We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 5 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a truly all-purpose liner that handles baking, air frying and even steaming, choose BOYAN 9; if you specifically need maximum steam flow for dumplings and dim sum in an air fryer basket or metal steamer, choose MOKKHNB 100pcs.
• BOYAN 9 — biggest strength: Food-grade silicone paper rated heat resistant up to 446°F (230°C), nonstick, waterproof and anti-tear, so it works in ovens, springform pans, toaster ovens and air fryers alike.
• BOYAN 9 — biggest trade-off: It is a solid, unperforated round that is intentionally cut slightly smaller than 9 inches to sit correctly inside a 9-inch pan — so it is not the ideal shape for a steam basket.
• MOKKHNB 100pcs — biggest strength: A round perforated liner with more holes than typical steamer papers, designed so steam passes through freely instead of pooling.
• MOKKHNB 100pcs — biggest trade-off: It is purpose-built for steaming — sized for 10-inch or metal steamers and 5.3-quart-or-smaller air fryers — so it is a narrower tool than a general baking paper.
• Pick BOYAN 9 if you bake, roast and air fry and want one liner that covers all of it.
• Pick MOKKHNB 100pcs if dumplings, buns and dim sum are the whole point.
The BOYAN 9 is the generalist of the two. It is made from 100% food-grade pulp with a silicone coating that is described as not bleached, non-toxic and non-wax, and it carries a heat resistance rating up to 446°F (230°C). That ceiling matters because it is what lets the same paper go from a springform pan in the oven to a toaster oven to an air fryer without you switching products. The nonstick surface is the second half of the pitch: less grease needed, no food residue welded to the pan, and a cake that releases cleanly instead of tearing on the way out.
The waterproof, anti-tear claim is the one I would weigh most heavily for everyday cooking. Wet, sloppy results usually come from paper that soaks through and disintegrates under a cheesecake or a fish fillet, and BOYAN is explicitly built to resist that. It also lists practical multi-purpose uses — cookies, cheesecake, deep dish pizza, baking meat and fish, and steaming dumplings and stuffed buns.
Who should buy it: anyone who wants a single liner format that lives next to the oven and gets used for baking and air frying week in and week out. Who should skip it: if your primary job is steaming dumplings in a basket and you want the paper to let steam through rather than hold it, this is the wrong shape for that specific task. Note also that each round is deliberately a touch under 9 inches to fit a 9-inch pan's slightly smaller interior — that is by design, not a defect.
The MOKKHNB 100pcs is a specialist, and it is refreshingly honest about it. These are circular perforated steamer liners, 9 inches across (23cm), intended for 10-inch or metal steamers and for air fryers of 5.3 quarts or smaller. The perforations are the entire design idea: the brand's own framing is that other steamer liners have fewer holes and therefore block steam, while these let it pass through fluently so food tastes and smells the way it should. That is also why the paper is described as thin enough to let steam through rather than absorbing it.
The anti-stick side is what you actually feel at cleanup time. Dumplings, buns and dim sum are notoriously prone to gluing themselves to a steamer basket or pan, and a nonstick perforated round keeps the residue on the paper instead of on your equipment. The material is paper, white, and each liner measures roughly 23cm × 23cm × 0.1cm, with a listed item weight of 5.76 ounces for the set.
Who should buy it: anyone whose air fryer dumpling routine lives or dies on steam — frozen dumplings, buns, dim sum, even vegetables and rice. Who should skip it: bakers who need a solid liner for a springform pan or a deep dish pizza. An open-hole paper is the wrong tool for batter, and it is also sized for smaller air fryers, so a large-capacity unit may not be a clean fit.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for baking and roasting → BOYAN 9. Heat resistance to 446°F (230°C) and a solid, nonstick round suit cakes, cookies, meat and fish.
• Best for steam flow → MOKKHNB 100pcs. More holes than typical steamer papers is the brand's core claim, and it is the reason to pick it.
• Best for oven-to-air-fryer versatility → BOYAN 9. One liner format covers springform pans, toaster ovens, Dutch ovens, tortilla presses and air fryers.
• Best for cleanup after sticky foods → MOKKHNB 100pcs for dumplings and buns; BOYAN 9 for cakes and greasy bakes.
• Best fit for a large air fryer → BOYAN 9, since MOKKHNB is specified for 5.3-quart-or-smaller air fryers.
• Best fit for a 10-inch or metal steamer → MOKKHNB 100pcs, which is precisely what it is sized for.
• Best for a one-product kitchen → BOYAN 9, because it does more jobs.
In my opinion, the right buy depends entirely on what "air fryer dumplings" means in your kitchen. If dumplings, buns and dim sum are the reason you own the air fryer, I would buy the MOKKHNB 100pcs — the perforated design is the whole point, and it is the more purposeful tool for that job. If you want one liner that handles cheesecake on Sunday and frozen dumplings on Tuesday, I would buy the BOYAN 9 instead and accept that it will not move steam as freely. Two different jobs, two different papers.
FAQ
how to air fry dumplings from frozen
Line the basket with a perforated round like the MOKKHNB 100pcs, which is sized for 5.3-quart-or-smaller air fryers, then cook the dumplings straight from frozen. The holes let steam escape so the wrappers do not turn gluey against the basket.
how to air fry dumplings not frozen
how to make air fryer dumplings
Set a liner in the basket, arrange the dumplings with space between them, and let the air circulate. If you also bake or roast, the BOYAN 9 covers those jobs too, since it is rated heat resistant up to 446°F (230°C).
how to air fryer dumplings
Line the basket first. For pure dumpling duty I recommend the MOKKHNB 100pcs because its holes are designed for steam; check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page before you decide.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SIUDANGKA 100Pcs vs AMYONE 12x12: Air Fryer Chicken, air fryer dumplings, air fryer frozen dumplings