Rebellion in America
Essential Question(s): What are some examples of rebellion in American history? What were the motivations behind these instances and what were the results? What are the similarities or differences between historical examples and modern ones? What about these instances of rebellion have stood the test of time and remained relevant in our society?
Introduction
Throughout America's history, there have been countless cases where a group of people have caused unrest in order to send a message. Often times, these cases of unrest can insight violence. In this unit, we will be observing three instances where people rose to rebel: two that take place further back in history, as well as one modern example. In each of these cases, we will learning about the factors that contributed to the rebellion as well as the immediate and long term effects. In order to think critically about what we are learning, we will be analyzing various sources to help us gather information to better understand the factors that contributed to each of these events. This will encourage us to think like historians and use sources to deepen our knowledge and help us build connections. At the end of the unit, we will be comparing and contrasting the motivations, circumstances, and impacts of the Stono Rebellion, the Tulsa Riots, and the Ferguson Unrest to try and make connections between events in history and the present.
Historical Context
Although the Stono Rebellion took place before the official founding of America, it still is very much a part of American history. In 1739, a group of 20 slaves planned their escape and robbed a convenience store - killing the two storekeepers in the process - on Stono's bridge in South Carolina. As this group of escaped slaves continued south, more continued to join them. When slave owners caught up to the group of nearly 100 escaped slaves, violence was incited. The result was that over 20 white and nearly 40 Black South Carolinians were killed. Because of this, lawmakers in the Colonies at the time began creating and enforcing harsher slave rules. As part of this, slaves were no longer permitted to have their own money or learn how to read. Although Stono's Rebellion is only one of over 200 documented slave revolts in the history of the U.S. Colonies and the south, it is the largest slave revolt in the Colonies prior to the American Revolution.
The Tulsa race riot, happening almost 200 years later, had some different motivations behind it. In 1921, white residents in Tulsa, Oklahoma attacked Black owned businesses as well as the workers in the Greenwood district. The Greenwood District was significant in the fact that it was the wealthiest Black community in the United States at the time, sometimes being called "Black Wall Street." These attacks were supposedly started because it was rumored that one of the Black workers in one of the businesses in Greenwood assaulted a white elevator attendant. As news of the event spread, mob violence ensued and Black Wall Street was attacked. Black owned businesses in Tulsa were bombed from the land and by private airplane; workers inside the buildings were beaten and shot. The result was that over the course of that Memorial Day weekend, an estimated 100-300 Black residents of the area were killed and thousands more were injured.
The Ferguson unrest is different from our other two examples of rebellion in America's history in the way that it is still recent to memory, happening in 2014. This event was incited by the death of Michael Brown, a Black teenager who was shot by a Ferguson police officer. When this case went to court, the Officer responsible for Michael Brown's death was not indicted. Many people interpreted this ruling as an injustice to Black people and claimed that the event was evidence of systematic racism in America. Those who shared these views took to the streets of Ferguson to express their feelings of injustice, and violence and vandalism ensued along with forms of peaceful protest. To try and combat the riots, Ferguson police officers began enforcing curfews on citizens and riot squads began monitoring the streets. This caused even more unrest in Ferguson, and a divided line between citizens and police was formed. Police officers fired tear gas at rioters and rioters charged at police barricades to express their feelings of injustice. Although this historic event did not involve any deaths other than that of Michael Brown, over 300 citizens were arrested. This event as largely seen as creating a domino effect that contributed to the feelings of distrust towards the police amongst American citizens.
Historical Thinking Skills
Close Reading: throughout this unit, students will be evaluating sources that cover the instances of rebellion in this unit. Part of this source evaluation will involve students gathering evidence from the text that support the author's point of view, including key words, quotes, etc.
Contextualization: in addition to close reading of sources, students will also be participating in contextualization. Once students have found the author's point of view as well as supported evidence from the source, they will be asked questions that will encourage them to analyze why the author may have that point of view.
Stono Rebellion: September, 1739
Watch this video that summarizes the events of the Stono Rebellion and interviews key historians on the topic. After watching the video, answer the questions below and be prepared to share your responses with a partner (and possibly the class).
- What was one thing that was covered in the video that was surprising to you? What about it was surprising?
- Based off of the video, what were the causes or motivations behind the Stono Rebellion?
- Do you think there was any bias in the way these events were described in the video? If so, where did you notice the bias?
- Is there anything in particular you would like to know more about the Stono Rebellion to help develop your opinion?
