Could Religion Survive the Discovery of ET?
Could the world's religions survive the discovery of extraterrestrial life? Or would their beliefs be so shaken that they would eventually collapse?
A survey discussed on Tuesday at a meeting on the search for alien life at the Royal Society in London suggests religion would survive.
The survey, designed by Ted Peters, a professor of Systematic Theology at the Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary and the Graduate Theological Union in Berkeley, California, asked 1300 people whether they thought the discovery of extraterrestrial intelligence would shake their individual belief, the strength of their religion as a whole or would adversely affect the beliefs of other religions. The survey included both religious and non-religious people, and most respondents were based in the US.
None of the 70 Buddhists questioned thought that the discovery of ET would undercut their belief systems, although 40 per cent thought it could pose problems for other religions.
More Roman Catholics believed ET could pose a problem for their faith. Only 8 per cent of the 120 surveyed thought that their individual beliefs would be shaken, but nearly a quarter – 22 per cent – said it could adversely affect their religion. Even more – 30 per cent – thought it could threaten the beliefs of other religious people.
The patterns were similar for the other Christian sects surveyed, including evangelical and mainline Protestants, but there was not enough data to draw firm conclusions about people of other religions, such as Hindus and Muslims.
Of the 205 people who identified themselves as non-religious (either atheists or those who describe themselves as spiritual but not religious), only 1 per cent thought it would affect their atheist or spiritual outlooks. But 69 per cent thought the discovery of ET could cause a crisis for other world religions. An average of only 34 per cent of religious people shared that belief.
Paul Davies, an astrobiologist at Arizona State University in Tempe was one of the first to suggest that the world's religions would not cope with the discovery of ET. And he still believes such a find would pose theological problems for Christians.
"They believe that Jesus came down to earth to save humankind – not dolphins, Neanderthals or extraterrestrials," he said in response to the survey results. "To make sense of this, either you need multiple incarnations [of Jesus on other planets] or a reason why this planet and this species was singled out for special attention."
Many survey respondents expressed no such qualms. A Roman Catholic said: "I believe that Christ became incarnate (human) in order to redeem humanity and atone for the original sin of Adam and Eve. Could there be a world of extraterrestrials? Maybe. It doesn't change what Christ did."
Another wrote: "From an evangelical Christian perspective, the Word of God was written for us on Earth to reveal the creator... Why should we repudiate the idea that God may have created other civilisations to bring him glory in the same way?"
"There is nothing in Christianity that excludes other intelligent life," asserted an evangelical respondent.
Indeed, Vatican astronomers have said in recent years that there is no conflict between believing in God and in the possibility of "extraterrestrial brothers".
Original article can be found at: NewScientist
A Response From Our Own Rabbi:
Interestingly, the article doesn't mention the effect such a discovery would have on Judaism so, I thought that I would add a few words here to detail that aspect.
Basically, Jews do not believe that the Laws of the Torah, (Old Testement), were intended to be binding on all humans. In fact, there are even passages that explain what is required of a non-Jew for them to be considered as "G-dly people". These passages are referred to as the "Noahide Laws". Not many, only six in fact, but, are believed by Jews to be in indication that non-Jews aren't expected to uphold ALL 613 Laws of the Torah. Let alone the innumerable rules and regulations listed in the Talmud and other Jewish sourses.
Because of this, Jews do not have a uniform position with regards to alien life. If it exists, great, if not, so be it. Our own holy books tell of others that are other humans on this planet who are not required to follow the same teachings so, an alien civilization with a different religion, (or no religion at all), is not considered to be contradictory to the teachings of Judaism.
It's also important to remember that a belief that the Earth is the center of creation or G-ds favorite project does not permiate this faith as it does many others. Because of this fact, an Extra-Terrestrials existence would not be viewed as a threat to it's continued existence. In fact, if it is found that they have a belief in a singlular Creator or G-d, irregardless of rather they followed specific teachings such as the Kosher laws, they would be viewed as Jewish. Even if they have a different name for their faith!
In short, the Jewish faith teaches that the Torah, and all the Laws entailed therein, were NOT given to all life... not even to all mankind. The Torah itself explains that it is intended to be the laws the Isaelites lived by, not the Germans, not the Russians. It's why there is no direct mention of dinosaurs or North America. Not even Europe. As such, it's hard to see the ommission of aliens from another planet as indicative of G-ds opinion that they don't exist. In fact, it would only be normal that they would not be mentioned. As stated above, the Torah was meant as a "users manual" for the Jews. Why would anyone expect a users manual for a hair dryer mention that you shouldn't burn car tires?
Additional commentary (in red), submitted by:
Rabbi Paul Edward Umbarger II
This article is the sole opinion of the author, and does not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Paranormal Investigation and Research Group or any of it’s members. This article, like any and all other articles on this site, is the sole property of the author and is provided to you for academic purposes only! Neither the author nor the members of the Paranormal Investigation and Research Group take any responsibility for YOUR actions. Investigations into the paranormal are inherently dangerous and by utilizing the information herein, in part or in total, for any purpose other than academic information or entertainment, the reader constitutes his or her intentions to be personally liable for and to hold the author and the Paranormal Investigation and Research Group blameless of, any and all injuries they may incur or legal actions that may befall them.
Original article can be found at: