We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a complete wired gaming headset with a mic, LED lighting and multi-platform support, choose BENGOO Pro Gaming Headset; if you need noise isolating foam tips to upgrade the earbuds you already own, choose Luckvan Memory Foam Replacement.
• BENGOO Pro Gaming Headset — biggest strength: a full over-ear system with a 40mm driver, an omni-directional noise-isolating boom mic, inline volume and one-key mute, and a sturdy metal frame — everything you need to game and talk in one box.
• BENGOO Pro Gaming Headset — biggest trade-off: it's wired only, USB, and the old-model Xbox One controller needs an extra Microsoft Adapter that isn't included.
• Luckvan Memory Foam Replacement — biggest strength: threaded-grip memory foam that locks onto 5mm–7mm nozzles and seals your ear canal for passive noise isolation, with 6 pairs and a storage box in the pack.
• Luckvan Memory Foam Replacement — biggest trade-off: it's not a headset at all — no drivers, no cable, no mic. It only improves earbuds you already own, and only if their nozzles fall in the 5mm–7mm range.
• Who each pick is for: BENGOO for someone who wants one wired headset for console, PC and mobile; Luckvan for someone who already loves their in-ears and just wants a better, more secure seal.
The BENGOO Pro is a gaming-first over-ear headset. Its design centers on a high-precision 40mm magnetic neodymium driver with a frequency range of 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz and 22-ohm impedance, which is the kind of spec sheet built to push a wide sound field and low-end punch — the reason it's marketed around "bass surround" and around hearing footsteps and gunshots clearly in shooters. The boom mic is omni-directional with noise-cancelling pickup, and it's long and flexible so you can angle it where you need it.
Buy it if you want one wired headset that covers PS4, PS5, PC, Nintendo 3DS, laptop, tablet, iPad and phone. Skip it if you're on an old Xbox One controller and don't want to buy a separate Microsoft Adapter, or if you want wireless freedom — this is a wired USB unit, full stop.
Luckvan Memory Foam Replacement: Who It's For
The Luckvan tips solve a completely different problem. If your earbuds sound thin, keep slipping out on runs, or let the outside world bleed in, the culprit is usually the seal — not the drivers. These are universal memory foam tips for nozzles between 5mm and 7mm, and the headline feature is the internal thread design. Standard smooth-bore foam tips loosen over time; the threaded bore grips the nozzle so the tip stays put through running, gym work and daily wear.
Memory foam itself is the second half of the story. It molds to your ear canal instead of forcing it open, which means no pressure points and no ear fatigue on long listening sessions. A tight foam seal is passive noise isolation — it blocks ambient sound so you hear deeper bass and clearer detail without cranking the volume. That's the same principle the BENGOO uses with its over-ear cushions, just applied at the ear-canal level.
Buy it if your earbuds have 5mm–7mm nozzles and you want a firmer, quieter, more comfortable fit — especially for sport. The 6 pairs across 3 sizes plus the storage box means you always have a clean spare. Skip it if you need a headset, a mic, or anything with a cable — this is a consumable accessory, not audio hardware.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for gaming with voice chat → BENGOO Pro Gaming Headset. The noise-isolating omni mic plus one-key mute is the whole point.
• Best for multi-platform use → BENGOO Pro Gaming Headset. PS4, PS5, PC, 3DS, laptop, tablet, iPad and phone from one wired headset.
• Best for running and gym → Luckvan Memory Foam Replacement. The threaded grip is designed specifically to stop tips slipping out mid-workout.
• Best for long sessions without ear fatigue → Luckvan Memory Foam Replacement. Memory foam molds to the canal instead of pressing on it.
• Best for a single all-in purchase → BENGOO Pro Gaming Headset. Driver, mic, cable, controls and LED lighting all come together.
• Best for a cheap upgrade to gear you already own → Luckvan Memory Foam Replacement. 6 pairs and a case keep you supplied.
• Best if you want wireless → neither, honestly. The BENGOO is wired USB; the Luckvan only modifies earbuds you already have.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the BENGOO Pro Gaming Headset. In my opinion it's the higher-value purchase because it's a complete, self-contained system — driver, mic, inline controls, metal frame and memory foam ear pads — and it covers nearly every platform you'd game on. The Luckvan tips are genuinely clever for what they are, and I'd recommend them to anyone with slipping earbuds, but they're an accessory, not a replacement for a headset. Buy BENGOO for the whole setup; buy Luckvan to fix the earbuds you already love. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
how to noise cancelling headphones work
The BENGOO headset uses passive noise isolation, not active cancellation — thickened memory foam ear pads physically block outside sound. The Luckvan tips work the same way at the ear-canal level: a foam seal keeps ambient noise out.
how to use noise cancelling headphones
Wear the BENGOO over your ears with the headband adjusted so the pads seal around, not on, your ears, and use the rotary volume wheel plus one-key mute on the cable. For the Luckvan, fit the tip size that seals your canal and let the foam expand before you press play.
how to test noise cancelling headphones
Do these two products do the same job?
No. The BENGOO is a complete wired over-ear gaming headset with a mic. The Luckvan is a pack of memory foam replacement ear tips for earbuds with 5mm–7mm nozzles. One replaces your headset; the other upgrades your earbuds.
They fit most earbuds with 5mm–7mm nozzles. If your earbuds fall outside that range, they won't seat properly, so measure before buying.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: BAIHUAFRU Cute Gaming Headset vs Puiixur Replacement Nova 3, LilGadgets Untangled Pro Kids vs Tatybo Gaming Headset, Niukeke Replacement Earpad Compatible vs Keybudz HyperFoam Memory Foam