Black Canyon of the Gunnison ClimbinG
Comic Relief Buttress (North Rim)
Dates: see main page for all days I've climbed in the Black CanyonPartners: see main page for all people I have climbed with in the Black CanyonTrip Report #s: see main page for all trip report numbers corresponding to reports for the Black Canyon
4 Trip Reports
COMIC RELIEF BUTTRESS (NORTH RIM):
Escape Artist + Lightning Bolt Crack (5.10-/11c, 8-9p)
Comic Relief (5.10, 8-10p)
Cloaked Interpretation (5.11-, 6-10p)
Modern Day Migs (5.10+, 6-10p)
This page is trip reports for Comic Relief Buttress in the Black Canyon. Routes ordered left to right along the buttress. Go to Black Canyon main page to access trip reports on other formations in the Black Canyon.
Table of Contents for this page
Trip reports
Escape Artist + Lightning Bolt Crack (5.10-/5.11c, 7-9p, ~1000-1500')
COMIC RELIEF BUTTRESS (NORTH RIM: SOB GULLY AREA)- Date: May 25, 2020 (Mon) Partner: Michael Cantrell
Escape Artist is an old-school 5.9 that has historically been viewed as a standard introductory route to the Black, more sustained than either Maiden Voyage or Leisure Climb, a couple of other popular 5.9's in the Black, and with a few spicy sections of solid 5.9 above gear. The rock is for the most part quite good. The route is known for its wild Vector Traverse pitch, a left-leaning ramp/crack that is one of the most memorable 5.9 pitches in the Black. After that, the route follows a long, left-facing corner system on the left edge of the buttress, and then joins Comic Relief for its final pitches to the top of Comic Relief Buttress. The splitter Lightning Bolt Crack variation on Pitch 5 is one of the best pitches on Comic Relief Buttress.
Michael and I climbed Last Payment as the first of three climbs during a trip to the Black in May 2020, where we did two climbs on the South Rim (Blackjack and Last Payment) before driving 1.5 hours to the North Rim, where we did one more climb (Escape Artist). This was my first time checking out the South Rim, and Michael's first trip to the Black. At the thinnest points on the rim, the South Rim and North Rim are a mere 1,100 feet apart, but it took 1.5 hours to drive around the Black Canyon to get from one rim to the other!
Pitch-by-Pitch Photos
Approach:
Descend the SOB gully almost to the river, to a white, polished slabby area under the third prominent buttress on your left. Scramble up to a large vegetated area below the wall; from here, scramble 4th and easy 5th class up and right to a small ledge below the two parallel cracks that lead to the Vector Traverse.Pitch 2:
5.9+. Vector Traverse pitch! Follow the wild ramp/crack system up and left. Lots of good gear placements throughout give confidence for the committing movement. Belay on a ledge at the end of the traverse.Pitch 3:
5.10-. Climb the steep dihedral. Belay at a stance on the left near an old pin. This pitch is sustained, long, and the gear can be thoughtful at times. The crux is near the top of the pitch.Pitch 5:
LIGHTNING BOLT CRACK. 5.9+ or 11c. For the 5.9+ version, climb the obvious corner, eventually moving right to belay on lower-angled terrain above. For an awesome 11c variation, climb the beautiful Lightning Bolt Crack on the overhanging wall right of the corner. Despite referring to this as a variation, this was actually the line of the first ascent by Ed Webster and Chester Drieman in 1982.Exit:
ESCAPE PITCHES. There are two options from the top of Comic Relief Buttress: rappel down and scramble out the exit gully, or rappel over to the continuing ridge and climb the "Escape Pitches" up to the rim. I had already climbed the Escape Pitches twice, and Michael and I had a goal of getting back to Boulder before it was dark, so we opted for the exit gully. This was quick and surprisingly pleasant.Top out:
Pop out on the canyon rim at the campground. Too bad the campground was closed due to Covid-19, since we had to walk an extra few hundred feet to get to the cool drinks in our car.Comic Relief (5.10, 8-10p, ~950-1500')
COMIC RELIEF BUTTRESS (NORTH RIM: SOB GULLY AREA)- Date: July 4, 2018 (Wed) Partner: Tony Bubb
- Date: May 20, 2022 (Fri) Partner: Nate Arganbright
Comic Relief is an excellent introduction to 5.10 climbing in the Black, with clean rock, good pro, easy routefinding, and a relatively short day. The climb stays in the shade until early afternoon, so it's a good choice for hot weather. This is one of the more popular routes in the Black.
