How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• ALJ 4QT — biggest strength: Purpose-built carbon steel crisper plate with a double-layer nonstick coating, a handle for lifting it out, and FDA-standard, BPA-free food-grade construction.
• ALJ 4QT — biggest trade-off: It's a single-fryer accessory. It's designed for the Gourmia GAF414 4QT, and you're told to fine-tune the four feet to match your basket — so it's the wrong buy for anyone with a different machine.
• HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9 — biggest strength: A three-piece silicone set (a 2-in-1 split liner plus one full liner) that folds flat for storage, handles up to 446°F, and works in air fryers, ovens, microwaves and steamers.
• HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9 — biggest trade-off: It's a liner, not a crisper plate. It catches grease and keeps your basket clean, but it doesn't give you the perforated, raised-grid airflow that a steel plate does, and sizing depends on you measuring your basket first.
• Pick ALJ 4QT if you own a Gourmia GAF414 4QT and want a drop-in replacement or upgrade for the crisper plate that came with it.
• Pick HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9 if you own a 5–8QT air fryer from Ninja, Cosori, Chefman, Instant Pot or similar and want reusable, stackable liners that cut cleanup time.
The ALJ 4QT is the narrow, specific tool. It's a carbon steel crisper plate sized for the Gourmia GAF414 Digital 4QT air fryer, and it exists to do one job: replace or improve the perforated tray that sits in your basket. The design is straightforward — a flat plate with a small handle so you can lift it out without burning your fingers, and four silicone rubber feet included so you can adjust how tightly it sits in the basket.
What it does best is airflow and browning. A raised, perforated steel plate lets hot air move under and around food, which is exactly what you want for frozen fries, nuggets, reheated pizza or anything you'd normally shake halfway through. The double-layer nonstick coating is the practical part: food releases, and the plate goes in the dishwasher. ALJ also notes it's made of food-grade carbon steel that meets FDA standards and is BPA-free.
Who should buy it: someone who already owns the Gourmia GAF414 4QT and has a worn, scratched or missing crisper plate, or who just wants a spare so one can soak while the other cooks. Who should skip it: anyone with a different air fryer. The compatibility note is explicit — this fits the GAF414 4QT, and you're expected to adjust the four feet for a snug fit. If your basket isn't that machine, look elsewhere. One more practical tip from the specs: don't scrub it with abrasive pads or metal balls, or you'll wreck the nonstick layer.
HOMELYLIFE takes the opposite approach: instead of a rigid plate for one fryer, it's a three-piece silicone liner set built to fit many. The headline is the design. You get a square liner split into two halves — a 2-in-1 — plus one whole large square liner. The split one is the clever bit: cook two different foods side by side in the same basket without them mixing, or pull the halves apart when you only need half the space. The full liner is for big items like a whole chicken or a pile of fries.
The material story is solid for the category. Food-grade silicone, non-stick, BPA-free, heat-resistant to 446°F, reinforced to resist warping, and dishwasher safe. The raised bottom is designed to let excess grease drain away from food while still allowing hot air to circulate, and there's an elevated handle so you can lift a hot liner out. When you're done, the whole thing folds down and tucks away — a genuine advantage if your kitchen storage is tight.
Who should buy it: anyone with a 5–8QT air fryer — HOMELYLIFE names Ninja AF141, AF142 and AF181, plus Cosori, Chefman and Instant Pot — who's tired of scrubbing the basket after every cook. It's also handy beyond the air fryer: oven, microwave, steamer, camping and baking all work. Who should skip it: people who want crispy, plate-style results from a perforated steel grid, and anyone unwilling to measure their basket first — the listing says plainly to check the size before ordering.
• Best for a Gourmia GAF414 4QT → ALJ 4QT. It's the only one of the two designed specifically for that machine.
• Best for broad compatibility → HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9. It's aimed at 5–8QT fryers across several brands.
• Best for crispy, air-circulated results → ALJ 4QT. The raised steel crisper plate is built for airflow and browning.
• Best for keeping your basket clean → HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9. A liner catches grease and residue so the basket barely needs washing.
• Best for cooking two foods at once → HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9. Its 2-in-1 split liner is made exactly for that.
• Best for tight storage → HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9. It folds flat; a steel plate doesn't.
• Best for multi-appliance use → HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9. Air fryer, oven, microwave, steamer and baking all work; the ALJ plate is a fryer insert only.
• Best for durability under high heat → a tie in my view. Carbon steel with a double-layer coating versus reinforced silicone rated to 446°F — both are built to last if you treat them properly.
If I owned the Gourmia GAF414 4QT, I'd buy the ALJ 4QT. It's the right tool for that exact fryer: a real crisper plate with airflow, a handle and a dishwasher-safe nonstick surface, at a fraction of the fuss of a universal accessory. But if my air fryer were anything else — or if I wanted one accessory that also works in the oven and microwave — I'd buy the HOMELYLIFE Collapsible 9 without hesitating. In my opinion it's the more versatile purchase for most households, simply because it fits more machines and folds away when it's not needed. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit; the button on this page will show you.
FAQ
No. The listing states it's made for the Gourmia GAF414 Digital 4QT, and you're asked to adjust the four feet to fit that basket. For other fryers, the HOMELYLIFE set is the more sensible choice.
It's designed for 5–8QT baskets, including Ninja AF141, AF142 and AF181, plus Cosori, Chefman and Instant Pot models. Measure your basket before ordering, since sizing is the one thing that decides whether it works.
Both are dishwasher safe. The HOMELYLIFE liners are non-stick silicone and fold for storage, while the ALJ plate is a rigid nonstick tray — but avoid abrasive pads or metal scrubbers on it, as that can damage the coating.
Yes. They're rated heat-resistant up to 446°F and the listing says they're oven safe, and also suitable for microwaves, steamers and baking — the ALJ plate is intended for the air fryer only.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: BELLA Fits-anywhere Slim 4qt vs JUOPTGJ 3.81qt: Best Air, WINNIESHOP 18Qt vs NKLOKSD 4.4QT: Best Non Toxic Air Fryer, YUVAMAGIMO Retro Sunflowers Patterns vs GLENLCWE Thanksgiving Pumpikn