If you want over-ear headphones with sound-isolating design for Xbox, choose Audio-Technica ATH-M50X; if you need a replacement cable for compatible Audio-Technica headphones, choose NewFantasia Replacement Upgrade Cable. These are not substitutes: one is a complete pair of headphones, and the other is an accessory that works with certain headphones you already own. For Xbox, the M50X is the relevant choice if you need headphones; the NewFantasia cable only replaces a cable and does not include headphones.
• Audio-Technica ATH-M50X: A complete pair of over-ear, wired headphones with 45 mm drivers and a closed-back design; the trade-off is that this is a headphone purchase, not a cable upgrade for another headset.
• NewFantasia Replacement Upgrade Cable: A 1.5-meter braided cable compatible with the ATH-M50X and several other Audio-Technica models; the trade-off is that it is only a cable, with no headphones included.
• Choose the ATH-M50X if you need headphones for listening and want a design that contours around the ears.
• Choose the NewFantasia cable if you already have a compatible headphone model and need a replacement connection.
The ATH-M50X is the actual listening product in this comparison. It has 45 mm dynamic drivers, a wired design, and over-ear cups intended to surround the ears. Audio-Technica describes its sound as clear across an extended frequency range, with deep, accurate bass. Its closed-back circumaural construction is designed to provide passive isolation from surrounding noise.
That makes it a more plausible fit for someone who wants a dedicated pair of headphones for home listening, studio work, or use on the go. The earcups swivel 90 degrees, which supports one-ear monitoring, and the product information lists professional-grade earpad and headband materials for durability and comfort. Those features may appeal to someone who switches between listening and monitoring or wants a wired set rather than a wireless-first design.
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-10-12 · 5 min read · Independent comparison
For Xbox, the M50X is the only one of these two products that supplies the headphones themselves. Still, the provided specifications do not identify Xbox-specific features, a microphone, or a wireless gaming connection, so I would not treat it as a purpose-built gaming headset on the strength of this information alone. Skip it if what you actually need is just a replacement cable for a compatible pair of headphones.
The NewFantasia product is an accessory, not a standalone audio device. It is a 1.5-meter (4.9-foot) replacement cable intended for the ATH-M50X, ATH-M40X, ATH-M70X, and ATH-M60X. It has a braided exterior, an internal OFC wire, and a 3.5 mm male connection with a 6.35 mm adapter to a 2.5 mm male connector. The cable also has a locking connection described as matching the original cable.
This makes sense if you own one of those supported headphone models and need a replacement lead or an additional cable for your setup. The stated length gives you a concrete fit to consider: think about where your headphones connect and how much distance you need between the listener and the device. The supplied information does not establish that it adds new headphone functions or changes the sound, so I would see it primarily as a replacement connection.
It is not a choice for someone starting from scratch, and it is not a pair of Xbox headphones. The package contains one cable and no headphones. If you are shopping for something like true wireless earbuds for Xbox, this product is especially far from that use: it is a wired replacement lead for specific over-ear headphone models, not earbuds or a wireless audio system.
• Need a complete pair of headphones → Audio-Technica ATH-M50X. The NewFantasia item is a cable only.
• Already own compatible Audio-Technica headphones and need a lead → NewFantasia Replacement Upgrade Cable. It lists compatibility with the ATH-M50X, ATH-M40X, ATH-M70X, and ATH-M60X.
• Want over-ear cups designed to surround the ears → Audio-Technica ATH-M50X. Its circumaural design is intended to provide passive isolation.
• Need a 1.5-meter replacement cable → NewFantasia Replacement Upgrade Cable. Its listed length is 4.9 feet.
• Want one-ear monitoring support → Audio-Technica ATH-M50X. Its earcups swivel 90 degrees.
• Need a cable with a braided outer construction and a 6.35 mm adapter → NewFantasia Replacement Upgrade Cable. Its listed connections also include 3.5 mm and 2.5 mm male ends.
• Shopping for headphones for Xbox → Audio-Technica ATH-M50X, with a caveat. It is the only complete headphone product here, but the supplied details do not establish Xbox-specific gaming functions.
• Looking for fast charging sports earbuds for Xbox or the best multipoint on-ear headphones for Xbox → neither product fits that description. The M50X is listed as wired, and the NewFantasia item is a replacement cable.
The main decision is not a subtle contest between two similar headphones. It is about identifying the thing you need. The ATH-M50X provides the listening hardware; the NewFantasia cable connects to compatible headphones you already have. If you compare them as though both could independently deliver sound, you risk choosing an accessory when you need headphones.
I would choose the Audio-Technica ATH-M50X if I needed headphones for Xbox, because it is the only complete headphone product here and has an over-ear, closed-back design.
I would not assume it has gaming-specific features that the supplied details do not list.
If I already owned compatible Audio-Technica headphones and only needed a replacement lead, I would choose the NewFantasia cable instead.
For Xbox, my recommendation is the ATH-M50X as the more relevant starting point—not the cable.
FAQ
No. It is one replacement cable, and the package does not include headphones. It is listed for use with the ATH-M50X, ATH-M40X, ATH-M70X, and ATH-M60X.
The ATH-M50X is a wired, over-ear headphone, so it is the only complete headphone option in this comparison.
The product details describe its materials, length, and connectors, but do not establish a sound-quality improvement. I would consider it a replacement cable for a listed compatible headphone model, not a guaranteed audio upgrade.
Confirm that your headphones are one of the supported models and that the 1.5-meter length suits your setup. Also check that its 3.5 mm connection, 6.35 mm adapter, and locking 2.5 mm headphone-side connection match what you need.
• AUDREE Soft Ear Plugs vs PAXA Sleep Headphones
• Corsair Gaming VOID USB vs Acer Headset: Work From Home
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.