This is my attempt to resolve the issue of who wrote Marcion's gospel. This may sound like an odd question, because surely Marcion did, didn't he? The majority of people who have looked into this agree, in particular the two who are the primary source of our knowledge about Marcion: Tertullian and Epiphanius. Because we have no copies of Marcion's own writings we must rely to a great deal on these two ancient writers. Unfortunately, both were very heavily biased against Marcion, and as a result very few people have attempted to look past this bias to see if it was justified, For various reasons, I am attempting to do exactly that, using my skills in looking for patterns in large amounts of data to attempt to uncover what Marcion's gospel contained, and how it was created.
When I look at what has been written about Marcion’s ‘The Gospel of the Lord,’ I feel how I imagine the writer of the Gospel according to Luke perhaps felt when he wrote his introduction:
“Now many have undertaken to compile an account of the things that have been fulfilled among us, like the accounts passed on to us by those who were eyewitnesses and servants of the word from the beginning. So it seemed good to me as well, because I have followed all things carefully from the beginning, to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus, so that you may know for certain the things you were taught.” (NET Bible)
The writer of Luke clearly thought that what had been previously written was not adequate for his readership, and I feel the same way regarding Marcion. The reports I have read appear to make too many assumptions regarding Marcion’s motives, and about what the exact contents of Marcion’s gospel might have been. So, to paraphrase Luke:
“Now many have undertaken to compile an account of the writing of Marcion’s gospel, like the accounts passed on to us by those who read Marcion’s gospel from the beginning. So it seemed good to me as well, because I have followed all things carefully, to write an orderly account for you, most excellent reader, so that you may know for certain the things Marcion wrote.”
The use of the introduction to Luke above does not just provide a slightly humorous lead-in to the work that follows. Use of an edited version of text from Luke here is apposite to the analysis of Marcion’s gospel, because this gospel is so similar to Luke. Indeed, many people believe that Marcion’s gospel is simply an edited version of Luke. Accordingly, this site contains a detailed verse-by-verse discussion of various features of Marcion’s gospel in comparison with the equivalent text from Luke, and in the Marcion Luke Parallel pages it provides a side-by-side listing of the reconstructed text of Marcion’s gospel and that of Luke, together with notes taken from several sources identifying possible areas of uncertainty.
NOTE: We often use ‘Luke’ to refer to the author of the gospel attributed to a person of that name, but we also often refer to that gospel itself as just ‘Luke.’ While generally the context prevents confusion, where questions of authorship arise it is important to distinguish the two. In the case of Marcion’s gospel we have three ‘entities’ to consider: Marcion himself, the gospel, and the person who created the gospel (who may or may not have been Marcion). In the rest of this site the three will be distinguished as follows:
In the navigation on the left of each page, click the small triangles against a subject title to either show or hide the pages under each heading.
Next: Who Was Marcion?
For verse-by-verse details of the text of Mcg, see either Marcion’s Gospel, Compared Verse by Verse With Luke, or for just a side-by-side listing of the (English) text, see the Marcion Luke Parallel.
If you want to avoid all the details of the analysis, go to the Summary pages, or just go straight to the Conclusions.
To see how the Synoptic Problem may be impacted by Marcion's gospel, go to Marcion's Gospel and the Synoptic Problem.
If you have any comments, questions, suggestions, etc. regarding Marcion or this page please email me at email@example.com