We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-19 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a colour-matched hard shell built specifically around Beats on-ear headphones, choose Aproca Purple Headphone Case; if you need a black universal-fit case that covers JBL, Sony, Soundcore, BERIBES and KVIDIO on-ears, choose LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset.
• Aproca Purple Headphone Case — biggest strength: a purpose-built fit for the Beats family (Solo 3, Solo 4, Studio 3, Studio Pro), plus a striped purple shell that stands out from the sea of black cases.
• Aproca Purple Headphone Case — biggest trade-off: it's an empty case only, and its fit is narrow. If you don't own a listed Beats model, this isn't the case for you.
• LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset — biggest strength: broad compatibility across the most common budget on-ear headphones — JBL Tune, Sony WH-CH, Soundcore Anker Q-series, BERIBES, KVIDIO.
• LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset — biggest trade-off: black and utilitarian, with a "universal" fit that's designed to work with many models rather than being tailored to one.
• Buy the Aproca if you own Beats on-ears and want a case that matches the brand's look and locks your specific model in place.
• Buy the LVKAYCE if you own JBL, Sony or Soundcore on-ears, or you want one case that could plausibly serve a household with more than one pair.
The Aproca Purple Headphone Case is the specialist of the two. It's designed around a short, specific list: Beats Solo 3, Beats Solo 4, Beats Studio 3 Wireless and Beats Studio Pro. That narrowness is the whole point. A case made for one family of headphones can hug the earcups and headband more tightly than a universal shell, and that's exactly what Aproca is going for.
The build is high-density EVA with 1680D material on the outside — a hard shell with a durable fabric face. In practice that means the case is meant to take the abuse of a bag or a backpack without letting the headband get crushed or the earcups get scratched. It also has the small conveniences that matter on a daily commute: a comfortable hand strap, a D-shaped buckle for clipping it to something, a mesh pocket for cables and adapters, and a double zipper that runs smoothly around the opening. The striped purple finish is the obvious differentiator — this is a case you'll spot immediately in a crowded bag, and it's a deliberate style choice rather than a neutral accessory.
Who should buy it: Beats owners who want a dedicated, good-looking hard case and don't mind that it's built for one brand. Who should skip it: anyone with JBL, Sony, Soundcore, BERIBES or KVIDIO headphones, or anyone who wants a single case that could work across different pairs. Also note the listing is for the empty case only — the headphones in the photos are illustrative, not included. If you're weighing it up, check the current price on Amazon before committing, since that's the one variable I can't speak to here.
The LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset plays the opposite game: breadth. Its fit list covers JBL Tune 510BT, 720BT, 770BT and 770NC; Sony WH-CH520 and WH-CH720N; Soundcore Anker Q20, Q20i and Q30; plus BERIBES and KVIDIO wireless on-ears. That's a big chunk of the popular budget on-ear market in one case, and it's the reason this is the pick for most people who don't own Beats.
The construction is hard EVA with a soft velvet lining — a hard outer shell to absorb impacts and splashes, and a velvet inner surface to keep the finish of your headphones clean and free of scuffs. Inside there's a holding belt that pins the headphones in place so they don't rattle around in transit, and an upper mesh pocket for a charging cable or a small dongle. The zipper is smooth, and there's a comfortable carrying strap for work trips, commutes or vacations. It's a black, zipper-pattern case, so it's functional and understated rather than a style statement.
Who should buy it: anyone with one of the listed JBL, Sony, Soundcore, BERIBES or KVIDIO models, or a household where several people have different budget on-ears and one case needs to do the job. Who should skip it: Beats owners who want a tailored fit, and anyone who specifically wants a coloured case rather than black. Same caveat as the Aproca — it's the case only, headphones not included.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Beats owners → Aproca Purple Headphone Case. It's the only one of the two that lists Beats Solo 3, Solo 4, Studio 3 and Studio Pro by name.
• Best for JBL / Sony / Soundcore owners → LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset. Its fit list covers the Tune, WH-CH and Anker Q-series models directly.
• Best for a neutral, low-key case → LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset. Black zipper case, nothing loud about it.
• Best for holding the headphones still in transit → LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset. Its holding belt is designed to pin the headphones down; the Aproca relies on a tailored fit instead.
• Best for soft-touch interior protection → LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset. Velvet lining is the spec here; the Aproca's focus is the hard EVA and 1680D exterior.
• Best for carrying extras → both. Each has a mesh pocket for cables and small accessories, and each has a strap for carrying.
• Best if you own more than one brand of on-ears → LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset. One case, broader compatibility.
In my opinion, the deciding question isn't which case is "better" — it's which headphones you own. If you have Beats on-ears, I'd buy the Aproca Purple Headphone Case: a purpose-built fit plus a hard EVA and 1680D shell is exactly what a dedicated case should be, and the purple finish is a genuine plus. If you own JBL, Sony, Soundcore, BERIBES or KVIDIO on-ears, I'd buy the LVKAYCE Hard Headphone Headset: the velvet lining and holding belt are thoughtful touches for keeping a budget pair safe, and the compatibility list is far wider. Own neither? Then match the case to your headphones, not the other way round.
No — based on the listed specs it's designed for Beats Solo 3, Solo 4, Studio 3 and Studio Pro. If you own Sony, JBL, Soundcore, BERIBES or KVIDIO on-ears, the LVKAYCE case is the one that lists those models.
Both use hard EVA shells to resist drops, bumps and splashes. The Aproca adds a 1680D fabric exterior; the LVKAYCE adds a soft velvet lining and a holding belt to keep the headphones fixed. In my opinion they're aimed at the same level of protection, just with different approaches.
No. Both listings are for the empty case only — the headphones shown in the photos are for illustration and aren't included.
That depends on your headphones, not the cases. A tailored fit for your exact model is worth more than a generic one, so pick the case whose compatibility list matches what you own, then check the current price on Amazon for each.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.