Although this illustration does not depict the Stono Rebellion, it does show shed some light on how slave revolts were portrayed at the time. Observe all parts of the illustration and use the questions below to support your observations. Be prepared to share your responses with a partner (and possibly the class).
- What was the first thing that stood out to you about the illustration?
- Think about how these people are depicted. Is there a clear "instigator" that is being portrayed? Is there a clear "victim"?
- Look at the time stamp of this illustration. Who do you think would have been observing this material? Is there a clear audience?
Read the hyperlinked article that covers two different viewpoints on the Stono Rebellion. While you are reading, practice marking the text by: circling main ideas, underlining key words, and putting a question mark next to words or ideas you are unfamiliar with. Use the following questions to guide your reading:
- What is the main point(s) of each of the perspectives given in this article?
- Where is there bias present in each of the authors' points of view?
- How are the escaped slaves and the slave owners depicted in each of the accounts? What are the similarities or differences?
- What do the differences in these accounts say about how the Stono Rebellion was perceived at the time? What impact does it have on the decedents of the escaped slaves (like the individual in the second account)?
Tulsa Riots: May/June, 1921
This photo was taken during the time of the Tulsa Riots. Observe all aspects of the photograph and record your thoughts in your notebook. Use the following guiding questions to support your observations.
- What was the first thing that stood out to you about this photograph? Why do you think you were drawn towards this part?
- Where do you think these people are going? Who do you think the passengers in the car are?
- What relationship can you make between this photograph and what we know about the Tulsa Riots? What context could you build based off of what you see?
This photo was taken during the time of the Tulsa Riots. Observe all aspects of the photograph and record your thoughts in your notebook. Use the following guiding questions to support your observations.
- Where do you think these people are?
- How would you describe the atmosphere at the time this photo was taken?
- Are there any people in particular that stand out to you? How do you think they are significant?
- What connection could these people have to the Tulsa Riots? What context can you build off of what you see?
Read the newspaper article to the right of the page titled "85 Dead from Tulsa Race Riot." While you are reading, look for potential bias that may be present. Mark the text for important information by: circling main ideas, underlining key words, and putting a question mark next to words or ideas you are unfamiliar with. Use the following questions to guide your reading:
- Who do you think the target audience of this article is? Do you think this impacts any bias present in the article?
- Did you notice a specific cause mentioned for the inciting of the riots? What was it?
- What are the main events of the riots that the author is trying to draw attention to?
- Based on what we know about the Tulsa Riots, is there any information not being mentioned or drawn enough attention to? Do you think this is purposeful?
Ferguson Unrest: August, 2014
This TED Talk of Damon Davis expresses his views on systematic racism in America and his experiences in Ferguson. Watch this video and pay close attention to what Davis says about the sense of community he felt in Ferguson during the time of Unrest. Then, answer the following questions in your notebook. Be prepared to share your responses with a partner (and possibly the class).
- How would you describe the community in Ferguson amongst people involved in the Unrest based on Davis' words? What do you think connected the people involved in the Unrest?
- What does Davis say about fear and courage? What about his thoughts may connect to other instances of rebellion discussed in this unit? (*Hint: Remember the causes of the Stono Rebellion.)
- Do you think everyone in Ferguson who was aware of the Unrest would agree with Davis' thoughts on the presence of systematic racism in America? What do you think someone who disagrees with him might say?
This photograph was taken in St. Louis after the Ferguson Unrest. Imagine yourself in the position of the person who wrote this, then answer the following questions in your notebook. Be prepared to share your responses with a partner (and possibly the class).
- What message is this person trying to convey?
- Who do you think the target audience of this message is?
- What do you think "Ferguson is Everywhere" has to do in relation to systematic racism?
This video was recorded in Ferguson in 2018, four years after the Ferguson Unrest. It goes into detail about what the social climate in Ferguson is today and incorporates the voices of the people still impacted by the Unrest. Watch the video and answer the following questions in your notebook. Be prepared to share your responses with a partner (and possibly the class).
- How would you describe the emotions of people interviewed in this video? Why do you think they feel that way?
- Pay attention to the excerpt from the man who currently lives in the apartment complex where Michael Brown was killed. How do you think he is impacted by Michael Brown's death?
- What connections can you make between the case in Ferguson and other instances of rebellion we have covered in this unit?
- What do you think this video has to do with systematic racism in the present? Do you think anything has changed since the Ferguson Unrest in regards to systematic racism (whether in Ferguson or across the U.S.)? If so, what?