July 2018: This was the first route I ever climbed in the Black. July isn't the ideal time to be climbing in the Black, but I was passing through Colorado and just wanted to check this area out. Comic Relief is a good choice because it is one of the few routes on the North Rim with morning shade. Tony and I started early, and the temperatures during the climb were surprisingly tolerable in the shade, comfortable even. We climbed the Escape pitches all the way to the rim (avoiding the hot hike up a gully to the rim); one of the perks of climbs in The Black is that many of them top out right on the rim, mere minutes from the campground. In fact, the Escape pitches topped out 100 feet from our campsite!
May 2022: I climbed this route a second time in May 2022. It was just as good a route as I remembered it to be. Nate led the excellent Black Corner (5.10) variation for Pitch 4. On this trip we had planned to climb a few more days, but we were shut down by a snowstorm that began just as we were topping out on the canyon rim from this climb. We made a sad 7-hour retreat back to Estes Park. But after a few productive days in Estes Park, we headed back to the Black for four more days of climbing (including The Cruise, Russian Arête, A Midsummer Night's Dream, and Lauren's Arête).
Pitch-by-Pitch Photos
I've included side-by-side trip reports for both times I have climbed Comic Relief. Color coded: July 2018 May 2022
Approach:
Descend the SOB gully almost to the river, to a white, polished slabby area under the third prominent buttress on your left. Scramble up to a large vegetated area below the wall; from here, scramble 4th and easy 5th class up and right to a small ledge below the obvious left-facing corner with a finger crack (the "Vector Traverse" on Escape Artist goes up and left from here).Pitch 1:
5.9. Begin in a nice 5.9- corner which leads to the base of the arching crack. Belay at the base of the arching crack, or keep going to link Pitches 1 + 2.Pitch 2:
5.10 (crux). Climb the arching crack (fingers/layback crux) and continue up sustained 5.9 crack to a belay ledge.Pitch 3:
5.7. Climb the left facing corner, traverse right at its top, continue up easy ground/slab to another short corner, and climb it to a good belay stance below a steep black corner.Pitch 4:
5.9 or 5.10. Traverse left to a flared corner (5.9) with good hands which leads to a nice ledge. Variation (which I did in May 2022): Climb the "Black Corner" above (5.10, excellent climbing), then hand traverse straight left (5.6) to the belay ledge.Pitch 5:
5.9+. Climb up easy ground and pull the bulge up and right. Then move right to the base of the tall left facing corner and climb the corner (5.9+) to the large ledge below Lightning Bolt Crack.Pitch 6:
5.9+. Climb the grungy but well-protected corner (climbs better than it looks) to a short pegmatite section, and a belay ledge on the right. Variation: Climb the striking Lightening Bolt Crack (5.11) on the overhanging right wall, sharp, strenuous, but well protected.Pitches 7&8:
5.7. (300' or more): Climb the lower angle, but at times runout, wall above to the top of the summit ridge.Pitches 9&10:
ESCAPE PITCHES (5.easy to 5.8) or "Walk off" (4th). On my 2018 ascent of Comic Relief, we climbed the "Escape Pitches" up to the rim. This entails 2-3 pitches of easy 5th (up to 5.8). The alternative to the Escape Pitches (which we did on the 2022 ascent) is to scramble up a gully to the rim. Either requires a short rap to get off the top of Comic Relief Buttress—use the left rap anchor for the gully scramble and the right rap anchor for the Escape Pitches.Other photos:
Just some other random photos....not directly related to the climb.Cloaked Interpretation (5.11-, 6-10p, ~950-1500')
COMIC RELIEF BUTTRESS (NORTH RIM: SOB GULLY AREA)- Date: May 16, 2020 (Sat) Partner: Nate Arganbright
Cloaked Interpretation links the first four pitches of Cloak & Dagger with the stellar upper pitch of Modern Day Migs, via a thin 5.11- crack on the arête between the two climbs. With the beautiful 5.10+ stemming dihedral-to-hand crack of Cloak & Dagger, the exciting 5.11- pitch on the arête, and the stellar rope-stretching finish of Modern Day Migs, this may be one of the best 5.11a routes in the Black. In particular, Pitches 3 and 6 were some of the best pitches of climbing I have done in the Black.
