Korean?
To Educators and Environmental Advocates,
I hope this is conveyed well with the Stock-Flow Concept Using the Bathtub Analogy in Systems Thinking.
Inflow: Water coming in from faucet #1,
Stock: Water accumulating in the bathtub,
Outflow: Water exiting faucet #2,
Then, using the following diagram, compare the Inflow and Outflow and explain how the water in the bathtub (Stock) changes under the three conditions. It's a good idea to make it a quiz - it's a simple concept, so it should be easy to get right, but keep that in mind. Ensure your students feel comfortable with the concept so they can confidently apply it to other situations. In particular, it makes it easier to understand the changes in carbon dioxide as it accumulates in the bathtub called Earth, described in the next step.
The figure below was contributed by MIT Professor John Sterman, one of the world's leading experts on System Dynamics. If we break it down into the Stock and Flow of the Bathtub model, we can describe it as follows.
Inflow: CO2 Inflow = CO2 Emissions9.1 billion metric tons C/yr,
Stock: The cumulative amount of carbon dioxide accumulating in the bathtub called Earth, 745 billion metric tons C/yr,
Outflow: CO2 Outflow = CO2 Absorption/Sequestration, 5 billion metric tons C/yr, trees/soil/ocean
What we're interested in here is the amount of Inflow and the amount of Outflow.
Many countries/businesses/schools/homes/individuals will have made efforts to reduce their carbon dioxide emissions. Let's say that as a result, emissions went from 9.1 billion tons to 8 billion tons. Obviously, a lot of people would have been inconvenienced, either by not using cheap and convenient fossil energy or by using alternative energy sources that they're not familiar with, but what if the outflow was still 5 billion tons?
Inflow: 8 billion tons
Outflow: 5 billion tons
Result: Additional cumulative volume of 3 billion tons
Therefore, there is more carbon dioxide in the bathtub, or the Earth. More carbon dioxide on the planet means more greenhouse effect, so the climate change we're experiencing will be more severe.
In other words, Despite reducing CO2 emissions from 9.1 to 8 billion tons, climate conditions continue to deteriorate.
Let's go a little further.
As climate change becomes more and more serious, even people who weren't previously interested in climate change and the environment will get involved in efforts to combat climate change. They're going to tighten their belts a little bit more, and they're going to try to reduce their carbon footprint. There will be stronger carbon taxes and more subsidies for electric cars, and electricity and oil that used to be cheap will become prohibitively expensive. It's going to be a bone-crushing effort.
Let's say the result is a revolutionary reduction in carbon dioxide emissions (Inflow) to 7 billion tons, but what if the Outflow is still 5 billion tons?
Inflow: 7 billion tons
Outflow: 5 billion tons
Result: Additional cumulative volume of 2 billion tons
Therefore, there is more carbon dioxide in the bathtub, or the Earth. More carbon dioxide on the planet means more greenhouse effect, and as a result, the climate change we're experiencing will be more severe again.
Consequently, environmental activists may experience burnout or disillusionment first.
Those who have been actively involved in climate change efforts will be the first to feel hopeless.
You might even feel like you're the only one losing out by going the extra mile. This scenario exemplifies the Tragedy of the Commons in climate action because while I was trying to reduce my carbon footprint, those who weren't making those efforts were living comfortably. We must ask ourselves what attitude we would choose in this situation. This thought experiment is essential for the generations that will face more serious climate and environmental challenges in the future.
We recommend that you try the following online simulator.(Open the simulator alone)
How to use the simulation
Set the change rate using the sliders for Inflow and Outflow.
Press the 'Play' button to start the simulation.
Press the 'Pause' button at any time to temporarily stop the simulation.
Adjust the sliders for Inflow and Outflow again to set new change rates.
Repeat steps 2-4.
Press the 'Reset' button if you want to start over from the beginning.
I would like to share the following takeaways.
We must focus on what happens to Outflow (carbon dioxide removal/capture) as we work to reduce Inflow.
We need to discuss and be interested in ways to make Outflow greater.
We need to understand that until Inflow is less than Outflow, Stock will continue to grow, which means that even if we reduce carbon dioxide emissions, carbon dioxide stocks will continue to grow.
Maintaining solidarity is crucial in our continued efforts to reduce CO2 emissions, even when progress seems slow or discouraging.
However, if recent data indicates anything, things do not look good.
This is an excerpt from the Global Carbon Budget 2023 report by the Global Carbon Project (GCP), an international research organization, released on December 5, 2023, at the 28th Conference of the Parties (COP28) (View original article )
Year 2013~2022 average inflow: 10.9 ± 0.8 Gt C/yr
Year 2013~2022 average outflow: 6.1 ± 0.9 Gt C/yr
Stock as of 2022: 886 Gt C
I don't think sharing this specific data with students is necessary, but rather to make sure they understand that reducing inflow(carbon dioxide emissions) can lead to increased stocks.
#googledocs