sound.
It depends entirely on your headset. Brrnoo is the better fit for the H12 BT 5.0; BAKDIK is the better fit for Skullcandy Crusher, Hesh and Venue owners, and it carries a longer one-year warranty. Check the current price on Amazon for each before deciding.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Turtle Beach Stealth Pro vs Skullcandy Method 540, AUDIRA Mini vs AONESY Headband, Focal FHPSTAND Headphone Stand vs MEZE Audio, BEBOAN 2-in-1 vs auvstar Active Noise Cancelling