How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
My top pick is the OPENICE Air Fryer Basket, because it is the only set here that gives you three different basket-and-tray sizes plus matching parchment in one box — so you can air fry a single portion or a full sheet-pan dinner without buying anything else.
• OPENICE Air Fryer Basket — best for households that cook different amounts on different nights; pick this if you want three sizes (12.8×9.6, 15.6×11.6 and 18.6×12.8 inches) plus 30-count parchment papers per size in one purchase.
• Chef Pomodoro Air Fryer Basket — best for oven and grill duty in a smaller kitchen; pick this if you want a single 12.8"D × 12.4"W × 3"H rectangular crisper basket with a nesting copper tray and easy-grip handles.
• DONGULI Air Fryer Basket — best for everyday family cooking on a budget of space; pick this if two 12.8×9.6-inch stainless steel basket-and-tray sets cover most of your roasting and reheating.
• DEGOVIN Air Fryer Basket — best for big-batch roasting and high-heat cooking; pick this if you need an 18.8×12.8-inch basket in thicker 0.6 mm stainless steel that the brand says resists warping above 450°F.
OPENICE sells this as a three-set bundle rather than a single basket, and that is the whole reason it sits at the top of my list. You get a medium basket and tray at 12.8×9.6 inches, a large at 15.6×11.6 inches, and an extra large at 18.6×12.8 inches — each one a mesh basket sitting over a solid tray. The package also includes three packs of parchment paper at 30 counts per size, cut to match. Everything is stainless steel with a non-stick surface, and the whole thing is dishwasher-safe.
In daily use, the mesh basket is what does the work: hot air moves around the food on all sides instead of only hitting the top, which is why you are not standing there flipping pieces halfway through. The tray underneath catches the fat and crumbs that drip off, so your oven floor stays cleaner and you are not scrubbing burnt-on grease later. The non-stick coating means you can skip the butter or oil you would normally add to stop food from welding itself to the metal.
The three sizes are the practical part. One person reheating leftovers uses the medium. A family roasting vegetables for four uses the large. A holiday bird, a big tray of wings, or a full batch of cookies for guests uses the extra large. Because the baskets and trays work together or separately, you can also run two sizes side by side in the same oven if your racks allow it. At 6.3 pounds for the whole set, it is not featherweight, but it is also not the kind of thing you wrestle in and out constantly.
The trade-off is straightforward: you are buying three sets whether or not you need three sets. If your oven is small, the 18.6×12.8-inch basket may simply not fit, and you will be storing pieces you rarely use. In my opinion, this is the pick for anyone who cooks for a variable number of people and wants one purchase to cover all of it.
Chef Pomodoro Air Fryer Basket
The design intent here is a single pan that cooks a complete meal. Fish and chips, a roast hen with vegetables around it, a homemade pizza — the mesh lets heat circulate so everything on the basket browns at roughly the same rate, and the copper tray below catches whatever drips. Use the tray alone and it behaves like a baking sheet for cookies, biscuits or rolls. The non-stick coating and dishwasher-safe construction keep cleanup short.
What I like most is that Chef Pomodoro explicitly designs this for the grill as well. Smaller vegetables fall through wide grill grates; a mesh basket holds them. Corn, onions, mushrooms, zucchini and peppers go straight in the basket on the grates and come off tender with char. That is a genuinely useful second job for a piece of kitchen gear.
The trade-off is size and material. This is a single large rectangle, so a small oven or a toaster-oven setup may be tight, and you do not get the option of a smaller basket for a single portion. Copper also asks for a bit more care than bare stainless if you want the finish to last. I would pick this if you want one well-handled pan that works indoors and on the grill.
DONGULI keeps it simple: two stainless steel basket-and-tray sets, each 12.8×9.6 inches, in silver. The basket is a mesh design that sits elevated over the pan so heat circulates around the food rather than pooling under it. The brand pitches this as the size that lets you cook more at once, and 12.8×9.6 inches is a genuinely useful footprint for a standard sheet-pan slot.
The 360-degree circulation claim is the functional heart of it. Because the mesh is elevated, hot air reaches the underside of your food too, which reduces the odds of a burnt top and a pale bottom, and means you are not flipping nuggets or fries halfway through. That is the difference between an air fryer basket and a flat baking sheet, and it is the reason these trays brown food more evenly.
Beyond air frying, DONGULI points out the multi-purpose angle: it doubles as a cooling rack for fried or grilled food, a draining basket for washed fruit and vegetables, and a resting place for dishes when it is not in the oven. Cleaning is soap-and-water simple, and the stainless steel construction means you are not babying a coating. If you cook oily food often, that easy rinse matters.
DEGOVIN Air Fryer Basket
DEGOVIN goes big. The basket measures 18.8×12.8 inches, which is the largest single basket in this group and about the footprint of a half-sheet pan. It is stainless steel, in a black XL set finish, and it ships with 30 pre-cut parchment papers sized for the tray.
The spec worth paying attention to is the thickness. DEGOVIN states the mesh is 0.6 mm stainless rather than the 0.4 mm the brand says is common on competing pans, specifically so it will not pop or warp when oven temperature climbs past 450°F. That is a real concern with thin mesh trays — they flex and buckle under high heat, and a warped basket does not sit flat. Thicker steel also holds up better over repeated dishwasher cycles.
Functionally, the elevated mesh does the familiar job: heat wraps around the food, so you get even browning without flipping, and the tray underneath catches grease and debris so your oven stays cleaner. DEGOVIN lists oven fries, pizza, onion rings, roast turkey, vegetables, hash browns and fried chicken as targets, and it also works as a reheat tray. The easy-grip handles let you pull the whole thing out without burning your knuckles.
The trade-off is obvious: 18.8×12.8 inches is a lot of pan. It will not fit a compact oven, and it takes up serious cabinet space when stored. For a large household, a holiday cook, or anyone who wants one big surface for roasting vegetables and protein together, that size is the entire point. The brand also notes you should avoid scratching the coating, so use the parchment and skip metal tongs.
I compared the published specifications and features of each basket — dimensions, material, thickness where stated, handle design, included accessories and dishwasher compatibility — and weighed them against how people actually cook: portion size, oven size, and whether the tray does a second job. The ranking is my independent editorial opinion, based on what the specs tell a buyer. No brand paid for placement, and no product here was selected on anything but its stated design.
FAQ
Yes, if your oven has a convection or air fry setting. The mesh basket lifts food off the solid tray so hot air moves around it on all sides, which is the same principle a countertop air fryer uses. In a standard bake-only oven you will get more even browning than a flat sheet, but less crisping.
Not much. All four use a non-stick or low-contact mesh surface, so food releases without butter or heavy oil, and the tray underneath lets excess fat drip away. A light spray helps browning on leaner foods like vegetables.
OPENICE, Chef Pomodoro and DEGOVIN all state dishwasher-safe construction, and DONGULI says soap and water is enough. DEGOVIN advises avoiding scratches on the coating, so stack carefully and use the included parchment.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: OIXXAF Air Fryer Oven vs GWYSY Air Fryer Basket, is air fryer better than oven, air fryer rotisserie basket