How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-18 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Bella Cooks 12 — biggest strength: Two heavy-duty carbon steel trays with a perforated surface that lets hot air circulate for crispier crusts, plus a non-stick coating and dishwasher-safe cleanup.
• Bella Cooks 12 — biggest trade-off: It's a fixed 12-inch round pan, so it's built around pizza and similar flat foods rather than lining any pan you own. It also takes up storage space as two solid discs.
• BYKITCHEN 220pcs — biggest strength: 220 precut 9-inch rounds made from natural wood pulp with a food-grade silicone coating, so you skip the cutting and trimming step entirely.
• BYKITCHEN 220pcs — biggest trade-off: They're single-use liners, and the 9-inch size only fits pans and baskets of roughly that diameter.
• Who each pick is for: Bella Cooks 12 is for the home pizza maker who wants repeatable crispy crusts; BYKITCHEN 220pcs is for the baker who lines pans constantly and wants zero fuss.
The Bella Cooks 12 set is two 12-inch round pans made from heat-resistant carbon steel with a black non-stick finish. The headline design choice is the perforated surface: small holes across the tray let hot air move under and around the dough, so moisture in the dough can escape instead of steaming the base. That's the whole reason a crisper pan exists, and it's the detail that separates this from a plain solid baking sheet.
In everyday use, the round shape is the other selling point. You get evenly shaped pizzas rather than the rough rectangle you get from pressing dough onto a sheet pan. The set includes two trays, which matters more than it sounds — you can bake two pizzas at once for a family, or run one tray for pizza and the other for fries, garlic bread or flatbreads. The brand also lists a pizza cutter among the included components, so you're not hunting for one on pizza night.
BYKITCHEN 220pcs: Who It's For
BYKITCHEN 220pcs is a different category of product entirely: 220 precut 9-inch round parchment sheets made from 100% natural wood pulp with a food-grade nonstick silicone oil coating on both sides. The sheets are greaseproof, waterproof and heat-resistant up to 446°F / 230°C, and they're safe in both the microwave and the oven. That temperature ceiling covers standard baking, most air fryer use and typical cake and cheesecake recipes.
The real value is the precut format. Anyone who has traced and trimmed a circle out of a roll of parchment knows the drill: awkward, wasteful, and the corners never sit flat. These rounds are already 9 inches across, so they drop straight into a 9-inch cake pan or springform pan and fit the first time. With 220 sheets in the pack, you're not rationing them either — you can line a pan for a quick bake without thinking about whether it's "worth" a sheet.
Beyond cakes, the listed uses are broad: cookies, pizza, separating burger patties or barbecue, and lining a tortilla press, air fryer basket, pizza pan or Dutch oven. The non-stick silicone coating means baked goods slide off rather than tearing, and because the paper catches the mess, cleanup is mostly a matter of lifting the sheet out and tossing it. The trade-offs: these are disposable, so they're a recurring purchase rather than a one-time one, and 9 inches is a fixed size. If your pans are 8-inch or 10-inch, or you bake in a large rectangular tin, you'll still be trimming. For round 9-inch baking, though, the fit is the point.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for crispy pizza crusts → Bella Cooks 12. The perforated carbon steel surface is designed specifically to circulate air and let dough moisture escape.
• Best for zero-prep pan lining → BYKITCHEN 220pcs. No cutting, no trimming, no measuring — the rounds are already the right size.
• Best for high-volume baking → BYKITCHEN 220pcs. 220 sheets means you can line a pan every day for months without restocking.
• Best for cleanup convenience → both, differently. Bella Cooks 12 is dishwasher safe and reusable; BYKITCHEN 220pcs you simply lift out and discard.
• Best for cake and springform pans → BYKITCHEN 220pcs. That's exactly what 9-inch rounds are made for; a rigid pizza tray can't do this job.
• Best for air fryer and tortilla press use → BYKITCHEN 220pcs. The listed uses cover air fryer baskets and tortilla presses, where a 12-inch metal pan won't fit.
• Best one-time purchase → Bella Cooks 12. It's a reusable pan set; parchment is a consumable you'll buy again.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy Bella Cooks 12. In my opinion, a reusable perforated pan set does more work in a normal kitchen: it makes better pizza than a flat sheet, it handles fries and flatbreads, and it never runs out. The dishwasher-safe non-stick coating means the effort per use stays low. That said, BYKITCHEN 220pcs is the smarter buy if your baking skews toward cakes, cheesecakes and air fryer batches — the precut 9-inch rounds remove a genuinely annoying chore. If you do both, they don't overlap at all, and owning both is the honest answer.
For baking pizza, yes. The perforated carbon steel trays are built to circulate air and crisp the crust, and they're reusable. BYKITCHEN rounds can line a pizza pan, but they don't add crisping on their own.
Are BYKITCHEN 220pcs parchment rounds safe in the oven?
I don't publish prices here because they change. Use the "Check latest price on Amazon" button on this page to see the current price for each product before you decide.
They're 9-inch rounds, so they won't cover a 12-inch pan edge to edge. They fit 9-inch cake pans, springform pans, air fryer baskets and tortilla presses, which is what they're cut for.
Bella Cooks 12 is reusable — two pans you wash and use again. BYKITCHEN 220pcs is a consumable supply of 220 single-use sheets, so you'll replace it once the pack runs out.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.