Current Survey Tool stage: Vetting

CLDR v33.1 and v34 releases

• CLDR v34 will include all data collected in this year's contribution cycle. Please continue your good work in CLDR data and pay particular attention to Errors and disputes (Dashboard) in this Vetting stage. The data submission phases have ended. Thank you for your contribution in this version of CLDR.  
• CLDR v33.1 is now released.
  

What's new in this release

1. Import of old votes is automatically handled. All your votes matching the latest Approved data will be imported automatically upon first log in. If you expected to see your old votes, but do not see them after your first log in, file a ticket. 
• If you have voted previously, upon log-in, you will see a message showing the number of your votes that matched the currently winning votes that have been auto-imported. 
  
  
  
• You can still import old voted data that do not match the Approved data. Go to Setting (gear icon), under My Votes, then Import Old votes. You will need to review and select each of the losing items for import. Select All is not an option votes.
  
2. Browser support for Survey Tool now includes the latest versions of Edge, Safari, Chrome, and Firefox. Please report issues with the latest versions of any of the supported browsers. [#10396]
3. Emoji
1. Finding Emoji 11: The new emoji entries for version 11 use identifiers starting with "E11:" (see image). You can do a “Find on page” to move quickly from one to the next. You can also see the Emoji 11 Unicode chart for a full list. [#10997]
2. Emoji Images: The new emoji will not show properly in your browser. However, an image will show up in the right-hand panel: 
3. Keyword voting: The calculation of the winning set of keywords is now different. Beforehand, if you had the following choices, #1 would win. Now, the fact that #2 is a subset of #3 gives it a larger weight in voting, and #2 will win.
1. {small} : 4 votes
2. {big | large} : 3 votes
3. {big | large | grand} : 3 votes
4. Keyword de-duplication: If one keyword phrase is covered by other keyword phrases, then it will be removed. For example, the set {big bad wolf | big | bad | wolf} ⇒ {bad | big | wolf}. This will happen automatically as you enter values.
1. Note that the items in the set are also automatically alphabetized: {big | bad | wolf} ⇒ {bad | big | wolf}
5. Names included in keywords: The emoji names will get included as keywords automatically. You won't see this happen as you enter them since the name may change before the release is resolved. So this change is done later in data resolution, after the names are final. [#10537]
1. You do not need to enter the Emoji names as Keywords explicitly — but don't bother removing them if present (since that might artificially introduce voting conflicts).
2. Example: 
• Name: fox face
• Keywords: {face | fox}
• Final keyword in the released XML: {face | fox | fox face}
6. Make sure to read the Translation Guides below for more on emoji.
4. Priority Items: In a sublocale like French (Canada) [fr_CA], the dashboard values for Missing and Losing more accurate reflect what needs to be done. [#9505]
5. Long Date formats: We have found that many languages misused "dd" instead of "d". Please revisit your decision for Long date formats to determine correct use of "d" vs. "dd". [#10018]
6. Language-Specific Issues: Feedback on specific language data will be posted in language forums.
1. For German language only: For the purpose of CLDR data, we will be using the English terms "AM/PM" as the data. CLDR provides the flexibility to use the 12 hour format even for those language who strictly use 24 hour format. In case of German, the CLDR TCs have concluded to use the English words. [#10789]
2. For Odia language only: Do not use diacritics in transliterations. [#11044]
3. Please participate actively in Forum postings for language-specific data feedback from CLDR users, and postings by CLDR committee members. See Survey Tool Guide.
7. Old forum posts: Forum posts from previous contribution cycles are now available as one thread, and the version number where the posting came from are identified with the date and time stamp.  
   
   
   
8. Subdivisions. Three subdivisions are added in Locale Display Names / Territories (Europe), for England, Scotland, and Wales. For example, see French. When translating these, make sure to distinguish the name for “England” from the name for “United Kingdom”, which includes England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland.

Translation Guides

1. The translation guides for date/time patterns and names have been updated, focusing especially on the need to synchronize different name forms such as format and standalone with the patterns that use them, and different ways of utilizing the format and standalone name forms.
2. Timezone names and Territory names often share the same term. A list of overlapping data between Timezone and Territory names are available in this public spreadsheet. Use this spreadsheet as a reference when working on Timezone names, and bring consistency for Timezone names where they are also found in Territory names.
3. Many of the emoji names are constructed. The emoji parts that are used to construct and add on to other emoji are found in under Characters in the Survey Tool, under Component, People and Category. Please review these carefully!
1. Component contains special emoji whose names are used for emoji with hair colors and skin tones.
1. Carefully check all of these. Some languages still have older terms for the skin tones that won't mean anything to users. Use understandable terms like “light skin” instead of numbered levels like “peau 1”.
2. CLDR doesn't have gender agreement for nouns, so please try to choose the grammatical forms that work the best. For example, in some languages there will be an adjective for “light skinned” that would need to agree with the noun (man or woman). It may work to make noun phrases instead, eg “light skin” or “bald head”.
2. People contains three values which are used to construct emoji.
1. All of these have examples marked by an ⓔ in the English Column.
2. Hover over the ⓔ to see how some sample constructed emoji would look in English.
3. Hover over each translated term (Winning, Others) to see how some sample constructed emoji look in your language:
   
3. Category contains 3 terms like “flag” (used in constructing flag names). These 3 terms are also marked with ⓔ, so make sure to review each of the examples in English and your language.
4. People should not be overly purist about keywords. The goal is to match what people might search for, which does not necessarily follow formal taxonomies. For example, if a user is likely to type "plant" (or equivalent in their language) when searching for a mushroom, then the mushroom should have that keyword, even if that is not biologically accurate.
5. For the Character > Categories > Label (such as French), whether or not a label is plural will depend on the label and the language. The pluralization choice will not necessarily follow the English.

Known Issues

Resolved Issues

• Ticket 11143: Emoji keyword fields with more than 7 keywords throw errors. Workaround: For the time being, please ignore these error messages.
• Ticket 11133: The automatic import does not import in your old votes when the winning vote is on inheritance.  Workaround: Ignore these fields or import them in from the Import my votes page. 
  

To see the Flagged items, go to the Gear dropdown, under Forum see Flagged items:

Resolution

The vetting is done, and further work is being done by the CLDR committee to resolve problems. You should periodically take a couple of minutes to check your Forums to see if there are any questions about language-specific items that came up.