Christmas Movie Reviews 2024
By: Ev Nicholes-Fox and Arlo Schilling
This wouldn’t be a proper movie review without mentioning the infamous Hallmark movies and their knockoffs (Some spoilers may be told in these reviews).
Christmas Movie Reviews 2024
By: Ev Nicholes-Fox and Arlo Schilling
This wouldn’t be a proper movie review without mentioning the infamous Hallmark movies and their knockoffs (Some spoilers may be told in these reviews).
Hot Frosty, a 2024 movie, was the first I watched in what would be known as the ”Great Hallmark Binge” among my family. The movie follows Kathy, struggling with her life after her husband’s death. Her friends show concern for her, and in an attempt to improve her life, her neighbor Mel gives her a red scarf, suggesting she go out and find someone new. Kathy however walks through the snowman-building competition and finds a jacked snowman without a scarf. Feeling sad for him, she wraps the red scarf around him and leaves. Unbeknownst to her, the scarf was magical and brought the jacked snowman to life. Surprised to be alive and not made of snow anymore, he runs around the small town, committing a couple of crimes along the way. Kathy finds him the next day and is determined to help him, though she isn’t convinced he is a snowman. The rest of the movie follows these two as they get to know each other and help out the small town, along with Kathy’s life. Against cops, confusion, and the threat of high temperatures, the two end up falling in love and having a Christmas miracle.
It had some funny moments and was full of recognizable actors like Lacey Chabert and Craig Robinson. It also had some tender moments, especially involving themes of moving on from the past and learning to love again. However, the fact that she fell in love with a once snowman in a span of only 2 weeks does cause me some pause, and, sometimes, what the movie portrayed as “cute and quirky” came across as cringy and annoying instead. It had some good scenes, full of humor, but overall was pretty bad. But I think that was the point as at times it seemed like the movie wanted to be bad—wanted you to get secondhand embarrassment or make fun of it or have a laugh at the ridiculousness of it. The entire plot seemed unserious and some of the characters really drove that point home. If this movie was trying to be bad, I would give it a 7/10: a job well done, nothing topped it in terms of a good bad movie. If it wasn’t, 4/10 as sometimes it was cute, but really it was cringy and the snowman romance dynamic does nothing more than hurt my brain.
Falling for Christmas, a 2022 film, was the second film I watched. I remember seeing clips of this show back when it first grew traction on TikTok due to its ridiculous beginning of events. The movie starts off with Sierra Belmont, heiress to a very successful ski resort business, and her big choice on whether or not to run a part of her father’s business. To cheer her up, and get internet clout, her influencer boyfriend Tad takes her to go skiing on the highest mountain. On top of the highest peak, he proposes to her, despite the ring being too big, and she accepts. All seems well and happy until a winter snowstorm hits (in a span of about 30 seconds) and pushes the happy couple apart. As the strong wind blows, Sierra attached to her skis slides off the mountain cliff and hits her head on a tree, knocking her unconscious. Tad is blown the other way, away from his fiancee. Jake Russell, a small-town ski resort owner, finds Sierra and takes her to the local clinic where she wakes up with amnesia. Now, with no memory, Sierra tries to remember who she is while in the care of Jake and his family, trying to help their struggling resort in the process and finding love.
This movie had the best start. Falling off a 20,000-foot mountain due to wind is just as funny and ridiculous as it sounds and really gets your attention. The movie has a couple more of these moments, bringing genuine laughter. The movie was also filmed in the beautiful Park City, UT, which provides wonderful scenery and being from Utah myself, some memories. Aside from the beginning and funny moments, it goes like your typical Hallmark movie however the sweetest moments come from Sierra and Jack’s daughter rather than Jack himself. In fact, Jack wasn’t a really interesting character and every time he came on, I didn’t really care. Even Tad, the chronically online Instagram buff, had more of an interesting storyline than Jack (he also looked like a younger version of her dad which was weird and I can’t get out of my head). This caused the blooming romance to be boring and felt like every other Christmas movie (but it is Hallmark so I’m not really surprised). I would rate this movie a 7/10, as it’s the only one on this list I would watch again. Almost all the characters were enjoyable to watch and it has some side plots that added to the overall plot. Family is what you make it and the family in this film shows this theme. A decent Christmas movie, a good family movie, and a very bad and boring romance movie.
Now, we’re getting to the really bad movies on this list. A Castle for Christmas, made in 2021, follows the story of Sophie, a recently divorced author whose newest book faced huge backlash as a fan-favorite character is killed off. In search of a means to escape the backlash, Sophie remembers her father’s story of a Scotland castle and decides to go and buy it. Arriving in Scotland she is recognized, but unlike her US fans, the Scots were happy with her new book and welcomed her in warmly. All except the cold Duke of Dunbar, Myles, who also happens to own the castle. Right off the bat, the two are at odds, finding the perfect information to jab each other with, resulting in a shared experience bonding the two. As the movie progresses, the two get closer as well as Christmas and the deadline for Sophie’s new pages to be written. As Sophie battles writer's block and a fear of new love, Myles has to get over his ego and pride, to finally find the warmth in his heart.
This movie wasn’t as bad as it was boring. The plot was slow-moving and felt like it never ended. The main couple was cute but unrelatable and at times they did things that made no sense just to further the plot and unneeded suspense. At one point, the characters have an interaction that goes back and forth from kissing to fighting to kissing. The only parts that interested me were the scenery shots of the castle and the friendship Sophie formed with a knitting club. And those were sparse. Sophie’s face is pounded with make-up she doesn’t need, making her look expressionless, like a doll. I would rate this movie a 4/10, because its main romance plot was boring and at times felt unreal (more unreal than a snowman coming to life). I didn’t feel any Christmas spirit and I just wanted the movie to end, and when it did, it left off with a sweet ending which made me wish the whole movie could’ve been about the end instead of the couple switching back and forth on if they liked each other or not.
