source: http://www.thehistoryofwwe.com/ecw96.htm

50 or more matches

Perry Saturn: 66 matches = 1-9-0 (singles) and 40-13-3 (tag)
Shane Douglas: 65 matches = 32-12-5 (singles) and 6-10-0 (tag)
John Kronus: 64 matches = 2-6-0 (singles) and 40-13-3 (tag)
Mikey Whipwreck: 62 matches = 21-31-0 (singles) and 4-6-0 (tag)
Buh Buh Ray Dudley: 62 matches = 12-13-0 (singles) and 19-16-2 (tag)
Tommy Dreamer: 61 matches = 13-15-2 (singles) and 21-10-0 (tag)
Pitbull #2: 60 matches = 20-13-3 (singles) and 10-12-2 (tag)
The Sandman: 59 matches = 22-15-2 (singles) and 13-7-0 (tag)
New Jack: 53 matches = 7-2-0 (singles) and 28-14-2 (tag)
Sabu: 51 matches = 28-3-8 (singles) and 2-7-3 (tag)
Taz: 50 matches = 42-1-3 (singles) and 4-0-0 (tag)
Raven: 50 matches = 31-6-1 (singles) and 1-11-0 (tag)

25 or more matches

2 Cold Scorpio: 47 matches = 18-12-9 (singles) and 2-6-0 (tag)
Mustafa: 46 matches = 0-2-0 (singles) and 28-14-2 (tag)
Brian Lee: 46 matches = 17-10-2 (singles) and 7-10-0 (tag)
Axl Rotten: 44 matches = 10-16-2 (singles) and 2-13-1 (tag)
Rob Van Dam: 41 matches = 16-9-4 (singles) and 2-7-3 (tag)
Stevie Richards: 39 matches = 9-15-0 (singles) and 1-13-1 (tag)
JT Smith: 39 matches = 5-8-1 (singles) and 9-15-1 (tag)
Hack Myers: 39 matches = 6-18-0 (singles) and 5-9-1 (tag)
D-Von Dudley: 30 matches = 5-8-1 (singles) and 2-13-1 (tag)
Louie Spicolli: 28 matches = 14-10-1 (singles) and 2-1-0 (tag)
Devon Storm: 28 matches = 2-19-0 (singles) and 3-3-1 (tag)
Little Guido: 26 matches = 1-9-0 (singles) and 8-8-0 (tag)
El Puerto Ricano: 26 matches = 2-14-2 (singles) and 0-7-1 (tag)
Bad Crew #2: 25 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 9-12-3 (tag)
Bad Crew #1: 25 matches = 1-0-0 (singles) and 9-12-3 (tag)

10 or more matches

Chris Jericho: 22 matches = 10-8-1 (singles) and 0-3-0 (tag)
Pitbull #1: 21 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 9-10-2 (tag)
Spike Dudley: 20 matches = 2-5-0 (singles) and 10-3-0 (tag)
Ron Harris: 17 matches = 1-0-0 (singles) and 9-6-1 (tag)
Don Harris: 17 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 9-6-1 (tag)
Terry Gordy: 14 matches = 3-3-0 (singles) and 5-3-0 (tag)
The Blue Meanie: 12 matches = 0-6-0 (singles) and 0-5-1 (tag)
Samu: 12 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-9-2 (tag)
GQ Gorgeous: 12 matches = 2-4-0 (singles) and 0-6-0 (tag)
Mack Daddy Kane/Rosie: 11 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-8-2 (tag)
Doug Furnas: 11 matches = 5-3-0 (singles) and 1-1-1 (tag)
Chris Candido: 11 matches = 7-2-1 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Headhunter B: 10 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 4-6-0 (tag)
Headhunter A: 10 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 4-6-0 (tag)

5 or more matches
Big Dick Dudley: 9 matches = 1-0-0 (singles) and 3-4-1 (tag)
Super Nova: 9 matches = 1-6-1 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Cactus Jack: 9 matches = 1-5-0 (singles) and 2-1-0 (tag)
Johnny Smith: 9 matches = 3-6-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
David Cash: 8 matches = 0-5-0 (singles) and 2-1-0 (tag)
Damien Stone: 7 matches = 0-4-0 (singles) and 1-1-1 (tag)
Francine: 7 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 3-4-0 (tag)
Tod Gordon: 6 matches = 0-4-0 (singles) and 0-2-0 (tag)
Damien Kane: 6 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 3-1-1 (tag)
Steve Williams: 6 matches = 3-0-0 (singles) and 0-3-0 (tag)
Dances with Dudley: 6 matches = 0-2-0 (singles) and 3-1-0 (tag)
Bill Alfonso: 6 matches = 4-0-0 (singles) and 2-0-0 (tag)
Mr. Hughes: 6 matches = 0-5-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Chris Chetti: 6 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-6-0 (tag)
Joel Hartgood: 5 matches = 1-1-0 (singles) and 0-3-0 (tag)
Damien 666: 5 matches = 0-4-1 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Beulah McGillicutty: 5 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 4-1-0 (tag)
Roadkill: 5 matches = 0-5-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Rick Rage: 5 matches = 0-3-0 (singles) and 0-2-0 (tag)
Billy Black: 5 matches = 0-2-0 (singles) and 1-2-0 (tag)

