How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
• atgestore SP201 — biggest strength: A two-piece set in 304 stainless steel (a crisper basket plus a crumb/drip tray) sized for specific Ninja Foodi and Ninja digital air fry oven models, so it restores the actual cooking hardware rather than covering it.
• atgestore SP201 — biggest trade-off: It is model-specific. If your oven is not on the compatibility list, or you do not match the basket size (13.5"L x 12.3"W) and tray size (13.2"L x 13"W), it will not fit.
• Generic Silicone Air Fryer — biggest strength: A 2-pack of reusable, food-grade silicone liners in a rectangular shape for 8-quart dual-basket fryers, with raised ridges for airflow and grease drainage, plus a pair of silicone-tipped tongs.
• Generic Silicone Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: It is a liner, not a replacement part. It sits inside your existing basket, so it only works if you already have a compatible 8-quart dual-zone machine.
• Who each pick is for: Choose atgestore SP201 if your original Ninja basket or tray is worn, damaged or missing and you need a like-for-like replacement. Choose Generic Silicone Air Fryer if your fryer works fine and you mainly want less scrubbing, less sticking and easier food handling.
The SP201 set is a repair-and-restore product. It ships as one basket and one crumb tray, both made from 304 stainless steel. That material choice matters: the listing calls out that plating-based alternatives tend to rust and deform over time, while 304 steel is meant to hold its shape through repeated heating and washing. The basket measures 13.5"L x 12.3"W and the crumb tray measures 13.2"L x 13"W. The tray has a clear job — catching crumbs and oil that drop during cooking so they do not bake onto the bottom of the oven — and it is removable, so you can pull it out and clean it rather than fighting the interior.
Where this set really earns its place is compatibility. It is built around the Ninja part numbers 110BH300 (the oven basket) and 111bh300 (the crumb tray), and it lists a long roster of machines: the SP300, SP301, SP351 and its color variants, FT301 on the dual-heat side, plus SP200, SP201, SP251Q and its variants, FT201A, FT205CCO, FT205CO and FT405CO on the digital air fry oven side. That is a genuinely broad net for a replacement part, but it is still a net — it is not universal.
So who should buy it? If you own one of those listed Ninja models and your original basket has warped, discolored, rusted, or simply gone missing, this is the straightforward fix. The basket is designed with 360-degree air circulation in mind, so you keep the crispy results you bought the oven for. Cleaning is simple too — the listing describes a non-stick-style release that wipes down with a soapy sponge and hot water, though it is stainless steel, not a coated pan, so treat it as a metal part that needs normal maintenance.
Who should skip it? Anyone with a fryer that is not on the compatibility list, and anyone who has not measured. The listing itself tells you to compare the size against your Ninja Foodi flip-up air fryer toaster oven before ordering, and that is the right instinct. If you have a dual-basket 8-quart machine like the Ninja Foodi Dual Zone, this is not the part you want — you want a liner instead. Also skip it if your current basket is perfectly fine; there is no reason to replace working hardware.
This is a protection-and-convenience product, not a replacement. You get a 2-pack of rectangular silicone liners plus a pair of silicone-tipped tongs — three pieces total. The liners are 1.5 mm thick, which is the detail I would focus on: thicker silicone holds its shape better and does not flop or collapse when you lift it full of food, whereas thin liners tend to buckle. The material is food-grade and BPA-free, with a non-stick surface that resists stains and odors and is dishwasher safe.
Two design features make this set more practical than a plain silicone mat. First, raised ridges on the base lift food slightly so air can move underneath and grease can drain away — that is what keeps things crisp rather than steamed. Second, integrated side handles let you lift the liner out of the basket securely, and the included tongs are silicone-tipped so you are not scratching anything or risking a burn when you move hot food.
Heat resistance goes up to 450°F, and the liners are rated safe for air fryers, ovens, microwaves, freezers and dishwashers — so they are not single-purpose. The stated fit is a rectangular shape for 8-quart dual-basket air fryers, and the brand lists compatibility with Ninja Foodi, Cosori, Gourmia, Instant Pot and other major dual models.
Who should buy it? If you own an 8-quart dual-zone fryer and you are tired of scrubbing baked-on grease out of two baskets after every meal, this is the low-effort upgrade. It also suits anyone who cooks messy foods — marinated chicken, fish, anything with a sticky glaze — because the liner takes the hit and goes straight into the dishwasher.
Who should skip it? Anyone with a single-basket fryer or a machine that is not in the 8-quart dual-basket family, since the rectangular shape is sized for that layout. And skip it if you actually want the crisper texture of food sitting directly on a metal basket — a liner, even a ridged one, changes the airflow path and the browning you get at the base.
• Best for replacing broken or missing parts → atgestore SP201. It is the only one of the two that replaces the basket and tray themselves.
• Best for protecting a working fryer → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. Liners shield your existing baskets from grease and grime rather than replacing them.
• Best for specific Ninja Foodi / Ninja digital oven models → atgestore SP201. The compatibility list covers SP200, SP201, SP251Q, SP300, SP301, SP351, FT301, FT201A, FT205CO, FT405CO and more.
• Best for 8-quart dual-basket fryers → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. Rectangular liners sized for dual-zone machines, across several major brands.
• Best for durability under heat and metal-on-metal use → atgestore SP201. 304 stainless steel is built to resist rust and deformation in a way silicone cannot match for structural parts.
• Best for easy cleanup → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. Dishwasher-safe, non-stick and odor-resistant, with tongs included for serving.
• Best for handling hot food safely → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. Side handles plus silicone-tipped tongs are designed specifically to reduce burn risk.
• Best for a fryer you may replace later → Generic Silicone Air Fryer. Because it fits many dual-basket brands, it survives a machine upgrade more easily than a model-specific part.
In my opinion, the right pick comes down to one question: is your fryer broken or just annoying to clean? If a basket or tray has warped, rusted or gone missing and your oven is on the compatibility list, I would buy the atgestore SP201 — it is the part that actually gets your Ninja cooking again, and 304 stainless steel is the sensible material for that job. If your fryer works fine and you just want less scrubbing, better grease drainage and safer food handling, I would buy the Generic Silicone Air Fryer. If you are torn and your machine is working, the liners are the lower-commitment move. Either way, check the current price on Amazon before deciding, and measure your machine first — fit is the one thing that will sink either purchase.
Yes — it is a basket and crumb tray set, not a liner. It replaces the crisper basket (13.5"L x 12.3"W) and the crumb/drip tray (13.2"L x 13"W) on compatible Ninja Foodi and Ninja digital air fry oven models. Confirm your model is on the compatibility list and that the dimensions match before ordering.
They are described as a rectangular fit for 8-quart dual-basket fryers and are compatible with Ninja Foodi, Cosori, Gourmia, Instant Pot and other major dual models. A single-basket or non-dual machine is not the intended fit, so measure your basket interior first.
They can. The raised ridges are designed to keep air moving under the food and drain grease away, which helps browning, but food sitting in a liner rather than directly on a metal basket generally browns a little differently at the base. For maximum crispness, the bare stainless basket is the better choice.
They are durable in different ways. The 304 stainless steel set is built to resist rust and deformation as a structural part under repeated heat and washing. The silicone liners are rated to 450°F and hold their shape at 1.5 mm thick, but they are flexible by design and meant to be lifted, washed and reused rather than to bear weight like a basket.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Generic 3 vs PRETYZOOM Air Fryer Liner: Air Fryer Chicken, Pazcii Glass Air Fryer vs Generic LUGBAR Beautiful 3, Jizlan Silver 8 vs generic Stainless Steel Mesh: Air Fryer