How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• brikinte's biggest strength: four 13.5 x 9.5-inch rectangular PTFE-coated sheets sized to drop straight onto Ninja DT201/DT251 oven trays, reusable and nonstick on both the cooking and cleanup side.
• brikinte's biggest trade-off: it is a sheet, not a fastener, and the Teflon-style coating has a stated ceiling — the manufacturer warns it should not exceed 480°F and recommends staying under 450°F.
• JoySil's biggest strength: twelve SmCo-core silicone magnets that clamp parchment or silicone liners flat against iron and steel baskets, heat resistant to 464°F, and they store in their own PP case.
• JoySil's biggest trade-off: they only solve the liner-lifting problem, and only on magnetic (iron or steel) baskets — they are useless on aluminum or ceramic-coated non-magnetic trays.
• Who each is for: brikinte for Ninja flip-up toaster oven owners who hate scrubbing trays; JoySil for parchment-paper users on standard metal air fryer baskets who are tired of chasing curled corners.
This one is a tray-protection play. You get four black fiberglass sheets, each 13.5 x 9.5 inches and rectangular, which is the shape that matches the original oven tray on the Ninja DT201 and DT251 countertop air fry ovens. That fit is the whole point: you lay a sheet down, cook, lift it out, and the tray underneath stays largely untouched. For anyone who uses a flip-up toaster oven air fryer daily — reheating, roasting vegetables, crisping frozen snacks — that is the difference between a thirty-second wipe-down and a soak-and-scrub session.
The material story is straightforward. The sheets are PTFE with a surface coating, described as BPA-free and PFOA-free, and the brand says they come off a professional batch assembly line with quality control in place. The weight is light — about 0.13 kg for the set — so they handle like thick, slightly stiff baking mats rather than rigid pans. They are also cuttable, so if your tray is not a Ninja DT201/DT251, you can trim a sheet down to your actual tray size instead of hunting for a brand-specific fit.
JoySil 12-Pack: Who It's For
JoySil attacks a different, very common annoyance: parchment liners that lift, fold, or drift up into the heating element mid-cook. These are small silicone-bodied magnets — roughly 4.13 inches long and 0.6 inches wide each — that you place along the edge of a disposable parchment liner or a reusable silicone liner to pin it flat against the basket. The core is enlarged samarium cobalt (SmCo), which the brand says holds harder than standard silicone magnets, and the silicone shell is food-grade, odor-free, and reusable. Heat resistance is rated to 464°F, which covers normal air frying, roasting and baking.
The practical benefit is consistency. When a liner stays put, air circulates the way the basket was designed to circulate it, and you stop opening the drawer to re-flatten paper. Setup is trivial — lay the magnets along the edge — and cleanup is a rinse. The included PP storage case matters more than it sounds: twelve small magnets are exactly the kind of thing that disappears into a junk drawer, and a dedicated case keeps them together and kitchen-organized.
The catch is compatibility. These attach to iron and steel baskets only, so they are a no-go on aluminum baskets or any non-magnetic ceramic-coated surface. They are also purely accessories — they do not replace a liner, do not protect a tray from grease, and do not do anything for an oven-style air fryer with a flat tray. If your air fryer uses a magnetic metal basket and you already buy parchment rounds or squares, this is the missing piece. If you cook on a flat oven tray, buy the brikinte sheets instead.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for parchment or silicone liners that keep curling up → JoySil 12-Pack, whose SmCo magnets pin liners flat against the basket.
• Best for high-heat cooking headroom → JoySil 12-Pack, rated to 464°F, versus brikinte's stated 480°F maximum with a recommendation to stay under 450°F.
• Best for tray and crumb protection → brikinte Non-stick Reusable Air, since a sheet shields the tray itself rather than just holding paper down.
• Best for round basket air fryers → JoySil 12-Pack, as long as the basket is iron or steel and therefore magnetic.
• Best for people who trim accessories to fit → brikinte Non-stick Reusable Air, because the sheets can be cut down to a different tray size.
• Best for keeping accessories tidy → JoySil 12-Pack, which arrives with a PP storage case for all twelve pieces.
• Best for nonstick cleanup with no extra parts → brikinte Non-stick Reusable Air, since the PTFE surface is the nonstick element rather than a separate clip you have to manage.
In my opinion, most people shopping this comparison should buy the brikinte Non-stick Reusable Air set. Four reusable sheets that match the Ninja DT201/DT251 tray, wipe clean, and can be trimmed to other trays is the more broadly useful purchase — it solves the mess problem at the source rather than managing paper. I would only switch to the JoySil 12-Pack if I cooked almost exclusively in a magnetic metal basket with parchment liners and my single biggest frustration was corners lifting into the element. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding, and confirm your basket is magnetic if you go the JoySil route.
FAQ
what are the best air fryer accessories
No. The JoySil magnets need an iron or steel basket to stick to, so they work on most metal air fryer baskets but not on aluminum or non-magnetic ceramic-coated ones. They are also rated to 464°F, so keep them within normal air frying, roasting and baking temperatures.
The manufacturer states a maximum of 480°F and recommends using them below 450°F because of how the PTFE coating behaves. If your recipes routinely run hotter than that, this liner is not the right fit and you should look at a different accessory.
Both are reusable. The brikinte sheets are nonstick PTFE liners you wipe or rinse and reuse, and they can be cut to size. The JoySil magnets are food-grade silicone over SmCo cores, reusable, rinse-clean, and they store in the included PP case.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: brikinte Non-stick Reusable Air vs MMH Air Fryer Silicone, MosBug Non Stick Reusable vs DISSKNIC 100PCS: Air Fryer, ANQIA Non-Stick Round Disposable vs QQDETRR Air Fryer 3.8QT