How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Air Fryer — best if you mainly want crispy food fast, in a small kitchen, with almost no cleanup.
• Toaster Oven — best if you want one countertop appliance that can toast, bake, roast and air fry for a family.
An air fryer is a small, sealed convection oven built around a basket. A fan pushes very hot air around the food, so the surface dries out and browns the way deep-frying does, but with a fraction of the oil. That's the whole trick, and it's a good one.
The Ninja AF101 shows what the category looks like in practice. It runs from 105°F to 400°F, which covers more than you'd expect: the top of that range is for crisping, and the bottom is for dehydrating. Four programs — Air Fry, Roast, Reheat and Dehydrate — mean you're not guessing at settings.
That 4-quart basket is the number that matters day to day. It fits about 2 lbs of French fries, which is genuinely family-sized for a side dish, but it's not a roasting pan. A whole chicken won't fit. A 12-inch pizza won't fit. You cook in batches, or you cook parts.
The trade-off is scope. An air fryer is superb at what it does and useless at what it doesn't. It won't toast six slices of bread, it won't bake a cake in a normal pan, and it won't hold a casserole dish. It also takes up real counter space for a single-purpose machine — the AF101's footprint is roughly 13.6 by 11 inches.
A toaster oven is a small oven that sits on your counter, and the better ones now include air frying as one mode among many. You're buying capacity and range of tasks, not just crispiness.
The Cuisinart TOA-60W is a good example of the type. It has a 1800-watt motor and knobs for temperature and function, with convection bake, convection broil, pizza, roast, bagel, reheat, warm and defrost, plus high and low fan speeds and a dual-cook setting. The temperature window — 80°F to 450°F — goes higher than the air fryer and lower too.
The capacity is the real argument for this type. It toasts six slices of bread, air fries up to 3 lbs of chicken wings, bakes a 12-inch pizza, or roasts a 4-pound chicken. That's a full meal in one appliance, on one rack, without batch cooking.
You also get a 60-minute timer with auto shutoff, a toast shade selector, an oven light, and a nonstick interior. Included are a rack, a baking pan and an air fryer basket. The trade-off is size, weight and warm-up. This thing is 21 pounds and about 16 by 15.5 inches — it dominates a counter. It also takes longer to come to temperature than a basket air fryer, and the door-and-rack format means more surfaces to wipe down.
Speed and crispiness. For fries, wings and nuggets, a basket air fryer wins. The cooking chamber is small and the air circulates tightly around the food, so it preheats fast and crisps hard. A toaster oven air fries well, but it's a bigger box to heat and the food sits on a rack rather than tumbling in concentrated air. If your goal is the crispiest possible result in the least time, the air fryer is the better tool.
Space. The air fryer is smaller, but it's a dedicated appliance. The toaster oven is bigger, but it can replace your toaster and possibly your full-size oven for small jobs. In a tiny kitchen, I'd still lean air fryer. In a normal kitchen where you'd otherwise own a toaster anyway, the toaster oven earns its footprint.
Versatility. This isn't close. The TOA-60W toasts, bakes, broils, roasts, warms and air fries. The AF101 air fries, roasts, reheats and dehydrates in a basket. If you want one appliance to do many things, the toaster oven is the answer.
Cleanup. The air fryer's basket and crisper plate are dishwasher safe, and the exterior just needs a wipe. The toaster oven has a nonstick interior, but you're cleaning a rack, a pan, a basket and a door. Air fryer wins on convenience; toaster oven wins on nothing here.
Which Should You Get?
Get an air fryer if your priority is fast, crispy food for one to four people and you're short on counter space. Get a toaster oven if you want to replace your toaster or your big oven for everyday cooking and you regularly cook for a family.
If you're genuinely torn, the deciding question is simple: do you need to make toast and bake a pizza, or do you just want perfect fries? Toast and pizza means toaster oven.
I'd point you to the Ninja AF101. It's a 4-quart, 1550-watt machine with touch controls and four programs — Air Fry, Roast, Reheat and Dehydrate — so it covers more than just frying. The 105°F to 400°F range is what makes the dehydrate function real rather than a gimmick.
The basket and crisper plate are aluminum with a nonstick ceramic coating, and both are dishwasher safe. It ships with a 20-recipe booklet, which matters more than it sounds if you're new to air frying. In my opinion, this is the right shape and size for a couple or a small family that wants crispy food without a lot of oil or a lot of cleanup.
Our Pick If You Choose Toaster Oven
The Cuisinart TOA-60W is my pick for the toaster oven side. The 1800-watt motor and 80°F to 450°F range give it real range, and the function list is long: convection bake, convection broil, pizza, roast, bagel, reheat, warm, defrost, plus high and low fan speeds and dual cook.
Generally yes, for small batches. The cooking chamber is smaller and the air circulates more tightly around the food, so it comes up to temperature faster. A toaster oven takes longer to heat a bigger space but can cook more food at once.
For small and medium jobs, often yes. The TOA-60W handles a 12-inch pizza or a 4-pound chicken. For big holiday cooking or large sheet pans, you'll still want a full-size oven.
The air fryer, in my opinion. Its basket and crisper plate are dishwasher safe and the exterior wipes clean. A toaster oven means cleaning a rack, a pan, a basket and the interior.
Not in a 4-quart basket like the AF101's — it's sized for about 2 lbs of fries. A toaster oven with the capacity of the TOA-60W can roast a 4-pound chicken.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer oven vs toaster oven, SUNVIVI 14-Quart vs WAA Air Fryer Toaster: Air Fryer VS Oven, ZhenD Toaster Oven Replacement vs HZOPUTLH 1200W: Air Fryer