How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want serious passive noise blocking for loud, clanging environments, choose 3M Peltor Optime 98; if you need a wired stereo headset with a boom mic for calls, classes, and everyday listening, choose Logitech H111. These two products only look like competitors at a glance — one is occupational hearing protection, the other is a communication headset. If your actual search was for the best wireless headset for gym, or for ipx7 waterproof bluetooth headphones for gym, neither of these is that product, and I'll explain why below so you don't buy the wrong thing for the best headphones for gym use case.
• 3M Peltor Optime 98 — biggest strength: NRR 24 dB of sound isolation with liquid- and foam-filled earcup cushions and an adjustable tilt design that seals well for long wear.
• 3M Peltor Optime 98 — biggest trade-off: It makes no sound, plays no audio, and is explicitly labeled for industrial/occupational use only, not consumer sale or use.
• Logitech H111 — biggest strength: A plug-and-play 3.5 mm stereo headset with a 180° rotating noise-canceling boom mic and a 7.71 ft cord, built for calls and classes.
• Logitech H111 — biggest trade-off: It's wired, so there's no wireless freedom, and it isolates far less noise than a dedicated earmuff.
• Who each pick is for: 3M Peltor Optime 98 for people who need to block loud noise; Logitech H111 for people who need to hear and be heard on a computer, tablet, or phone.
The Optime 98 is a hearing conservation product, full stop. Its headline number is a Noise Reduction Rating of 24 decibels, which is the kind of figure that matters when you're standing next to machinery, not when you're trying to enjoy a podcast. The earcups are liquid- and foam-filled, and that combination is doing two jobs at once: sealing against your head for isolation and staying comfortable long enough that you don't rip the thing off after twenty minutes.
The frame is built to be worn, not admired. A stainless steel headband spreads the clamping force across the top of your head, and the earcup pivot points tilt so the cups follow the shape of your skull instead of fighting it. 3M also notes the muffs are E-A-Rfit compatible, which matters in workplace settings where fit verification is part of a hearing conservation program. The whole thing comes in at 10.08 ounces, and the dimensions are 8 x 6 x 4 inches with an over-the-head fit and a yellow ABS shell.
Logitech H111: Who It's For
The H111 is the opposite kind of product entirely. It's a stereo headset with a standard 3.5 mm jack, which means it plugs into a Chromebook, a Windows laptop or PC, an iPad, a smartphone, or a tablet and just works. Logitech lists it as a certified Works With Chromebooks product, which tells you the target audience: schools, call centers, and anyone doing a lot of talking into a microphone.
The mic is the star. It rotates a full 180°, so you can wear the boom on whichever side suits you, and you can tuck it out of the way when you're not on a call. Logitech describes it as noise-canceling, with the flexible boom positioned for better voice capture and background noise reduction — the practical effect is that your voice comes through cleaner on the other end of a video call or webinar.
Comfort details are sensible rather than luxurious. The headband adjusts, the ear cushions are leatherette and easy to wipe down between users (a deliberate choice for shared classroom use), and the cord runs 7.71 feet — long enough that you can stand up and stretch mid-conversation without unplugging. On the audio side you get dynamic drivers with a 20 Hz–20 kHz frequency range, 32 ohm impedance, and 100 dB sensitivity, which is standard, easy-to-drive headset territory. It weighs 128 g, so it's light on the head. It also carries a 1-year limited hardware warranty.
Who should buy it: students, remote workers, teachers, and anyone who needs a cheap, reliable wired headset for calls and casual listening. Who should skip it: anyone who wants a wireless setup, and anyone expecting meaningful noise blocking. The H111's "sound isolation" is incidental to wearing over-ear cups — it is not a 24 dB hearing protector, and it isn't meant to be.
• Best for blocking loud noise → 3M Peltor Optime 98. NRR 24 dB with liquid- and foam-filled cushions is a genuine hearing-protection spec.
• Best for talking on calls → Logitech H111. The 180° rotating noise-canceling boom mic is the whole point of this headset.
• Best for wearing all day → Logitech H111. At 128 g with an adjustable headband and soft leatherette cushions, it's the lighter, more casual wear.
• Best for long-session comfort under pressure → 3M Peltor Optime 98. The stainless steel headband and tilting earcups are designed to spread weight and keep the seal comfortable.
• Best for shared or multi-user settings → Logitech H111. Wipeable leatherette cushions and universal 3.5 mm compatibility make it the easier hand-off device.
• Best for device compatibility → Logitech H111. Chromebooks, Windows laptops and PCs, iPads, phones, tablets — anything with a 3.5 mm jack.
• Best for gym use → neither, honestly. If you want headphones for the gym, you're looking for a wireless, sweat-resistant design — ideally ipx7 waterproof bluetooth headphones for gym sessions — and both of these fall short of that brief for different reasons.
• Best for audio playback → Logitech H111. The Peltor Optime 98 has no drivers and plays nothing.
In my opinion, the right pick depends entirely on which job you actually have. If you need to protect your hearing around loud equipment, I'd buy the 3M Peltor Optime 98 — the NRR 24 dB rating, stainless steel headband, and tilting, liquid-filled earcups are built for exactly that, and nothing on the Logitech side comes close for noise blocking. If you need to talk on calls, attend classes, or just listen to audio from a laptop or tablet, I'd buy the Logitech H111, because it actually makes sound, has a proper boom mic, and plugs into almost anything. For gym use specifically, I'd recommend neither: you want a wireless, sweat-resistant pair, and that's a different category of product. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since both are inexpensive enough that value will come down to which problem you're solving.
FAQ
You can physically wear it, but I wouldn't recommend it. It's a wired 3.5 mm headset with leatherette cushions and no water-resistance rating, so it isn't built for sweat. For gym use, look for wireless, sweat-resistant headphones instead.
It has a noise-canceling microphone, not active noise cancellation for what you hear. The mic boom rotates 180° and can be positioned for better voice capture, but the headset itself only offers basic sound isolation.
They're comfortable in different ways. The Peltor Optime 98 uses a stainless steel headband and tilting earcups to keep pressure low over long shifts, while the H111 is much lighter at 128 g with an adjustable headband and soft leatherette cushions.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ZLiT Earpads vs XBERSTAR Ear Pads Hearing, Piluyaa Clip-on Earbuds vs WUYUEGE Open Ear Earbuds, HyperX Cloud Stinger 2 vs XHXJCYS Black Single Earset, Monster Open Free AC100 vs coioc Open-Ear Headphones