How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a reusable liner you can rinse, wipe, and keep using for months, choose Altalsby Air Fryer Silicone; if you need a no-wash, toss-and-go solution for greasy, messy cooks, choose Fyruzella Air Fryer Paper. That's the whole decision in one line. Everything below is the reasoning.
• Altalsby's biggest trade-off: You still have to wash them, and because both liners are the same round 8-inch size, they suit round 3–5 QT baskets far better than awkward or rectangular ones.
• Fyruzella's biggest strength: 100 pre-shaped 7-inch parchment liners with a raised 4.5cm edge — you line the basket, cook, and throw the mess away.
• Fyruzella's biggest trade-off: They're disposable, so you'll eventually run out and rebuy, and the paper needs care around preheating.
• Who Altalsby is for: Anyone who cooks in their air fryer almost daily and wants to stop buying liners altogether.
• Who Fyruzella is for: Anyone who hates scrubbing, cooks sticky or greasy food, and wants zero cleanup effort.
Altalsby sells a two-pack of round silicone liners sized for 3–5 QT air fryers. The listed fit covers 3qt, 4qt, 4.2qt, 4.5qt, 4.8qt and 5qt baskets, so it's aimed squarely at the mid-size machines most people own. Each liner is 8 inches across and 2 inches deep, made from clear, BPA-free food-grade silicone, and rated heat resistant up to 450°F. That temperature ceiling matters: it sits above what most air fryer recipes call for, so you're not fighting the liner's limits while you cook.
The real selling point is that this is a reusable product. You drop it into the basket, cook, then either hand-wash it or put it in the dishwasher — it's listed as dishwasher safe. Over time that means no repeat purchases, and no parchment sitting near a heating element. Altalsby specifically frames the silicone as a safer alternative to disposable paper liners on the fire-hazard point, and that's a fair design argument: silicone doesn't char or curl.
Who should buy it? Anyone who air fries several times a week and wants one purchase that keeps paying off. Who should skip it? If you cook for a crowd, rotate through multiple batches back-to-back, or genuinely can't face washing anything, the reusable route will annoy you. Also worth noting: at 8 inches round, these are built for round baskets. If your air fryer has an unusual shape, check the fit before committing.
Fyruzella Air Fryer Paper: Who It's For
Fyruzella takes the opposite approach. You get 100 disposable round parchment liners, each 7 inches across, pre-formed into a shallow bowl with a raised 4.5cm edge. They're made from natural wood pulp parchment with a food-grade silicone coating, listed as non-stick, oil-resistant and waterproof, and heat resistant up to 428°F. The material is unbleached and odorless, so it isn't supposed to leave a taste behind — a legitimate concern with cheap parchment.
The convenience angle is the whole product. You place a liner in the basket, cook, lift it out, and throw it away. Grease, crumbs and residue go in the bin with it, which is why Fyruzella emphasizes reduced cleaning time and a basket that stays clean after every use. There's no washing, no soaking, no dishwasher space used up. For anyone who cooks greasy wings, sticky marinades or breaded food, that's a genuinely appealing trade.
Two design details deserve attention. First, the pre-shaped bowl means no cutting, folding or tearing — you just drop it in, which is the kind of small thing that decides whether you actually use a product. Second, Fyruzella states the liners don't block hot air circulation, so heat still moves around the food. Air fryers work by moving hot air; a liner that blocks it defeats the point. Fyruzella also includes a specific warning worth repeating: don't put the liner in during preheating. Add it with the food after preheating, so the paper never contacts the heating element.
The obvious trade-off is that it's disposable. You will run out and buy more, and you'll be generating paper waste with every cook. The 100-count pack softens that, but it doesn't change the fundamental model.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for zero cleanup → Fyruzella Air Fryer Paper. Lift it out, bin it, done.
• Best for greasy, sticky foods → Fyruzella. Marinades and breading are exactly what disposable liners handle best.
• Best for higher-heat cooking → Altalsby. Silicone is rated to 450°F versus 428°F for the parchment.
• Best for round 3–5 QT baskets → both. Altalsby's 8-inch liners and Fyruzella's 7-inch liners are both built for that range.
• Best for batch cooking → Altalsby. One liner can handle repeated rounds; paper is one-and-done per cook.
• Best for travel, camping or BBQs → Fyruzella. A stack of flat paper liners packs far more easily than two silicone bowls.
• Best for people who hate washing dishes → Fyruzella. This is the deciding factor for most shoppers.
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the Altalsby Air Fryer Silicone liners. In my opinion, the reusable model wins on the math that actually matters over a year of cooking: two thick silicone liners that survive the dishwasher and handle up to 450°F beat a stack you'll eventually exhaust. The thicker build is a real differentiator too — thin silicone liners flop and tear, and Altalsby explicitly positions itself against that.
That said, I'd genuinely recommend Fyruzella to anyone whose real problem is the scrubbing, not the buying. If you know you won't wash a liner, reusable silicone is the wrong answer no matter how good it is. Pick based on your habits, then check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
Neither is universally better — they solve different problems. Silicone is reusable, dishwasher safe and rated to a higher heat (450°F on the Altalsby). Paper is disposable, needs no washing and is rated to 428°F on the Fyruzella. Choose by whether you'd rather wash or throw away.
Do Fyruzella air fryer paper liners fit a 5 QT air fryer?
Yes. Fyruzella lists the 7-inch liners as fitting 3–5 QT air fryers, and the same range applies to Altalsby's 8-inch silicone liners. Both are designed for round mid-size baskets, so if your air fryer is an unusual shape, verify the fit first.
In my opinion, yes — if you air fry often. Two reusable liners replace ongoing paper purchases and can go in the dishwasher. If you cook rarely or hate washing up, disposable paper is the more practical choice.
Fyruzella says no. Add the liner together with the food after preheating, so the paper doesn't contact the heating element. Silicone liners like Altalsby's don't carry that restriction, which is one small advantage of the reusable route.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ZOWVAAM Air Fryer Liners vs RedLemon Air Fryer Paper, Boribim 9 vs Mobestech Silicone Air Fryer, uxcell 18Pcs vs Generic Silicone Air Fryer