thirdissue

Third Issue (double number)

(Vol. 2 No.2 & Vol.3 No.1, July 2009-July 2010)


of the journal: 

Library and Information Science Critique: Journal of the Sciences of Information Recorded in Documents

Monterrey, Nuevo Leon, Mexico, November 12, 2010 

 [Ir a la versión en español]

 

  [Ir a la versión en español]

Go to main page

Instructions for authors

Manifesto about the rights of authors

 About the journal

 Editorial Board

Proofreaders

Founders

Director and Editor-in-chief

Vice-director and Adjunct editor

 Archive

Contact us

 

Table of Contents

 

Open Access free of charge and direct of the full issue

  | PDF | [Only in Spanish] [110 pp.] [1.59 MB]

Editorial

 

Editorial

Library and Information Science Critique reaches its third volumen launching its double number (volume 2, no. 3 & volume 3, no. 1), by: Zapopan Martín Muela-Meza (MEXICO)

 |full text  pdf | [English version]
Articles

 

The social class struggles concept with an interdisciplinary approach: a paramount concept for research in library and information science (LIS), by: Zapopan Martin Muela-Meza (MEXICO), p. 8.  
 
 |full text  pdf | [Original in English]
 

Abstract

 

This paper analyses the social class struggles concept with an interdisciplinary approach to be used by theorists and practitioners of library and information science (LIS). This concept emerged as part of the theoretical framework employed by the author in his doctoral thesis (Muela-Meza, 2010): An Application of Community Profiling to Analyse Community Information Needs, and Providers: Perceptions from the People of the Broomhall Neighbourhood of Sheffield, UK. This concept is complemented from philosophy (Marx and Engels, [1848] 1976a), and the natural sciences (Hauser, 2006; Sagan and Druyan, 1992), and it served the author to understand better the bigger dimensions of the underlying issues behind social classes and human conflicts. It also served to understand better the contradictions between people (e.g. LIS users with contradictory and mutually exclusive information needs to be provided by libraries and other institutions of information recorded in documents), and how these intensify when these are interrelated with the social class they belong to (Muela-Meza, 2007). This paper also criticises some competing views whose proponents by pretending fallaciously and deceitfully to deny the presence of social class divides in society, such as those rhetorical ploys of post-modernism that propose capitalist-class-driven ideologues of  “community cohesion” based on “social capital” (Putnam, 1999). It shows evidence of how those followers (e.g. Pateman, 2006; Contreras Contreras, 2004; Bryson, Usherwood and Proctor, 2003) of capitalist-class ideologues, by doing so they aligned their discourse to that of dominance hierarchies and hegemony against working class people, in LIS and other sciences, and the humanities. It also criticises the postmodern pseudoscience because it pretends to undermine the logical rationality fundamental in LIS and all other sciences. It recommends that LIS theorists and practitioners employ the social class struggles concept as configured here in order to understand better contradictions, conflicts, and struggles within LIS theory and practice, and also to search for broader epistemological aims such as justice and wisdom (Fleissner and Hofkirchner, 1998), concealed by the capitalist or bourgeois and middle classes for their benefit against working class.

 

Keywords

 

Sciences of Information Recorded in Documents; Library and Information Science (LIS) -- Epistemology; LIS -- Methodology; social class; social class struggles; dominance hierarchies; submission hierarchies; hegemony; critical and sceptical thinking; logical fallacies; rhetorical ploys.

 

Banning of reading in Cordoba (Argentina). Elements for its study, by: Federico Zeballos (ARGENTINA), p. 37.
 
  |full text  pdf | [Only in Spanish]
 

Abstract

 

This work “The banning of reading in Córdoba. Elements for its study” intents to provide elements for the knowledge about the mechanism of banning of reading in the Córdoba’s libraries during the recent past. Are presented several cases of censorship in different type of libraries: university, public, school, etc. Besides are included two cases of public burning of “banner books” in this city. The investigation has may testimonies of librarians, photographies, institutionals resolutions, regulations notes, etc. 