Nate and I climbed Cloaked Interpretation on the second of three climbs during an enjoyable trip to the Black in May 2020. The other two climbs we did on this trip were The Odyssey and Buzz Cut. The Black had a rather unique vibe to it on this trip, since the National Park had just re-opened to day use following a lengthy closure due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Pitch-by-Pitch Photos
Approach:
Descend SOB Gully as per Comic Relief. The route starts just right of the start of Comic Relief on a ledge at the base of the wall. Traversing around the corner may involve a bit of low- to mid-5th or a short rappel, depending on how high you go as you scramble towards the start of the route.Pitch 4:
CLOAK & DAGGER. 5.10. Climb through the arching roof and continue up a left-facing corner, eventually trending left into a lower angle weakness to a terrace above. This is the belay spot for Cloak and Dagger. However, to continue via Cloaked Interpretation, you need to move the belay rightwards along the terrance towards the arête, stopping at an obvious ledge with blocks on it.Pitch 5:
CLOAKED INTERPRETATION. 5.11-. Make a few committing moves up steep jugs and thin crack, gaining the dihedral on the arête. This eventually leads to a section of difficult climbing (protected by RPs and microcams) to gain the belay ledge beneath Pitch 6 of Modern Day Migs.Pitch 6:
MODERN DAY MIGS. 5.11-. Climb a crack just right of the bombay, eventually trending back left into a wonderful hand crack. This ends on a ledge (optional belay). From this ledge, continue up the fractured, brown face, pulling over the top to a belay on a ledge. Without the optional belay, this is a full 60m pitch of great 5.10-5.11- climbing. This is one of the best pitches of climbing have done in the Black.Pitch 7:
MODERN DAY MIGS. ~5.7. Take the arête to the top of Comic Relief Buttress. It is also possible to cut more leftward and get on easier terrain.Pitches 8-10:
ESCAPE PITCHES. 5.easy to 5.8. We climbed the "Escape Pitches" up to the rim. This entails 2-3 pitches of easy 5th (up to 5.8). The alternative to the Escape Pitches is to scramble up a gully to the rim. Either requires a short rap to get off the top of Comic Relief Buttress—use the left rap anchor for the gully scramble and the right rap anchor for the Escape Pitches.Top out:
Pop out on the canyon rim at the campground. Too bad the campground was closed due to Covid-19, since we had to walk an extra few hundred feet to get to the cool drinks in our car.Other photos:
Just some random photos.Modern Day Migs (5.10+, 6-10p, ~950-1500')
COMIC RELIEF BUTTRESS (NORTH RIM: SOB GULLY AREA)- Date: May 17, 2024 (Fri) Partner: Nate Arganrbight
This route starts on Cloak and Dagger and then veers rightward after two pitches, gaining access to the beautifully polished, reddish-brown rock on the upper wall. Nate and I had climbed the first two pitches and last two pitches when we climbed Cloaked Interpretation in May 2020, but the middle three pitches were new to us and worth climbing the route for. The route features a lot of protectable 5.10- climbing, with a 5.10+ move here and there.
Pitch-by-Pitch Photos
Approach:
Descend SOB Gully as per Comic Relief. The route starts just right of the start of Comic Relief on a ledge at the base of the wall. Traversing around the corner low just involves an exposed low-5th move. Traverseing too high may result in a short rappel.Pitch 2:
SHARES WITH CLOAK & DAGGER. 5.9+. Climb the hand-fist crack which eventually enters the peg chimney above. Continue up the chimney and belay on a ledge below an open book dihedral. To get to the start of Pitch 3, move the belay about 20 m to the right, via a 5.5 traverse.Pitch 3:
5.10. Climb a small, right-facing corner/hand crack near some black streaks, eventually moving right to pull through an exposed 5.10 bulge. Continue to a small alcove above, where a steep 5.9 section leads to an easier weakness. Belay below a right-facing corner.Pitch 6:
5.10+. Climb a crack just right of the bombay, eventually trending back left into a wonderful hand crack. This ends on a ledge (optional belay). From this ledge, continue up the fractured, brown face, pulling over the top to a belay on a ledge. Without the optional belay, this is a full 60m pitch of great 5.10 climbing. This is one of the best pitches of climbing have done in the Black.Scramble to rim:
ESCAPE PITCHES (5.easy to 5.8) or "Walk off" (4th). On other ascents of Comic Relief Buttress, I have climbed the "Escape Pitches" up to the rim. This entails 2-3 pitches of easy 5th (up to 5.8). The alternative to the Escape Pitches is to scramble up a gully to the rim. Either requires a short rap to get off the top of Comic Relief Buttress—use the left rap anchor for the gully scramble and the right rap anchor for the Escape Pitches. But Nate had to make a phone call so we decided to scramble out the exit gully. Pop out at the campground (ideally near your campsite!).