The Knight Before Christmas, a 2019 film, somehow managed to be worse than A Castle for Christmas. The movie starts in a medieval castle, as two brothers, Sir Cole and Sir Geoffrey, are about to join the knights on a hunt. As the two brothers split up, Sir Cole heads into a forest and finds an old crone who he offers kind assistance to. Because of his kindness, the crone gives him a knightly task, to find what is his true heart’s desire, and sends him into the year 2019. Around this time, a high school science teacher, Brooke, has given up on love after her previous boyfriend cheated on her. After telling a student Knight in Shining Armor doesn’t exist and to just focus on her school career, she heads out to a holiday festival in town when she hits Sir Cole with her car. Startled, she checks on him and thinks he’s delusional when he tells her he’s a knight from medieval England. To try and help him regain memories she thinks he’s lost, she takes him in as he tries to complete his knightly task in time for his brother's knighting on Christmas day. Along the way, they help each other learn what truly the heart desires and that knight in shining armor really does exist.
This movie took the bad, cringyness of Hot Frosty and the boringness of A Castle for Christmas and turned it into the worst movie I watched on this list. The only funny thing about this movie was the fact that Sir Cole’s name was pronounced “Circle” for half the film and how he kept calling every old woman he saw an old crone. As cute as it could’ve been, I just felt like I was watching Hot Frosty all over again but with time travel and knights instead which somehow made it worse. Brooke was an uninteresting main character with bad clothes and no humor. All of the side storylines (if there were any) didn’t go anywhere and were unimportant. The only character who seemed to matter and who was mildly entertaining was Sir Cole. He brought the humor of what a medieval knight in modern times would have, calling servers wenches and threatening to fight people with his sword. I think it’s the end of the film that’s the worst though as Sir Cole is trying too hard to get back to his brother before the knighting ceremony, and when he finally gets back to his brother he decides that Brooke ( a girl he’s known for a record-breaking 5 days in the Hallmark halls of fame) is his heart’s desire and means more to him than his own brother! He goes off and lives in the future with her, despite the entire film being about his knightly task so he can go back to the past. I rate this movie a 2/10 because it felt like I watched Hot Frosty again but this time worse, only one character was funny and interesting at all, and the ending sucked! Romance was not the direction this movie should’ve gone, instead, it should’ve been about brotherly love or the importance of family instead.
Lacey Chabert is back for the final movie I watched: Haul out the Holly, a 2022 film. The movie follows Emily who just broke up with her boyfriend and now has nowhere to stay due to him getting the lease by himself behind her back. Her parents convince her to return home for the holidays but when she arrives, her parents tell her that they’ll be going on a vacation to Florida. Instead of a relaxing vacation to recover from her breakup and eat cookies, she’s now stuck with housesitting and her Christmas-obsessed neighbors. To make matters worse, the new president of the HOA, Jared, has been flagging her with fines and community service due to the lack of Christmas spirit, forcing her into the festivities the neighborhood displays every year. The movie goes on as Emily helps her neighbors prepare for each event while working some Christmas miracles. Slowly she learns to love again in the Christmas spirit along with someone new.
This movie was refreshingly different than the others on this list and was filmed in Utah which gave it the beautiful tall mountains for perfect scenery for the movie. The side characters had heartwarming backgrounds and stories in the movie, making very likable neighbors in the neighborhood. There was humor in the ridiculous plot, similar to Hot Frosty and Falling for Christmas. However, due to the ridiculous plot, many scenes were bad and cringy, especially involving the main love interest, Jared. He was a Christmas enthusiast which was more cringy than cute as having a grown man act like a Christmas-obsessed child got old fast and made him an unlikeable character and love interest. It felt like he was dumbing down Emily as the movie went on which slowly dumbed me down too. While the story paced well, I found myself losing interest as it felt like the same thing over and over again just with different neighbors and events. Jared finds her or forces her into doing an event and now she has to do it while getting to know either him or her neighbors. Interesting in the beginning but it lost value over time. The plot twist surprise was predictable and the ending wasn’t very impactful as I hardly remember it. Overall, I would rate this movie a 3/10, because the only interesting parts were the side stories about the neighbors with Emily’s and Jared’s main romance plot feeling like it took the back seat, especially when Jared is unlikeable and Emily isn’t very interesting. There were some good scenes but I wouldn’t watch this movie again due to the cringyness of a Christmas man-child.
A Christmas Story is a comedy from 1983 by Jean Shepherd that follows a family and a young boy named Ralphie Parker who spends the days leading up to Christmas praying for his dream gift…a Red Ryder BB gun! Along the way, he navigates flat tires, bullies, and a crazy Santa. As my favorite Christmas movie which has become a tradition to watch every year, A Christmas Story is a reliable classic that the whole family is sure to enjoy.
Elf is the story of an elf from the North Pole who finds out he has a human dad living in New York City! Played by Will Ferrel “buddy” the elf embarks on a journey to find his biological father and who he truly is, what he was not expecting was that his father Walter Hobbs would not be so accepting of his elf son. Elf is an inspiring Christmas story of love reunion and hope, great for all ages this 2003 masterpiece will always entertain the masses.
Home Alone is a hilarious and thrilling story of a boy who is left home alone by accident when his family goes on Christmas vacation. Little does young Kevin McCallister know, he will have to defend his home against ruthless intruders attempting to rob his home and ruin his Christmas. One of the most entertaining pictures of 1990, this movie was filmed beautifully and checks all the boxes for a great Christmas watch.