 

Keywords

 

Córdoba; reading; libraries; censorship; dictatorship; destruction of book; burning books; banned books.

 

Universidades, bibliotecas, imprentas y cárceles: espacios de educación, lectura y obra teórica del intelectual revolucionario del proletariado, por: Felipe Meneses Tello (MÉXICO), p. 52.

 
 |full text  pdf | [Only in Spanish]
 

Abstract

 

The author analyzes in this article (“Universities, libraries, presses, and jails: spaces of education, reading, and theoretical work of the revolutionary proletarian intellectual”) the main institutional (universities, libraries, presses, and jail) resources that revolutionary proletarian intellectuals have used throughout their lives to study, research, and produce a large number of bibliographic tools. In this way, instruction and theoretical possession by the proletarian intelligentsia can be thought about from a documentary context, characterized by specific situations: secrecy, persecution, imprisonment, and exile, among other possibilities.

 

Key Words

Intellectual revolutionaries, Proletariat, Universities, Libraries, Presses, Jails.

 

Ensayos

Tendencias conformistas en el discurso y en la realidad laboral de los bibliotecarios en México, por: José Ángel González Castillo; Carlos Alberto Martínez Hernández (MÉXICO), p. 64.

 
 |full text  pdf | [Only in Spanish]
 
 

Abstract

 

This paper criticizes a rooted tendency and attitude of conformism that has been exposed both in library practice and debate. It also criticizes the enthusiast acceptance of the dominant establishment and the active defense of capitalistic impositions that are systematically published in LIS documents, and implemented in library routinary strategies through all the levels of LIS practice. It also criticizes various LIS institutions ranging from the General Direction of Libraries of the Mexican National Network of Public Libraries, until the LIS schools that foster such conformist speech in LIS that tramples on labour rights, that triviliazes LIS curricula and that abandons this discipline in a theoretical and critical void.

 

Keywords

 

Mexico; Library and Information Science (LIS); conformist librarianship; pro-capitalistic driven librarianship; critique to capitalism; critique to conformist librarianship.

 

¿Y si el bibliotecario fuera académico? La problemática laboral de los bibliotecarios que trabajan en universidades públicas estatales, por: Horacio Cárdenas Zardoni (MÉXICO), p. 78.

 
 |full text  pdf | [Only in Spanish]
 
 

Abstract

 

The librarian is an important position for the functioning of libraries belonging to institutions of higher education. Library personnel is in charge of planning, organizing,  management, operation and giving information services  in the universities, it is a fundamental part of the teaching/learning process, in grade and postgraduate education, of the knowledge generation activities, and culture diffusion. The university librarian plays an instrumental part in the university curriculum, and a relevant role in the rhetoric of society of information/society of knowledge, offering from beginners instruction to specialized searches that facilitate the scientific work, technological development and contextualization of these in the academic information universe. Despite of all this and of being in charge of guarding, capitalization and exploitation of  important economic investments on  the part of the Government of the Republic and the institutions of higher education in Mexico, the librarian is not considered an academician, merely an administrative worker, without the recognition and advantages of the first, and without the betterment possibilities of the second.

 

Key words

 

University libraries; university librarians; librarians; academic personnel; administrative personnel; salary tabulators; universities; institutions of higher education.

 

Libros de la UNAM a través de Google: dos años después, por: Gonzalo Clemente Lara Pacheco (MÉXICO), p. 104.

 
 |full text  pdf | [Only in Spanish]
 

Abstract

 

Google corporation digitizes books published by the Mexico National Autonomous University (UNAM) since 2007. The corporation agreed not to charge anything for this service; instead, it was informed through some communication media that UNAM would be benefited in two senses: a) books could be consulted (just a few pages) in the site of Google books, and b) the university community would have access to the digitized titles, in full text versions, through the libraries of UNAM. As it will be shown, more than two years after this project began, UNAM community still does not have access to the full text version of the books published by UNAM that Google digitsize.

 

Keywords

 

Google, digital library, National Autonomous University of Mexico, agreements

 
Comments