How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want the simplest possible path to crispy air fryer chicken wings with almost no cleanup, choose Apenkes 8; if you need a durable, dishwasher-safe tray that actually replaces the air fry basket inside a Gourmia toaster oven, choose GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement.
• Apenkes 8 biggest strength: 200 disposable round paper liners with a 1.8-inch raised rim that catch grease and crumbs so the basket stays clean.
• Apenkes 8 biggest trade-off: It's a consumable — you use one per cook and throw it away, so it never becomes a permanent piece of equipment.
• GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement biggest strength: Food-grade steel tray sized 12.2'' x 11'' x 1'' that sits in the oven and circulates heat around wings without flipping.
• GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement biggest trade-off: It's a replacement part built around specific Gourmia models, so it only makes sense if you own one of those ovens.
• Who each pick is for: Apenkes 8 suits anyone with a 5–8QT air fryer who hates scrubbing; GCQFZ suits Gourmia toaster-oven-combo owners who want a reusable steel tray.
Apenkes 8 is a box of 200 round, 8-inch disposable liners made from wood pulp, designed to sit inside 5–8QT air fryer baskets. The headline number here is the 1.8-inch raised rim. That rim is what makes the liner useful rather than decorative — it holds sauce, oil and crumbs in place instead of letting them run underneath and bake onto the basket. For chicken wings specifically, this matters. Wings cooked in a sticky honey-garlic or teriyaki glaze are exactly the kind of cook that turns an air fryer basket into a scrubbing project. Drop a liner in first, and the mess stays on paper.
The heat rating is the other spec worth knowing: up to 428°F (220°C). That's high enough to cover the standard air fryer range, so you're not limited to reheating leftovers. You can do wings, nuggets, fries, roasted vegetables or a small pizza without worrying the liner will fail mid-cook. The material is unbleached wood pulp, and the brand describes it as heavy-duty and designed not to rip or leak.
Who should buy it? Anyone who air fries several times a week and resents the cleanup more than the cooking. It's also a genuinely practical gift for someone who hosts game nights or movie nights and ends up with a greasy basket at the end of it. Who should skip it? If you already own a reusable tray or basket liner you're happy with, or if you'd rather not manage a consumable, this isn't the pick. And if your air fryer is smaller than 5QT, the 8-inch round format is aimed at larger baskets.
GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement is a different kind of product entirely. It's a replacement air fryer tray for Gourmia toaster oven air fryers — the listing names the GTF7655, GTF7530, GTF7465 and GTF7520 — and it measures 12.2'' x 11'' x 1''. Note that 12.2 x 11 is a rectangular footprint, not a round one. This is not a liner you toss. It's a steel tray that lives in the oven and does the cooking surface job.
The material is food-grade steel, described as BPA-free, non-toxic, tasteless and meeting FDA standards. It's also stated as dishwasher safe, which is the real argument for it over paper: you load it, run it, and it's ready again. The listing also emphasizes durability — high-temperature resistance and no deformation — which is the trade-off you'd expect from steel versus disposable paper. It's heavier and it costs you a dishwasher cycle instead of costing you one liner.
The cooking claim worth noting is 360° heat circulation. Because the tray sits above the base and lets air move around the food, the brand states you don't need to turn or flip wings to get them crispy outside and juicy inside. That's a meaningful convenience if you're doing a full tray of wings for a crowd. The 14.9-ounce weight and 12.48 x 11.02 x 1.02-inch package tell you this is a real piece of hardware, not a thin accessory.
Who should buy it? Gourmia toaster-oven-combo owners whose original tray is lost, damaged or worn out — this is a direct replacement. It's also for anyone who wants a reusable steel surface for wings, fries, vegetables, pizza or steak and prefers dishwasher cleanup. Who should skip it? Anyone without a compatible Gourmia model. This is a fit-specific part, and buying it for a different brand's air fryer is a gamble the listing doesn't support.
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup after wings → Apenkes 8. The liner catches the glaze and crumbs; you throw it away.
• Best for a permanent, reusable cooking surface → GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement. Steel, dishwasher safe, no consumable to restock.
• Best for 5–8QT round air fryer baskets → Apenkes 8. The 8-inch round format and raised rim are built for that shape.
• Best for Gourmia GTF-series toaster oven air fryers → GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement. The tray is sized for those models specifically.
• Best for high-heat cooking up to 428°F (220°C) → Apenkes 8. That's the stated heat resistance of the liner.
• Best for hands-off wing batches → GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement. The 360° heat circulation design is meant to crisp food without flipping.
• Best for gifting → Apenkes 8. A 200-count box of liners is an easy, universally useful present for an air fryer owner.
• Best for buyers who hate restocking → GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement. Buy once, wash, reuse.
In my opinion, most people searching this comparison should buy Apenkes 8. It solves the single most annoying part of air frying wings — the greasy basket — and it works across any 5–8QT round air fryer, so compatibility is rarely an issue. I'd only steer you to GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement if you specifically own a compatible Gourmia toaster oven air fryer and need a durable replacement tray rather than a disposable liner. These aren't really competitors; they solve different problems. Pick based on your appliance, not on the comparison itself.
FAQ
how to air fryer chicken wings
Pat the wings dry, season them, and arrange them in a single layer so air can move around each piece. If you're using Apenkes 8 liners, set one in the basket first — the 1.8-inch rim contains the grease and any glaze. Cook at a temperature within the liner's 428°F (220°C) limit.
how to air fryer chicken wings crispy
how to air fryer chicken wings in the oven
If you're using a toaster oven air fryer combo like the Gourmia models the GCQFZ tray fits, place the tray in position and let the fan do the work. The tray's design is intended to crisp the outside while keeping the inside juicy. Spread wings out — 12.2'' x 11'' gives you real surface area to work with.
how to air fry chicken wings from frozen
Frozen wings release a lot of moisture, so expect a longer cook and a crisp-up at the end. A liner helps here because the water and rendered fat stay contained rather than pooling in the basket. Give frozen wings space, and don't sauce them until they've crisped.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement vs sjeygfr Air Fryer Safety, Loveuing Silicone Air Fryer vs Ragyzity 4: Air Fryer or Oven, GZHCJJ Air fryer Replacement vs Kispog Magnetic Air Fryer