Fig.1. Theoretical Framework
Fig.1. Theoretical Framework
On July 23, 2023, the globally worldwide-known singer, Taylor Alison Swift, had a concert in Lumen Field Seattle where her concert created a 2.3 magnitude seismic event. The seismic activity produced at the concert was primarily due to the human activity of her fans, especially to their engagement to the song “Shake it Off” (Che, 2023).
The study attempts to address the following questions:
How do the different floor materials vary in terms of the amount of piezoelectricity created,
What is the relationship present between the restitution of each floor material and the vibration produced from the stomping of the device
Is the electricity produced sufficient to light a single 3mm LED bulb?
How much, on average, can electricity be produced per floor material?
This serves as a tool to help the community understand how simple daily activities, such as walking, could help them generate electricity. This is especially useful during disasters when the wearers of the piezoelectric footwear can use it to charge essential devices like radios, cell phones, and light bulbs. The footwear prototype of this study could also serve as a motivating force for the shoe industry to make innovations and create footwear that can be a clean alternative source of electricity.
The investigation and findings on the application of piezoelectricity to various floor materials will provide the community and future researchers with valuable information and insight on which floor
material would be the most efficient and advantageous in producing the greatest amount of electricity. The government could be motivated as well by this study to seek a long-term solution to the concerns with global warming brought on by the nation's coal-based energy system (Fecht, 2021).
This paper may also function as a tool of understanding on the topic of piezoelectricity as a green alternative source of energy for them to innovate the current approaches being used in the electricity sector. A thorough investigation into the possibility of piezoelectric footwear in energy production on various coefficients of restitution of floor materials advance the society's knowledge of available alternative electricity sources, particularly piezoelectricity, concerning cost, accessibility, and sustainability.
Fig. 2. Procedural Framework
The researchers used an Experimental Research Design to study the comparative relationship between the coefficient of restitution of the three types of floor materials (wood, soil, and concrete) and the voltage output of the AliPatos footwear tested per material. The set-up required one participant who weighed 50 - 55 kilograms and was also 16-18 years old during the time of experimentation. The singularity of our participants has the purpose of the consistency of results, rather than having multiple participants that will skew the results due to several factors such as age and weight. During the experimentation, the researchers made use of a ruler to ensure that the participant was lifting the shoe only 3-4 inches from the ground for all trials and asked the participant to apply moderate force when stomping the AliPatos.
They used a multimeter, for convenient recording of data, to obtain the values from the stomping of the AliPatos footwear fifty (50) times on each of the floor materials. They filmed the whole implementation of the methodology while ensuring that the numbers presented in the multimeter are also captured using a video camera for easing recording of values. They collected a total of 150 trials, signifying 50 per chosen floor material. Consequently, the data was statistically analyzed in a website named, Jamovi, wherein it will be calculated using the Interquartile Range Method to achieve valid results from Welch’s One-way ANOVA test. This simply let the researchers know if there is a significant difference among the voltages obtained from the three (3) floor materials used as represented by rejection of the null hypothesis when the p-value obtained is less than 0.05.
Once the One-way ANOVA claims that there is a significant difference among the three floor materials, they then proceed to use the Tukey’s HSD to determine which of the floor materials have a
significant difference from each other by pairwise. This is also represented by the rejection of the null hypothesis when the p-value obtained is less than 0.05. The tests will then determine the correlational trend (2.3 - TuKey Test for pairwise mean comparisons | STAT 502, n.d. & One-way ANOVA in SSS Statistics - Step-by-step Procedure Including Testing of Assumptions, n.d.).
They ensured that the prototype came with a flap that would secure the participant's foot and prevent slipping and other accidents. They also considered the possibility of being “energized” or “electrocuted” by the AliPatos since the researchers experienced a minor electric shock while testing the slipper, they took extra precautions and built a prototype with wires located between the slipper as well as a plastic cover on the sole of the slipper to prevent damage and electrification from the water contact.
The data on voltage produced from the three different floor materials reveal distinct trends wherein Wood, which has an average voltage of 0.18764V, shows a broad data range with occasional high peaks while Soil, which has a mean of 0.252V, exhibited diverse voltage values, generally lower than wood or cement and Cement, which has an average of 0.393V, consistently produced a higher voltage value in comparison to the other two floor materials. The study aimed to determine if there were any significant differences in voltages between three types of floor materials: wood, soil, and concrete.
The initial statistical test, One-Way ANOVA, compared the data and found that there were indeed significant differences among these materials with the obtained p-value less than 0.001 (< 0.001), which is lower than the alpha, or level of significance of 0.05 as seen in table 1.
