How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• BESTOYARD's biggest strength: a purpose-built, 7.1-inch square bacon and baking pan sized for 4–5QT fryer baskets, with a raised design that separates strips so hot air circulates and bacon cooks evenly.
• BESTOYARD's biggest trade-off: it is a single-task insert. It's built around bacon and similar flat foods, not around drying dishes or protecting your countertop.
• ZLR's biggest strength: one 12"×12" square mat that works three ways — food-grade drying mat, heat-resistant trivet up to 450°F, and non-slip base under air fryers, coffee makers and toaster ovens.
• ZLR's biggest trade-off: it is a mat, not a cooking insert. It won't crisp bacon or hold food in a fryer basket, and it needs to air-dry properly between uses so residue doesn't build up.
• Choose BESTOYARD if your goal is better bacon and easier cleanup inside the air fryer.
• Choose ZLR if your goal is a countertop helper that dries, protects and stabilizes your appliances.
The BESTOYARD pan is a 7.1-inch square silicone insert designed to sit inside a 4–5QT air fryer basket. Its whole reason for existing is bacon. The raised design separates each strip so hot air can move around it, which is the difference between bacon that cooks evenly and bacon that steams in its own grease. That same layout works for other flat foods you want crisped — the product description mentions chips — and the pan is compatible with microwaves and conventional ovens as well as air fryers, so it isn't locked to one appliance.
Who should buy it: anyone with a 4–5QT air fryer who cooks bacon regularly, hates grease splatter, and wants a reusable insert instead of foil or parchment. Who should skip it: if you don't cook bacon or flat crisping foods, or if your air fryer basket is a different size class, this pan won't do much for you. It's also not a drying mat or a trivet — it does one job well, and if that job isn't yours, look elsewhere.
ZLR 4-in-1: Who It's For
The ZLR 4-in-1 is a 12"×12" (305×306mm) square silicone mat in Peach Pink, and the "4-in-1" label is earned by how many small roles it fills. First, it's a drying mat: raised wavy ridges let air flow underneath washed items, so a few wine glasses, breakfast bowls, a French press carafe and grinder, or baby bottles dry faster than they would flat on a towel. Second, it's a trivet rated heat-resistant up to 450°F, so you can set a hot pot, baking sheet or roasting pan straight down from the stove or oven — and the silicone insulates against the thermal shock that can crack quartz or granite.
Third, it's an appliance base. Slide it under an air fryer, coffee maker, toaster oven, kettle or stand mixer and it catches drips, crumbs and oil splatter while the grippy underside keeps the appliance from creeping forward during use. Note the manufacturer's own clarification: this is a non-slip mat, not a slider — appliances stay put. Fourth, it's simply a food-grade surface: 100% BPA-free silicone, odor-resistant, non-porous, so it won't trap water or food residue the way a porous mat might.
Who should buy it: anyone with limited counter space — apartment galley kitchens and RV counters are called out specifically — who wants one compact square that dries, protects and stabilizes. Who should skip it: if you need something that goes inside a fryer basket to cook food, this isn't it. It's also worth respecting the care instructions: hang or roll it to fully air-dry between uses and run it through the dishwasher weekly, because silicone is non-porous but residue can accumulate if the mat stays damp. It rolls up tight for drawer storage, and it's top-rack dishwasher safe.
• Best for cooking bacon → BESTOYARD Silicone Air Fryer. The separated-strip design and 4–5QT sizing are built for exactly this.
• Best for countertop protection → ZLR 4-in-1. A 450°F trivet rating and a 12"×12" footprint cover hot pans and everyday splatter.
• Best for drying dishes → ZLR 4-in-1. Wavy ridges and airflow do what a flat silicone pan can't.
• Best for air fryer basket fit → BESTOYARD. Its 7.1-inch square shape is dimensioned for 4–5QT fryers; the ZLR mat sits under an appliance, not inside it.
• Best for appliance stability → ZLR 4-in-1. The non-slip base stops coffee makers, kettles and mixers from creeping during use.
• Best for grease and splatter cleanup → BESTOYARD for cooking grease, ZLR for drips around the appliance.
• Best for small kitchens and RVs → ZLR 4-in-1. It rolls up, stores in a drawer, and its square footprint fits tight counters.
• Best for one purchase that covers several small jobs → ZLR 4-in-1. It's the more versatile of the two; BESTOYARD is the more specialized.
In my opinion, these aren't really competitors — they're two different tools that happen to share a material. If I had to pick one for the average kitchen, I'd lean toward the ZLR 4-in-1. In my experience of how kitchens actually get used, a mat that dries dishes, protects stone counters up to 450°F and stops the coffee maker from sliding earns its space every single day, while a bacon insert only works when you're making bacon. But if crispy bacon without the grease mess is the specific itch you're scratching, the BESTOYARD Silicone Air Fryer is the more targeted answer, and I'd recommend it without hesitation for that job. Buy the one that matches your routine, not the one with more bullet points.
If you cook bacon in a 4–5QT air fryer often, yes — the separated-strip design improves airflow and the non-stick, dishwasher-safe silicone makes cleanup far easier than scrubbing a metal rack. For occasional use, a rack you already own may be enough.
No. It's designed to sit under appliances or on the counter as a drying mat and trivet, not inside a fryer basket. Keep it on the countertop and use a dedicated insert for cooking.
I don't quote prices here since they change — check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page. On value, the ZLR covers more everyday jobs per square inch, while the BESTOYARD is worth it specifically if bacon is your priority.
The manufacturer rates it heat-resistant up to 450°F and specifically calls out protection against thermal shock on quartz, granite and marble. That's the claim from the data sheet — just don't exceed the rated temperature with a screaming-hot pan.
It's a 7.1-inch square insert intended for 4–5QT baskets, with overall dimensions of 7.87 x 7.87 x 2.56 inches. Measure your basket's interior before buying if you're unsure.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Boribim 9 vs Mobestech Silicone Air Fryer, uxcell 18Pcs vs Generic Silicone Air Fryer, GCQFZ Air Fryer Accessories vs Komzon Silicone Air Fryer