Several matches

Rey Mysterio Jr.: 4 matches = 2-1-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Balls Mahoney: 4 matches = 1-2-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Big Titan: 4 matches = 2-1-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Judge Dread: 4 matches = 2-1-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
The Dirt Bike Kid: 3 matches = 0-2-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Juventud Guerrera: 3 matches = 1-2-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Tarzan Goto: 3 matches = 3-0-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Spiros Grekko: 3 matches = 2-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Don E. Allen: 3 matches = 0-2-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Salvatore Bellomo: 3 matches = 1-0-0 (singles) and 0-2-0 (tag)
Jason Helton: 3 matches = 0-3-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Phil Lafon: 3 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-1-1 (tag)
Paul Varelans: 3 matches = 2-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
unknown: 2 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Tony Stetson: 2 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-1 (tag)
Jimmy Del Ray: 2 matches = 0-2-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
the Shark Attack Kid: 2 matches = 0-2-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Bam Bam Bigelow: 2 matches = 2-0-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Lori Fullington: 2 matches = 1-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Chad Austin: 2 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-2-0 (tag)
Prodigy: 2 matches = 0-2-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Jimmy Cicero: 2 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)

One Shot Stars
Paul Lauria: 1 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Konnan: 1 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Kendo Nagasaki: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Lady Alexandra: 1 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Rocco Rock: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Davey Pisano: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Keizo Matsuda: 1 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Gary Albright: 1 matches = 1-0-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
Missy Hyatt: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
911: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Johnny Grunge: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
LA Smooth: 1 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
A-Train: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Keisuke Yamada: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Big Guido: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Takashi Okano: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Mass Transit (Eric Kulas): 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Hollywood: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Terry Funk: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Chubby Dudley: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Dino Sendoff: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Chris Michaels: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
the Punisher: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Little John: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Beef Wellington: 1 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
the Studd: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 1-0-0 (tag)
Big John: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
Cody Michaels: 1 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-0-0 (tag)
O Dog: 1 matches = 0-0-0 (singles) and 0-1-0 (tag)
(tag)

SINGLE WINNERS:

Sabu: 28-3-8 (90%)

Losses:
ECW @ Bensalem, PA - Boomerang Nightclub - October 19, 1996 (325)
* 2 Cold Scorpio pinned Sabu

ECW @ Philadelphia, PA - ECW Arena - May 11, 1996 (1,000)
* Rob Van Dam pinned Sabu at 18:47

ECW @ Plymouth Meeting, PA - Lulu Temple - June 21, 1996 (400)
* Shane Douglas defeated Sabu via referee's decision when the match was stopped after Sabu sustained a neck injury

Taz: 42-1-3 (98%)

Sole "Loss" :
Big Ass Extreme Bash 96 - Philadelphia, PA - ECW Arena - March 9, 1996
(1,200)
Chris Jericho defeated Taz via disqualification at 6:00

Raven: 31-6-1 (84%)

5 losses to the Sandman and...

ECW @ Middletown, NY - Fairgrounds Fieldhouse - November 2, 1996 (700)
* Mikey Whipwreck defeated Raven

Chris Candido: 7-2-1 (78%)
Losses: 2 losses to RVD

New Jack: 7-2-0 (78%)
Losses: 2 losses to 2 Cold Scorpio

Bill Alfonso: 4-0-0 (100%)
Beat Tod Gordon four times.

Steve Williams: 3-0-0 (100%)
Beat Johnny Smith, Devon Storm and 2 Cold Scorpio.

Tarzan Goto: 3-0-0 (100%)
Beat Axl Rotten (2x) and Buh Buh Ray Dudley.

Bam Bam Bigelow: 2-0-0 (100%)
Beat Cactus Jack & Terry Gordy.

TAG WINNERS:

Eliminators (Perry Saturn & John Kronus): 40-13-3 [75%]
Losses to the Gangsters, Pitbulls & Francine, 911 & Rey Mysterio Jr and Dreamer & Terry Gordy

Spike Dudley (tagged with Buh Buh Ray Dudley): 10-3-0 [77%]
Losses to Eliminators (3x)

NOTABLE LOSERS:

Devon Storm: 28 matches = 2-19-0 (singles) and 3-3-1 (tag)
Did beat El Puerto Ricano (twice).

Little Guido: 26 matches = 1-9-0 (singles) and 8-8-0 (tag)
Beat Hack Myers.

El Puerto Ricano: 26 matches = 2-14-2 (singles) and 0-7-1 (tag)
Beat Super Nova

Mack Daddy Kane/Rosie: 11 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-8-2 (tag)
Samu: 12 matches = 0-1-0 (singles) and 0-9-2 (tag)
NEVER WON.

The Blue Meanie: 12 matches = 0-6-0 (singles) and 0-5-1 (tag)
NEVER WON.