Further investigation using the post-hoc Tukey test pinpointed specific pairs that stood out. Wood versus Concrete and Soil versus Concrete showed clear distinctions with very low p-values, meaning there were significant differences. The data collected clearly demonstrated a relationship between the type of floor material and the generated vibration from stomping feet.The findings support the alternative hypothesis that different floor materials with different coefficients of restitution influence voltage production, with hard materials like concrete which have lower coefficients of restitution being more effective in producing higher voltages.
Despite variations in electricity production among materials, the researchers affirm that all tested floor materials generate sufficient electricity to light a single 3mm LED bulb within the required voltage range of 2.5-3.2V. This aligns with the study's objectives, confirming the impact of floor materials on electricity generation and leading to the rejection of the null hypothesis in favor of the alternative hypothesis. The recorded data ranging from 0.007V to 1.186V, notably falling far below the specified operational range of 2.5V-3.2V for a standard 3mm LED light bulb, was still able to light the LED, is an unexpected observation from the data
The results that were obtained in the study shows that there is a relationship between the type of floor material and the vibration produced from stomping the feet indeed has an effect on the generation of electricity. The results suggest that the more inelastic the material is, the more piezoelectricity will be produced.
The findings of the group compared to previous research in the field indicates that cement was able to help produce more electricity when mechanical pressure is applied; unlike other studies that only focused on the application of piezoelectric sensors on different devices to generate electricity as seen in the study of Naresh et al., (2018); Thakur et al., (2017) & Kaylani et al., (2015). The group findings’ would be beneficial for future scholars who wish to tackle the topic more on piezoelectricity.
The results imply that the type of flooring materials used influences the transmission of voltages. For instance, hard inelastic materials such as concrete transmit vibrations more effectively than less rigid and soft materials like wood and soil, resulting in higher voltage production when feet are stomped on concrete. Despite cement being able to produce more electricity compared to other materials, the researchers can confidently say that regardless of which material produces the most, all the different floor materials were able to produce enough electricity to light a single 3mm LED bulb, with a required voltage range of 2.5-3.2V.
This level of voltage production was enough to light the LED bulb because of the piezoelectric material's responsiveness and sensitivity to vibrations. With this information, there are limitations that the researchers stumbled upon. One of which was addressing the gap of understanding the trend between the correlation of the coefficient of restitution of the material since the statistical analysis determined that there is no significant difference between the soil and wood floor materials due to lack of evidence.
The research can be further improved by incorporating a storage system for the generated electricity. Through external storage, the electricity produced could be utilized away from the footwear itself to charge other devices, especially in case of an electricity shortage. Studying the relationship between the restitution of the floor material and the amount of voltage produced by the AliPatos footwear concluded that the more inelastic the material used, the more piezoelectricity will be produced when mechanical pressure is applied. The information that this study provided is crucial in inventing devices that use the theory, Piezoelectric effect, since it will add efficiency to the creation of sustainable energy and human activity.
Through the gathered data and results, the researchers concluded that floor materials do indeed have an effect on the generation of electricity. Thus, they rejected the null hypothesis which states that there is no significant difference among the voltages obtained from the three different floor materials tested, giving us the alternative hypothesis stating that there is a significant difference present among the voltages obtained.
Samantha
"The sleepy STEM student"
Johannine
"The universal hotspot"
Christine
"The RRL queen"
Chloe
"Pare refill ng kape"
Janelle
"The crochet master"
Annika
"The 'Okedoke' Princess"
Che, C. (2023, July 31). Taylor Swift-Quake: Fans cause seismic activity at Seattle concert. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/28/arts/music/taylor-swift-earthquake-seattle-.html
Fecht, S. (2021, March 17). How exactly does carbon dioxide cause global warming?. State of the Planet. https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2021/02/25/carbon-dioxide-cause-global-warming/
Balaji, A., Nagaraju, G., Naresh, K., & Rambabu, M. (2018, July 7). Practical oriented foot step electric power generation by using piezo material and microcontroller in campus. International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology. 5(7), 1593-1595. www.irjet.net
Thakur, A., Dewangan, M., & Lalwani, P. (2017). PIEZOELECTRIC ROADS. In Piezoelectric Roads. International Journal of Advance Research in Science and Engineering. http://www.ijarse.com/images/fullpdf/1504679409_CIET_00
Kaylani, V. L., Pious, A., Vyas, P.(2015, August) Harvesting Electrical Energy via Vibration Energy and its Applications. Journal of Management Engineering and Information Technology (JMEIT) Volume -2, Issue- 4, ISSN: 2394 - 8124.
2.3 - TuKey Test for pairwise mean comparisons | STAT 502. (n.d.). PennState: Statistics Online Courses. https://online.stat.psu.edu/stat502_fa21/lesson/2/2.3
One-way ANOVA in SSS Statistics - Step-by-step Procedure Including Testing of Assumptions. (n.d.). Laerd Statistics. https://statistics.laerd.com/spss-tutorials/one-way-anova-using-spss-statistics.php