A Pilot Study of the MSUM Regional Science Center
Table of Contents
The objective of this project was to investigate the metal content of soil and water samples from the MSUM Regional Science Center (RSC).
The MSUM Regional Science Center (RSC) is approximately 400 acres of prairie, forest, and river habitat. Image of the Buffalo River.
Metals occur naturally in soils, but their spatial distribution is influenced by the soil’s parent material as well as human influence such as different types of land use. Identifying and quantifying metals in soil and water is important because some metals are toxic. The RSC property has seen a variety of uses in recent history, including some that involved the use of fertilizers, pesticides, and fungicides which often contain metals.
The goal of this study was to obtain baseline data for metals concentrations in soil and water samples at the RSC. This pilot survey tested for the concentration of select metals of interest (Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, K, Mg, Mn, Ni, Pb, and Zn) in soil and water samples from several areas at the site.
The 10 metals of interest analyzed in this study. The metal selection was made based on the availability of cathode lamps and metals of interest for the location. Cd and Pb because they are heavy metals, Cu and Zn because of their presence in soil treatments such as fertilizers and fungicides, and Mg because of Mg compounds contributing to water hardness. Fe because it is a ubiquitous component of soil, so it served as a method control.
Sample collection, processing, and analysis occurred over the summer. Report writing, data analysis, and presenting occurred during the academic year.
A project proposal was created and then reviewed and approved by the College of Science, Health, and the Environment Student Advisory Board.
A series of calibrations were done to validate the instrument. A series of test soil digestions were completed and analyzed in order to validate the method.
Soil samples were collected using stainless steel soil probes. Water samples were collected in sterile 500mL plastic wide-mouth bottles.
A convenience sampling approach utilizing existing trails and bridges was used to survey a variety of locations at the site.
An aqua regia digestion was used. This was not a total digestion method, but would dissolve almost all elements of interest that could become environmentally available.
Analysis was performed using a 240FS AA from Agilent with an air/acetylene flame.
Calibration curves were fit using the new rational method. They were used to determine the concentration of metals in the collected samples.
Preliminary investigations of the spatial distribution were made by mapping the data in ArcGIS Pro.
Results were presented in detail in a report for the chemistry Senior Thesis capstone course.
Results were summarized in a poster that was presented at the Minnesota State University Student Academic Conference.
Most metals in the samples were either within or below normal ranges for the area.
Most of the metal concentrations had unimodal distributions, many of which were positively skewed due to a few high concentration samples as seen in the following histograms.
To understand these results in the context of the region, the soil sample results were compared to data from the United States Geological Survey (USGS). The USGS collected soil samples from locations East of Sabin, MN (Site MN6361) and near Rollag, MN (Site MN2265) in September 2009. Data from these locations offer comparison values and baseline metal concentrations for the region. The USGS published maps of the conterminous United States with interpolated values between sampling sites, from these maps a predicted range was determined for the location of the RSC.
USGS map for Cd concentrations in the soil A Horizon with RSC location and USGS sampling sites labeled.
Values were also compared to the Soil Reference Values (SRVs) from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA) which are a screening tool used to evaluate potential human health risks from exposure to contaminated soil. See the following table.
Table of metal concentrations in soil samples obtained from this study and comparison values from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA).
Some of the metals had average concentrations that matched expected concentrations for the region, and many had average concentrations below what was expected for the region. The USGS data came from analysis done using a total digestion technique while the RSC data from this study came from analysis done using a partial digestion technique. This may explain why some metals had average concentrations much lower than expected for the region. Why Cu, Fe, K, Mg, Mn, and Zn had concentrations below the expected range while Cd, Cr, and Pb had concentrations in the expected range was unclear. The chosen digestion technique was likely more effective at freeing Cd, Cr, and Pb from the soil matrix and less effective at freeing Cu, Fe, K, Mg, Mn, and Zn from the soil matrix.
Preliminary investigations of the spatial distribution were made by mapping the data.
Graduated symbol maps were created in ArcGIS Pro with data grouped into 5 classes based on the Jenks Natural Breaks method. This provided a qualitative picture of which locations had higher or lower metal concentrations.
These preliminary investigations of the spatial distribution identified areas of interest for continued study, i.e. areas of high concentration.
Since ArcGIS Online maps cannot be embedded, I have included a Google MyMaps showcasing the data in a graduated colors map. Click the icon in the upper left to see the various layers.
Contact abigailrbormann@gmail.com to get more information on the project