How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• brikinte 4 biggest strength: It's a full kit — four reusable liners plus a replacement crumb tray pan, sized specifically for the Ninja DT201/DT251 air fry countertop oven.
• brikinte 4 biggest trade-off: The Teflon coating is capped around 480°F, and brikinte itself recommends staying under 450°F, so very high-heat broiling is off the table.
• TCSNOE 5PCs biggest strength: A 500°F heat ceiling and five 12" x 12" liners that sit flat on the oven floor of the Ninja FO101 French Door Premier 20.3qt.
• TCSNOE 5PCs biggest trade-off: It's liners only — no crumb tray — and it's cut for the FO101 footprint, so it isn't a general-purpose fit.
• Choose brikinte 4 if you own a DT201/DT251 and want liners plus a spare crumb tray in one purchase.
• Choose TCSNOE 5PCs if you own an FO101 and want more liners with a higher heat tolerance.
The brikinte 4 set is built around one specific oven: the Ninja DT201 air fry countertop oven. That focus is the whole point. Instead of a one-size-fits-nothing mat, you get non-stick baking sheets cut to sit in that oven, plus four matching black Teflon cleaning pads that double as reusable liners. The package also includes a brand new replacement crumb tray pan, which is the detail that separates this set from a plain liner pack — it addresses the bottom of the oven, not just the surface food sits on.
Materials matter here. The liners are made from high-quality PTFE with a special nonstick surface coating, and they're BPA-free and PFOA-free. In practical terms, that means you can bake, roast and air fry on them, then wipe them down instead of scrubbing a stained tray. The reusable angle is the real selling point: one purchase covers many cooking sessions, and the four-pad count means you can rotate through a batch cook without stopping to wash in between.
The catch is temperature. Because of how Teflon behaves, brikinte states the maximum is 480°F and recommends keeping things below 450°F. So if your routine leans on very hot broiling or high-heat searing, this isn't the set for that. It's also a poor fit if you don't own a DT201 or DT251 — the sizing and the included crumb tray are matched to that oven. Skip it if you have a French door model or a different brand entirely.
TCSNOE takes the opposite approach: fewer moving parts, more liners, higher heat. This set is five reusable Teflon mats, each 12" x 12", sized for the Ninja French Door Premier Air Fryer Convection Toaster Oven FO101 (including the FO101BK and FO101BL variants, 20.3qt). They rest flat on the oven bottom and are designed to give full coverage without blocking normal heat circulation — a detail that matters, because a liner that traps heat changes how your food cooks.
The headline spec is the 500°F (260°C) rating. That's meaningfully above what the brikinte liners are cleared for, and it opens up everyday baking, roasting and air frying in an electric oven without you worrying about the ceiling. The nonstick surface does what you'd expect: grease, crumbs and residue wipe away with a damp cloth or a rinse rather than a soak. Like the brikinte set, these are food-grade Teflon, BPA-free and PFOA-free.
Where TCSNOE is thinner is in what's in the box. There's no crumb tray — just the five mats. If your oven bottom is already in decent shape and you mainly want a reusable barrier to catch drips and extend the life of the appliance, that's fine. But if you're replacing a worn or missing tray, this set won't do it.
The other limitation is fit. The 12" x 12" size is tuned to the FO101 footprint. It's not a universal liner, and it isn't the right buy if you own a DT201/DT251. Buy it if you own an FO101, want five liners to rotate, and value the higher heat rating over the extras. Skip it if you need a crumb tray or you're cooking above 500°F.
• Best for Ninja DT201/DT251 owners → brikinte 4. The liners and crumb tray are matched to that oven.
• Best for Ninja FO101 owners → TCSNOE 5PCs. Sized for the French Door Premier 20.3qt.
• Best heat tolerance → TCSNOE 5PCs. 500°F versus brikinte's 480°F ceiling and sub-450°F recommendation.
• Best all-in-one kit → brikinte 4. You get four liners and a replacement crumb tray pan.
• Best for simple bottom protection → TCSNOE 5PCs. Five flat liners that catch grease and crumbs without extra parts.
• Best if you broil hot → TCSNOE 5PCs. The higher rating gives more headroom for high-heat cooking.
• Best if you're replacing a worn tray → brikinte 4. TCSNOE doesn't include one.
• Best for rotating through a big cook → either. Four liners vs. five — both let you keep cooking while one is being washed.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down entirely to which oven you own. If you have a Ninja DT201 or DT251, I'd buy brikinte 4 — the included crumb tray and matched sizing make it the more complete solution, and staying under 450°F is an easy habit to keep. If you have a Ninja FO101, I'd buy TCSNOE 5PCs for the higher 500°F ceiling and the extra liner. Buy for your oven, not for the spec sheet — a liner that doesn't fit is just clutter.
FAQ
how to use reusable air fryer liners
how to clean reusable air fryer liners
Let them cool, then wipe the nonstick surface with a damp cloth or rinse under water. TCSNOE specifically notes cleanup with a damp cloth or water rinse; brikinte's PTFE nonstick coating is designed for the same kind of wipe-down. Avoid abrasive scrubbers that could damage the coating.
how to use air fryer liners
Use them as a barrier between your food and the oven surface to catch grease, crumbs and drips. The TCSNOE liners sit flat without affecting heat circulation, and brikinte's pads protect the crumb tray. Just keep an eye on temperature — under 450°F for brikinte, up to 500°F for TCSNOE.
can you put liners in air fryer
Yes — both are made for it. brikinte's liners are reusable pads for the Ninja DT201/DT251 oven, and TCSNOE's are reusable mats for the Ninja FO101. The main rule is heat: stay within each product's stated maximum temperature, and check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: KUKUGO Air Fryer Liners vs TCSNOE 135PCs: Can You Use, brikinte Non-stick Reusable Air vs TCSNOE 125PCs: Best Air, INFRAOVENS Reusable Liners vs Suenozero Silicone Air Fryer