How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
• BYKITCHEN 11x12 — best for large air fryer ovens and toaster ovens used every day; pick this if you want 100 disposable sheets you can trim to fit and a 450°F heat ceiling.
• WMKGG 100 — best for Cuisinart-style countertop ovens and anyone who wants a reusable mat in the box; pick this if you'd rather not buy a separate grill mat.
• SIUDANGKA 4PCS — best for Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro owners; pick this if you want a reusable floor liner cut to 12.5" x 19" that can also act as a drip pan or grill mat.
• brikinte Non-stick Reusable Air — best for Ninja DT201/DT251 owners; pick this if you want four reusable PTFE sheets shaped to sit on the original oven tray.
This is a 100-piece pack of rectangular parchment sheets measuring 11 x 12 inches, made from unbleached wood pulp with a food-grade nonstick coating. The sheets are perforated with a pattern of holes rather than punched randomly — the idea being that air and steam still move around the food instead of getting trapped under a solid barrier. If you've ever lined a basket with a plain sheet and noticed the underside of your food steaming instead of crisping, the holes are the fix.
The size is the reason I put it first. An 11 x 12 sheet covers the floor of a large air fryer oven — the sheet itself names the Ninja SP101 and SP201 style ovens, plus XL air fryers, toaster ovens and dehydrators — and it's oversized enough that you can cut it down for a smaller basket without ending up with a useless sliver. A 100-count pack also means you're not treating each sheet like it's precious. Tear one, grab another.
What it does day to day: catch drips, stop grease from baking onto the oven floor, and turn cleanup into lifting a sheet out and throwing it away. The nonstick coating keeps food from welding itself to the paper, and because it's unbleached, there's no bleaching residue to think about. Heat resistance is rated to 450°F, which covers the vast majority of air fryer and toaster oven cooking.
The trade-off is real and the manufacturer is upfront about it: this is disposable paper, and it will move. If you preheat an empty oven with a sheet sitting on the rack, the airflow can lift it into the heating element and scorch it. The stated rule is to put enough food on top first — the sheet says the food should cover at least two-thirds of the paper's area. There's also a maximum heating time of 45 minutes noted, extendable by 5 to 15 minutes when there's enough food on top. In my opinion, that's a small amount of discipline in exchange for never scrubbing a rack again.
WMKGG 100
Same basic concept, different execution. The WMKGG pack is 100 sheets at 12 x 11 inches, made from wood pulp with a double silicone coating — the silicone is what gives it the release and the stain resistance. The sheet calls out compatibility with Cuisinart TOA-60 and TOA-65, plus Breville, Black & Decker, Hamilton Beach and Cosori, with the sensible caveat to measure your appliance first.
Temperature range is listed as -68 to 425°F, which is a slightly lower ceiling than some parchment products but still well within normal air frying and baking territory. The double silicone coating keeps food from sitting directly against the metal and leaving stains behind.
The trade-off is that lower ceiling combined with the same handling caution: don't put the paper in during preheat mode, keep it under the food, and never let it touch the heating tube — the tube runs far hotter than the paper's rating. And because the sheet is 12 x 11 rather than something larger, very big ovens will need it positioned deliberately rather than just dropped in. For a Cuisinart or similar countertop oven, though, it's a near-exact fit.
This one is a different animal entirely: reusable mats rather than disposable paper. You get four black rectangular liners at 12.5" x 19", made from a fiberglass-based material, and they're cut specifically to fit the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV845BSS. The stated job is shielding the oven floor from spills, drips and food residue.
Because they're reusable, the math changes. You're not restocking; you're wiping one down and putting it back. The material is BPA-free and PFOA-free, and the sheet notes it's free of lead and cadmium and can be cooked on directly without melting. Heat resistance is up to 500°F, which is the highest ceiling of the four picks here. The brand also positions it as multifunctional — grill mat, baking mat, oven liner, pan liner, drip pan — so it can migrate between appliances.
The 12.5" x 19" footprint is the key spec. That's a floor-covering size, not a basket-liner size, which makes it genuinely useful for a toaster oven where crumbs and cheese drips land on the bottom element area. The sheet includes a practical note for ovens with hidden heating elements: place the liner on the lowest tray or grill rather than on the bare floor.
The trade-off is fit rigidity. These are made for one oven model family, and there's no mention of trimming them — so if you don't own that Breville, or something close to it, they may not seat properly. They also need the same respect as any liner: no direct contact with heating elements or open flames. In my opinion, this is the pick if you own that specific Breville and you'd rather scrub a mat than buy paper forever.
brikinte Non-stick Reusable Air
That "compatible with the original tray" detail matters more than it sounds. Because the mats are cut to sit on the tray you already own, they drop in without fiddling or trimming if you have one of those Ninjas. And if you don't, the brand explicitly says you can cut them down for other trays and sizes — which makes them far more flexible than a rigid floor liner. Four mats means you can keep one in the oven, one drying, and two in the drawer.
The material is the story here. PTFE is the same family of nonstick coating used on plenty of cookware, and it's what makes these wipe-clean rather than scrub-clean. The whole pitch is that cleaning up after air frying is the annoying part, and a reusable liner that lifts out and rinses off removes most of it.
The trade-off is temperature discipline. The max is stated as 480°F, but the brand recommends keeping actual use below 450°F because of how the material behaves at its limits. That's a narrower working window than the SIUDANGKA mats and it means you should think twice before running a very hot bake or broil cycle with one in place. If you mostly air fry and roast in the 350–425°F range, it's a non-issue. If you like ripping hot temperatures, paper or a higher-rated mat is the safer call.
I compared the published specs and features on each product sheet — material, dimensions, heat rating, sheet count, stated compatibility and handling warnings — and weighed them against how people actually use air fryer ovens: daily convenience, fit, and cleanup. The ranking is my independent editorial opinion. No brand paid for placement, and no product was included because of anything other than what its specs say it does.
Only if they're solid and cover the whole basket. The parchment options here are perforated specifically so heat and steam circulate; the reusable mats sit on the floor or tray and leave the basket's sides open. Follow the food-coverage guidance and you won't smother anything.
Not the paper ones. Both parchment brands warn against preheating with a sheet in place, because airflow can lift it into the heating element. Put the food down first, then the liner stays put. Reusable mats are less prone to flying, but still shouldn't touch the element.
Disposable if you want zero cleanup and you're lining a large oven floor — 100 sheets lasts a long time and you can trim to fit. Reusable if you own one of the specific ovens named, want a higher heat ceiling, and don't mind a quick rinse instead of a restock.
Measure first. The 11 x 12 and 12 x 11 parchment sheets can be cut down to smaller baskets, and the brikinte mats are explicitly trimmable. The SIUDANGKA 12.5" x 19" liners are cut for a specific Breville model, so those are the least forgiving if your oven differs.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer oven microwave, toaster oven air fryer combo, air fryer paper liners disposable