CONTACTS
Implementing Organization: Environmental Division
Implementation Lead: Ron Steiner
Development Team:
Ron Steiner, NEPA/Natural Resource Specialist
Bracken Davis, Region 4 GIS Manager
Eric Hansen, Region 4 Environmental Manager
Naomi Kisen, Environmental Program Manager
Matt Howard, Environmental Manager
Article Written By: Mindi Cowley, Ron Steiner and Bracken Davis
Innovation Council Liaison: Mindi Cowley
Innovation Team Coordinator: Quinten Klingonsmith
STATUS
Implementation Date: May 31, 2023
Adoption Status: Fully Implemented
Adoptability Note: This 3D noise mode can be used to more precisely determine the impact of open pit mining on nearby species.
APPLIES TO
Topic: Data Collection, Analysis and Visualization
Organization(s): Central Construction, Central Maintenance/Facilities Management, Data Technology & Analytics, Environmental Division, Region 1, Region 2, Region 3, Region 4
Job Role(s): Business Analyst, Construction Engineer, Program Director
Tags: capital productivity, labor productivity, materials, political factors, economic benefits, inspection, governance > auditing, policy making, procedures, compliance, law, ( legal ), information technology >> software, networks, ( data visualization ), geographic information systems ( GIS ), construction, facilities, testing > samples, sampling, environmental quality > pollution > air, noise
PROBLEM
UDOT needed a quarry in the Bluff area. A location was identified by Materials Management, but a NEPA environmental document was needed to clear the pit for use. Two endangered bird species were identified within ½ mile of the quarry site. This prohibited its use during the birds’ nesting season which coincided with the time when the pit needed to be running. The environmental assessment identified that sound from the quarry operation was the largest potential impact for both species. For UDOT to open and operate this quarry for their intended purpose, clearance to run year-round was needed.
Transportation-related construction and maintenance activities along with mining of raw materials from quarries, tend to produce sound at a magnitude that may have negative effects on wildlife, including disruption of communication, habitat abandonment, altered behavior, disruption of breeding patterns, and habitat fragmentation. These issues can impact threatened and endangered species and other species of concern.
To avoid these potential issues, activities that may impact species are often required to occur outside of their breeding season. Such timing restrictions often negatively impact the summer construction season by increasing costs and/or timelines for project completion.
In the past, UDOT has used 2D noise models to complete Noise Impact Assessments to evaluate the propagation of these noises over distances. These models do not consider the influence of topography, atmospheric pressures, and other relevant factors that can affect noise propagation.
CHANGE
UDOT Region Four found an existing 3D Quarry Noise Model funded by USDOT in the state of Oregon that models quarry noise. They implemented the Quarry Noise Model (QNM) which uses DOT’s Advanced Acoustic Model for analyzing aircraft sound. A gravel pit in Southern Utah was evaluated by comparing QNM outputs with natural background noise.
Construction crews began working the quarry outside the timing restrictions for the nesting period while outside consultants collected noise measurements in the sensitive species’ habitats.
RESULT
After running the QNM, the model showed the noise levels decreased as they propagated out from the quarry to the river bottom where the endangered species’ habitat is located.
The wildlife analysis was then reevaluated based on the results of the noise study. The manager responded that “based on the topographical barriers between the noise-generating work and suitable habitat, project noise will not result in impacts.” The timing restriction was removed from the project’s State Environmental Study.
ArcGIS Screenshot
Example Noise Output within the ArcMap environment
Bluff Pit Elevation Analysis
Comparison of Two Blast Noise Events Propagated over Flat (left) and Natural (right) Terrain
IMPACT
EFFICIENCIES*
Cost Savings: $200,000 over 20 years (May 31, 2023 - May 31, 2043)
This amount could go up substantially if the model results in other quarries being approved or opened year-round
*Benefits are estimated net of initial and ongoing expenses. Savings are averaged over the expected benefit life of the innovation. See details.