Zebra mussels (Dreissena polymorpha), a two-shelled mollusk native to eastern Europe, cause significant ecological and economic damage to invaded ecosystems. While prevention is ideal, we need to develop effective control options for established populations to mitigate impacts and limit further spread. We know we can kill the zebra mussels... the question is, can we do it safely? To that end, the Phelps Lab has partnered with the US Geological Survey to evaluate and refine recommendations for the use of copper-based pesticides (i.e., EarthTec QZ) for large scale population suppression.
More information on zebra mussels can be found here.
Copper-based pesticides can be highly effective tools for lake management and have been used in varying formulations for over a century to control algae, plants, and invertebrates. However, copper can have unintended consequences for non-target organisms, many of which are poorly understood. To better understand the current state of the science, we are conducting a systematic review that seeks to establish, through the available literature, how different copper-based lake management pesticides impact non-target aquatic organisms. To date, our review has identified 7,300+ articles for initial screening! Articles are currently being read for relevance against pre-determined inclusion and exclusion criteria with assistance from researchers and citizen scientists.
The Phelps Lab has partnered with the USGS to develop zebra mussel suppression strategies that will reduce ecological and economic impacts to infested waterbodies and reduce the risk of spread to uninfested waterbodies. This project built on several years of promising research, culminating with the largest scale low-dose/long-duration EarthTec QZ treatment ever attempted for zebra mussels. The results suggest treatments effectively reduced zebra mussel veliger density, juvenile zebra mussel recruitment, and live adult zebra mussel density. Non-target impacts varied; relative zooplankton mean density was reduced immediately after treatment and showed some recovery at 2 weeks, chlorophyll-a concentration increased after treatment, and survival and copper residue in fathead minnow suggest sensitivity in that species, but other fish species and native mussels were unaffected. The project team continues to monitor the treated and untreated areas to evaluate long-term trends of this approach. For more information, visit: https://www.maisrc.umn.edu/copper-control.
As our knowledge about zebra mussel control practices continues to expand, lake managers are beginning to implement different strategies. We reviewed data from 33 past dreissenid mussel control projects in 23 lakes across North America and identified patterns and knowledge gaps to help inform adaptive management strategies. Results are in preparation and will be available to share soon!
Copper is an essential micronutrient for plants and animals but at high concentrations is toxic to many aquatic organisms... Good for targeting invasive speices, bad for non-target native species. These tradeoffs must be carefully evaluated to ensure potential adverse non-target impacts do not outweigh the potential benefits of a management decision. One way to predict copper impacts to gilled aquatic organisms, such as zebra mussels, in different water chemistries is by using the Biotic Ligand Model (BLM). While the BLM has been used to set water quality standards, to the best of our knowledge, it has not been used to inform aquatic management practices. In this project, we demonstrate the potential application of the BLM to predict species-specific responses to different copper concentrations with the goal of learning how copper affects zebra mussel veligers and non-target organisms. By calculating a precise concentration of copper necessary to meet a management goal given site-specific water chemistry, we hope to predict, mitigate, and minimize unintended impacts and optimize management costs.
While studies on zebra mussel veliger sensitivity to copper pesticides have been conducted, there is limited information on the accompanying water chemistry for those experiments. Without that information, it is challenging to accurately predict the minimum amount of copper to use to control veliger numbers. To improve our understanding of veliger sensitivity to copper, we conducted a toxicity trial in a mobile lab with six concentrations plus a control (no copper added) in lake water. Simultaneously, we also measured water chemistry metrics of the lake water, sufficient to use the BLM for future predictive work for veliger control. Results are currently being analyzed, and will be available soon!